BrainParrot

BRICS in a fragmented world order, a test of relevance

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 10 October 2026

Summary

  • The author reviews the 18th BRICS Summit (New Delhi, 12–13 Sept 2026). It unanimously adopted the New Delhi Declaration under India's chairship, which he credits to India's standing.
  • He then argues that the optics mask structural weakness. BRICS is subject to "variable geometry" and ad hoc coalitions, and its founding demands remain unmet.
  • He argues that China's growing preponderance and the India–China wariness risk making BRICS irrelevant, and that membership adds little extra strength for India.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — IR (bilateral/multilateral groupings; India's neighbourhood and China)

Key facts for Prelims

  • The 18th BRICS Summit was held in New Delhi on 12–13 September 2026 (India's fourth chairship). Earlier Indian chairships: 2012, 2016, 2021.
  • BRICS has 11 full members and a Partner Country category.
  • The first BRIC summit was at Yekaterinburg (Russia) in 2009. South Africa joined in 2011 (Sanya Summit).
  • Expansion: January 2024 added Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Saudi Arabia and the UAE. Indonesia joined in January 2025.
  • The New Development Bank (HQ Shanghai) and the Contingent Reserve Arrangement date from 2014 (Fortaleza).
  • BRICS Economic Partnership Strategy 2030 and the Global Value Chain Action Plan 2026–2030 are named in the Declaration, as reported in the editorial.
  • "Bretton Woods institutions" means the IMF and World Bank.
  • The WTO disputes-settlement reference in the editorial is a "two-tier" mechanism.

Data and details

  • Summit dates: 12–13 Sept 2026. Membership: 11. The Declaration was adopted unanimously.
  • The Declaration covered global governance reform, trade, finance, energy, climate, technology, health and agriculture.
  • It proposed local-currency trade and inter-operable cross-border payment systems.
  • It backed the BRICS Economic Partnership Strategy 2030 and a Global Value Chain Action Plan for 2026–2030.
  • It sought a more representative UN and international financial system. It supported de-escalation in West Asia and humanitarian access in Gaza.
  • It defended the WTO and rules-based trading, including a two-tier dispute settlement system.
  • It backed Palestinian self-determination and a just settlement under international law.
  • It contained detailed AI language: AI's growth potential, and cooperation on AI governance, computing access, research and skills.
  • PM Modi's inaugural call: BRICS leaders should draw up 10 global-governance reform proposals. His message was that if the future is shared, the right to shape it must be assured.
  • Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin attended. The UAE and Iran participated without mutual recriminations.
  • The editorial's critique:
  • The first BRIC summit was in 2009 (Yekaterinburg).
  • The original five members' demands (IMF, World Bank and UN reform) remain unfulfilled.
  • South–South cooperation and reduced dependence on Western finance are unfulfilled.
  • BRICS has not become an integrated economic bloc able to stand up to the "Bretton Woods Twins".
  • He compares BRICS to Europe's "coalition of the willing", arising from the "near demise" of NATO in Europe, as his analogy.
  • China's heft since 2009 has far eclipsed the others.
  • The author cites US President Trump's "kowtowing" to Xi during Xi's September 2026 Washington visit as evidence China is no longer a Global South member.
  • No serious India–China conflict since Galwan (2020), but ties remain uneasy despite calm.
  • The author says India need not fear the "Thucydides Trap" or Kindleberger's theories, but membership adds little political or economic strength.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • BRICS is an informal, summit-based grouping of major emerging economies. It has no founding treaty or charter, and its decisions are taken by consensus.
  • Its core agenda is to reform Bretton Woods institutions (IMF/World Bank) and the UN to give emerging economies more voice. This is the "multipolarity" and "strategic autonomy" strand of Indian foreign policy.
  • The editorial tests that claim against hard constraints. These are intra-group power asymmetry (China), unmet reform goals and global fragmentation.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: Bilateral, regional and global groupings and agreements; effect of policies of developed and developing countries on India's interests; international institutions and their mandates.

Background primer

BRICS

What it is:
A platform for consultation and cooperation on contemporary issues of global and regional significance, and on global political and economic governance.
Founded:
The acronym BRIC was coined by Goldman Sachs in 2001. BRIC was formally established in 2006 as a political cooperation forum among Brazil, Russia, India and China. The first BRIC Summit was held at Yekaterinburg, Russia, in 2009. South Africa's inclusion was agreed at the 2010 foreign ministers' meeting in New York. It attended the 3rd summit at Sanya in 2011.
Members:
11 countries: Brazil, China, Egypt, Ethiopia, India, Indonesia, Iran, Russia, Saudi Arabia, South Africa and the UAE. A major expansion began in January 2024 with Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Saudi Arabia and the UAE. Indonesia joined as the eleventh member in January 2025. A Partner Country category was created, and ten countries joined it in 2025: Belarus, Bolivia, Cuba, Kazakhstan, Malaysia, Nigeria, Thailand, Uganda, Uzbekistan and Vietnam.
Mandate:
Three pillars: political and security cooperation; economic and financial cooperation; and cultural and people-to-people exchanges.
Why it matters:
A more democratic, legitimate and balanced international order, with a stronger voice for emerging economies in global political and economic governance, including reform of the IMF, World Bank and UN.

Additional context

  • The 18th Summit's theme was "Building for Resilience, Innovation, Cooperation and Sustainability". It concluded with unanimous adoption of the New Delhi Declaration. The Declaration was a 140-point consensus document.
  • The BRICS Payment Task Force was tasked with advancing cross-border payment interoperability and settlement in local currencies, not with creating a single BRICS currency.
  • Members noted support for India's proposal to host a BRICS Risk Lab at GIFT City IFSC, Gujarat.
  • The Declaration condemned the 22 April 2025 terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir and called for adoption of the Comprehensive Convention on International Terrorism.
  • On UN reform, it recognised African aspirations (Ezulwini Consensus and Sirte Declaration). It also restated China's and Russia's support for the aspirations of Brazil and India.
  • UNCTAD data: intra-BRICS trade rose from about USD 84 billion in 2003 to about USD 1.17 trillion in 2024. China is the largest exporter and importer in intra-BRICS trade. This supports the editorial's China-imbalance argument.

Mains dimensions

  • Success case:
  • Consensus on a 140-point Declaration with Xi, Putin, the UAE and Iran in one room shows India's convening power.
  • It matches strategic autonomy, multi-alignment and multi-vector engagement.
  • The pragmatic agenda (local-currency settlement, AI, health, agriculture) moves BRICS from spectacle to substance.
  • Structural limits:
  • Founding demands (IMF/World Bank/UN reform) are unmet.
  • There is no integrated economic bloc.
  • The editorial's "variable geometry" and plurilateralism point shows ad hoc interest-based coalitions replacing alliances.
  • China factor:
  • China's economic dominance creates an intra-bloc imbalance. UNCTAD data show it as the biggest intra-BRICS trader.
  • China can no longer credibly claim Global South status.
  • India–China uneasiness after Galwan limits unity.
  • Expansion dilemma: the larger membership (11 plus partners) adds weight but makes consensus harder. Iran–UAE tensions are one test.
  • India's calculus: the editorial says membership adds no extra strength. A counter-view is that BRICS gives India a platform for Global South leadership and hedging, without which it would have less voice.
  • Way forward:
  • Focus on deliverables (payment interoperability, NDB lending, CRA).
  • Set clear membership criteria.
  • Keep BRICS "non-Western, not anti-Western", and keep Quad/G20 engagement alongside.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Despite consensus at the 2026 New Delhi Summit, BRICS faces internal imbalances and unfulfilled goals. Critically examine whether BRICS remains a relevant platform for advancing India's foreign policy objectives."

Related topics

  • New Development Bank and Contingent Reserve Arrangement
  • Reform of Bretton Woods institutions and UNSC reform (G4, Ezulwini Consensus)
  • India–China relations post-Galwan
  • Strategic autonomy and multi-alignment
  • WTO dispute settlement and the Appellate Body impasse
  • Global South and South–South cooperation

Topics: GS2Economy

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 10 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs