Ganga Water Treaty is flawed, needs to be updated: Bangladesh river expert
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 8 October 2026
Summary
- Manjur A. Chowdhury, former Chairman of Bangladesh's National River Conservation Commission, called the 1996 Ganga Water Treaty flawed. His complaints are that it has no guarantee clause, no environmental or ecological flow provision, and no climate-change factors. He wants a three-year interim treaty and then a researched trilateral treaty including Nepal.
- Former Bangladesh Foreign Secretary Farooq Sobhan, who negotiated the 1996 treaty, said the lack of an arbitration clause is a problem. He said India's promised barrage on the Padma in Bangladesh was never built.
- The treaty expires in December this year. Technical consultations are yet to be held, and in India the Bihar angle has emerged.
Key facts for Prelims
- Ganga Water Treaty: signed 12 December 1996, 30-year term, expires December 2026, dry season 1 January–31 May, at the Farakka Barrage.
- Farakka Barrage: built and operational in 1975 on the Ganga, in Murshidabad, West Bengal.
- Joint Rivers Commission (1972); Joint Committee monitors flows at Farakka and Hardinge Bridge.
- The 1996 treaty includes an emergency-consultation trigger below 50,000 cusecs. It has no arbitration clause (per Sobhan). Each side is assured 35,000 cusecs in alternate three 10-day periods between 11 March and 10 May, but commentators note it lacks a general guaranteed-minimum-flow clause as in the 1977 agreement.
- Nepal's rivers named: Ghaghara, Gandaki, Koshi, which carry Himalayan snowmelt into the Ganga.
- Padma is the name for the Ganga in Bangladesh. The Teesta river-sharing agreement remains unsigned.
- The earlier arrangements before 1996 were the 1977 agreement and interim arrangements of 1982 and 1985.
Data and details
- Treaty age: three decades. Expiry: December 2026.
- Chowdhury's proposal: a three-year short-term treaty first, then a better-researched trilateral treaty (India, Bangladesh, Nepal). His remarks to The Hindu came on Tuesday, a day after similar remarks at a Dhaka conclave.
- His criticisms: no guarantee clause; no ecological or environmental flow; no climate-change factors; the treaty "simply divides the water"; a good treaty should consider the "health of the river" to prevent over-exploitation.
- He says India treats the Ganga treaty as bilateral, though the Ghaghara, Gandaki and Koshi supply the lean-month flow and also need monitoring.
- Farooq Sobhan negotiated the treaty in 1996 under Hasina. He says the missing arbitration clause is a problem. India had promised a barrage on the Padma in Bangladeshi territory as the quid pro quo for omitting it, but it was not built. Bangladesh did surveys in the 1990s and received no help.
- Renewal discussions are ongoing in both countries, but important technical consultations are yet to be held.
- JD(U) MP Sanjay Jha asked the government not to renew, saying the treaty "negatively impacted" Bihar. On 28 August EAM S. Jaishankar replied that the Jal Shakti Ministry had led inter-ministerial consultations with stakeholders on the treaty's future.
Static–dynamic linkage
- India and Bangladesh share transboundary rivers. They share 54, but agreements exist only for the Ganga and two other rivers, and none for others such as the Teesta. The Ganga treaty is therefore the cornerstone of bilateral water cooperation.
- The core principle in transboundary-river law is equitable and reasonable use without causing significant harm. A formula-based division, as Chowdhury says, may ignore the river's ecological needs.
- Nepal matters because Himalayan tributaries (Ghaghara, Gandaki, Koshi) supply dry-season snowmelt to the Ganga, which makes the basin management trilateral in hydrology even if the treaty is bilateral.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: India and neighbourhood, bilateral agreements; GS1 – Geography: Ganga drainage and its tributaries; GS3 – Environment: environmental flows, climate change and rivers.
Background primer
Ganga (Ganges) Water Treaty, 1996
- What it is:
- a bilateral treaty governing the sharing of Ganga waters at Farakka between India and Bangladesh during the dry season.
- Founded:
- signed on 12 December 1996 for 30 years, renewable by mutual consent. It was signed during Sheikh Hasina's first term as Bangladesh PM. It replaced short-term arrangements such as the 1977 agreement.
- Mandate:
- distribution during the dry season, 1 January to 31 May, through a ten-day sharing schedule based on historical average flows.
- Why it matters:
- predictable, formula-based sharing, equity and no-harm principles, and salinity control for the Bhagirathi–Hooghly (Kolkata Port).
Additional context
- The Farakka Barrage lies on the Ganga in Murshidabad district, West Bengal.
- After suspending the Indus Waters Treaty, India was reported to be exploring a review of the Ganges treaty. One report said India wanted an additional 30,000–35,000 cusecs in the lean season for irrigation, port maintenance and power.
- Bihar has sought that its projected water needs up to 2050, scientific silt management and greater representation of affected states be considered in any revision.
- The Parliamentary Standing Committee on External Affairs (report of 18 December 2025) suggested beginning bilateral discussions on the treaty.
- Officials of both countries have reportedly begun joint water-level measurements on the Ganga and Padma every 10 days until 31 May.
- Status of talks: the Standing Committee report (December 2025) noted that formal renewal discussions had not yet commenced. The Hindu report says discussions are ongoing in both countries but key technical consultations are still pending.
Mains dimensions
- Treaty design gaps: no guarantee or arbitration clause, no ecological flow, no climate provisions. A pure volume-division model ages badly as flows change.
- Lower-riparian anxiety: the barrage promise unfulfilled (the quid pro quo for no arbitration clause) feeds a perception of asymmetry. Lean-season stress in northern Bangladesh and the ecologically fragile Sundarbans delta raise the stakes.
- Basin approach: Nepal's contribution to lean-season flows makes a trilateral framework hydrologically sensible. It also complicates diplomacy, since India has traditionally preferred bilateral deals.
- Domestic federal stakes: Bihar's siltation and flood concerns, and the Jha letter, show that renewal involves states. The Jal Shakti-led consultation is the Centre's response.
- Strategic context: renewal comes alongside the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance and the unsettled Teesta. India's own position as an upper riparian on the Ganga and a lower riparian on the Brahmaputra calls for consistent water diplomacy.
- Way forward: an interim renewal to avoid a legal vacuum, joint scientific data, environmental-flow and climate clauses, a dispute-settlement mechanism, and a Teesta settlement for trust.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Ganga Water Treaty of 1996 is due to expire in December 2026. Discuss the shortcomings of the treaty and the considerations India should weigh in renewing or renegotiating it with Bangladesh."
Related topics
- Indus Waters Treaty and India's changed-circumstances argument
- Teesta river dispute; India–Bangladesh border and connectivity agreements
- Farakka Barrage, Bhagirathi–Hooghly, Sundarbans delta
- Transboundary river principles (equitable use, no-harm); Brahmaputra and China
- Cross-reference: Cauvery distress-sharing dispute (domestic inter-State analogue)
Topics: GS2Geography
All current affairs of 8 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs