Left off poll rolls, 4 West Bengal men detained for a month in Chhattisgarh
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 7 October 2026
Summary
- Four migrant workers from Murshidabad, West Bengal, were held in a Raipur detention centre for over a month. Chhattisgarh Police suspected they were Bangladeshi nationals. They had been deleted from the voters' list during SIR, and the police cited this deletion in court to question their nationality.
- Their 19 co-detainees were released after the local court's order, once their names reappeared on the rolls after adjudication.
- In Bengaluru, lakhs of SIR notices are pending hearing, while in Hyderabad MP Asaduddin Owaisi alleged bulk, pre-filled Form 7 deletions.
Key facts for Prelims
- RP Act 1950: Section 16 (non-citizen, unsound mind, or disqualified under law relating to corrupt practices cannot be registered); Section 21 (preparation and revision of rolls); Section 22 (correction/deletion of entries by ERO); Section 23 (inclusion of names).
- Section 23(3): no amendment, deletion or inclusion can be made after the last date for nominations until the election is complete.
- Form 7: objection to inclusion / deletion of an entry. Form 6: inclusion (new elector). Form 8: correction of entries.
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: Form 7 is filed under Rules 13(2) and 26.
- Foreigners Act, 1946: Section 2(a) defined "foreigner"; Section 9 placed the burden of proof on the person; the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 was made under Section 3. The Act has since been repealed by the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025.
- Article 326: franchise to citizens aged 18+.
- ERO = Electoral Registration Officer; AERO = Assistant ERO; BLO = Booth Level Officer.
Data and details
- Four men: Sabir Sheikh (42), Safikul Islam (39), Nasiruddin Sheikh (35) and Laltu Sheikh (28), from Samserganj and Sahabad areas, Murshidabad.
- At least 23 migrant workers went to Chhattisgarh in late August. On 4 September the police detained 23 persons from their residences in Chunchiapara-Ganesh Nagar and took them to a holding centre for illegal immigrants in Raipur.
- Nineteen were released on 18 September after a local court order. The four stayed in the detention centre for over a month.
- In court the police questioned their nationality on the basis of the SIR deletion. The other 19 found their names back on the rolls after adjudication.
- Safikul's father Riyajul Sheikh (67) says the family has lived in Samserganj for generations. Their century-old house was washed away by soil erosion and the new residence was set up in 1973.
- Remedies in motion: an appeal to the tribunal for restoring names, and a petition by family in the Calcutta High Court for release.
- Hearings on SIR notices are scheduled to conclude by 12 October.
- More than 3.70 lakh of the 6.66 lakh notices pending hearing statewide are in Bengaluru, per Special Commissioner (Election) Shilpa Nag C.T.
- More than 24 lakh notices were issued in Bengaluru for logical discrepancies and for being unmapped. Only 13,550 are yet to be delivered.
- BLOs will visit houses and collect documents; hearings are online only in some cases.
- 1,117 AEROs have been appointed for hearings, in addition to 76 regular AEROs.
- Asaduddin Owaisi alleged that numerous pre-filled Form 7 applications seeking deletion were submitted in Goshamahal constituency, which is part of the Hyderabad Lok Sabha seat.
- Example: 122 Form 7 applications at Booth 28. He called them pre-printed, part of a deliberate move to remove minority voters, and named the filer as one Janardhan, "BJP supporter or sympathiser", and sought action against him. (These are allegations.)
Static–dynamic linkage
- Voter-roll inclusion and citizenship are legally different questions. The ECI can check citizenship only to decide enrolment. Declaring someone a foreigner is for the statutory competent authority.
- When a roll deletion is treated by police as proof of foreign nationality, the two are conflated. The result is prolonged custody pending slow tribunal or court processes.
- The burden-of-proof rule in foreigner cases makes this especially harsh for poor, documentation-poor migrants.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Representation of the People Act, 1950 (electoral rolls, Sections 16, 21–23); Art. 326; Citizenship Act; GS2 – Governance: due process, quasi-judicial bodies; vulnerable groups (migrant workers).
Background primer
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- A focused, time-bound ECI exercise to update and verify electoral rolls. Booth Level Officers (BLOs) do house-to-house verification.
Form 7 and deletion
- What it is:
- An application objecting to inclusion of a name or seeking deletion of a name in the electoral roll.
Foreigners Tribunals (FTs) and burden of proof
- What it is:
- Quasi-judicial bodies that determine whether a person is a foreigner or an Indian citizen. They were formed by the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 under Section 3 of the Foreigners Act, 1946.
Additional context
- In its May 2026 SIR verdict (ADR v. ECI), the Supreme Court upheld the SIR under Art. 324 read with Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950. It ordered the ECI to refer all persons deleted on citizenship grounds to the competent authority within four weeks, with restoration of voting rights if they are found to be citizens.
- The Court held that a deletion on citizenship grounds does not mean the ECI has declared the person a non-citizen; it only means the ECI was "unable to be satisfied" for electoral purposes.
Mains dimensions
- Roll deletion ≠ citizenship loss:
- The SC has held that deletion on citizenship grounds only means the ECI was unable to be satisfied for electoral purposes.
- Yet in Raipur a deletion became the police's ground to question nationality, and the men spent over a month in a detention centre.
- The contrast within the group shows the stakes: 19 whose names reappeared on the rolls were released, and 4 whose appeals were pending were not.
- Reverse burden of proof and vulnerability: Migrant labourers lack stable documents and cannot appear in two states at once. Under the foreigner-proof regime the onus falls on them, and a pending tribunal appeal does not stop custody. Soil erosion washing away a family home, as in this case, shows how natural disasters destroy documentary trails.
- Federal and inter-state coordination: A West Bengal voter was held by Chhattisgarh Police on a roll-based doubt. There is no clear mechanism for verification between ERO, police and tribunal across states.
- Capacity strain in SIR: In Bengaluru, over half of the pending notices statewide, 3.70 lakh of 6.66 lakh, are in one city, with a 12 October deadline. Only some hearings are online, so notice delivery, document collection and hearing capacity risk procedural exclusion.
- Integrity of the objection mechanism:
- Form 7 allows any registered elector to seek deletion of another's name. The safeguards are the objector's onus, a declaration with a penalty for false statements, and ERO inquiry with a hearing.
- Owaisi's bulk pre-filled-forms allegation tests whether these safeguards bite. It points to the case for audits of bulk filings and prosecution for false objections.
- Way forward:
- Time-bound referral of citizenship doubts to the competent authority.
- Prior verification with the ERO before police act on roll data.
- Release on bond during pending appeals.
- Public deletion lists with reasons.
- Document-light enrolment of migrants, including portability of enrolment.
Possible Mains question
**GS Paper II, 15 marks:** "Electoral-roll revision and citizenship determination are distinct legal processes, but recent SIR-linked incidents show them blurring in practice. Discuss the implications for the rights of migrant workers and suggest institutional safeguards."
Related topics
- Citizenship Act, 1955; NRC and Assam; Foreigners Tribunals; Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025
- Art. 21 and preventive/administrative detention; due process
- Art. 326, RP Act 1950 vs 1951; ERO/BLO structure
- Internal migrants: portability of entitlements, One Nation One Ration Card
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 7 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs