BrainParrot

Why are States divided over the mining amendment?

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 6 October 2026

Summary

  • Parliament passed the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Act, 2026. It widens the Centre's regulatory control to mineral-bearing lands and bars States from imposing fresh taxes on mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands, except as the Union prescribes.
  • It also cancels mineral taxes that States imposed but had not fully collected before commencement.
  • States are split. Karnataka, Telangana, Himachal Pradesh and Kerala plan to challenge it in the Supreme Court. Jharkhand has objected strongly. The BJP-led Odisha government says its revenue is not hurt, and Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh have made no comparable challenge so far.

UPSC relevance: GS2/GS3 — Polity: Centre-State relations, fiscal federalism; Economy: mining and natural-resource taxation

Key facts for Prelims

  • Entry 23, State List: regulation of mines and mineral development, subject to Union law. Entry 54, Union List: Parliament's regulation of mines and mineral development to the extent it declares expedient in the public interest.
  • Entry 50, State List: taxes on mineral rights, subject to limits imposed by Parliament by law relating to mineral development. Entry 49, State List: taxes on lands and buildings (includes mineral-bearing land per the 2024 ruling). Land itself is Entry 18, State List.
  • MMDR Amendment Act, 2026 inserts Section 9D (limits on State levies) and extends the Centre's regulatory reach to "mineral-bearing lands". Section 13 gets rule-making powers.
  • Mineral Area Development Authority v. Steel Authority of India (2024): 9-judge Bench; royalty is not a tax; States can tax mineral rights and land subject to constitutional limits.
  • The Act is an instance of Centre-State friction. The article lists earlier flashpoints: GST compensation, Finance Commission terms of reference, National Education Policy, CAA, and proposed amendments to All-India Services rules.

Data and details

  • Mineral receipts as share of non-tax revenue: Jharkhand 85%, Odisha 80%, Karnataka 48%, Madhya Pradesh 41%, Rajasthan 39%, Telangana 11%, Chhattisgarh 6%.
  • Four States (Karnataka, Telangana, Himachal Pradesh, Kerala) are planning an SC challenge.
  • Kerala's additional argument: treating mineral-bearing land this way gives the Centre wider power over coastal and forest areas.
  • Jharkhand's Chief Minister warned that lost revenue could hit social-security schemes benefitting millions, because the Act renders some uncollected past dues invalid.
  • Odisha: the Opposition demanded a special Assembly session, which the BJP State government rejected. It argues the Act will not harm the State's revenues, so there is no unified State position despite 80% dependence.
  • Telangana (11% dependence) is among the non-NDA States intending to approach the SC, showing that dependence alone does not predict challenge.
  • No comparable challenge so far from Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan or Chhattisgarh.
  • The Centre's argument: uneven, multiple State taxes raise mineral costs, push industry toward imports and burden the exchequer.
  • Impact of the Act: unrecovered past dues are invalidated, which hits potential revenue sources and narrows prospective mineral revenue for major mineral-bearing States.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The Seventh Schedule splits control of mines and minerals. States regulate mines and mineral development under Entry 23 of the State List, but this is subject to Union law under Entry 54 of the Union List. That entry lets Parliament decide how far it will control mining regulation in the public interest.
  • States have taxing power over land (Entry 49) and mineral rights (Entry 50) in the State List. Entry 50 is expressly subject to limits imposed by Parliament through a law relating to mineral development.
  • The 2026 amendment uses the Centre's regulatory power to restrict State taxation. The dispute therefore moves from regulation to the fiscal autonomy of mineral-rich States, and from "who regulates" to "who taxes".
  • The Supreme Court's 2024 position is that States can tax mineral rights, subject to Parliament's limits. Their power to tax mineral-bearing land cannot be curtailed through Entry 54. The article says the amendment contradicts this.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Centre-State legislative and financial relations (Seventh Schedule, Part XI–XII); federal structure and fiscal autonomy; GS3 — Economy: resource mobilisation, mining sector and investment climate.

Background primer

Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957

What it is:
The central law regulating mining. Mineral concessions (prospecting licences, mining leases) are granted by State governments under rules and auction processes set by the Centre. The Centre also fixes royalty rates, which States collect from lessees.
Founded:
Enacted in 1957 under Entry 54 (Union List) after the Constitution came into force.
Members:
Not a body. A framework statute with the Centre and States as co-actors. The Centre regulates major minerals (coal, iron ore, bauxite), while minor minerals (building stones, gravel, ordinary clay) are regulated by States.
Mandate:
Regulation of mines and development of minerals in the public interest.
Why it matters:
National control of strategic minerals, with revenue and local administration through States.

Fiscal federalism in India (Seventh Schedule)

What it is:
A federal scheme in which the Centre has the larger tax base and States carry large expenditure responsibilities. The article calls it asymmetric.
Mandate:
The Union also shapes State finances through borrowing limits and transfers.
Why it matters:
A balance between national uniformity and State autonomy, mediated by the Finance Commission and the Seventh Schedule.

Additional context

  • MADA v. SAIL (2024): A 9-judge Constitution Bench held 8:1 in July 2024 that States can tax mineral rights (Entry 50) and mineral-bearing land (Entry 49). It also held that royalty is not a tax but a payment arising from the contractual obligation to enjoy mineral rights. It noted that State power over mineral rights can be limited by an Act of Parliament, but the MMDR Act, 1957 did not place any such restriction. The Court allowed tax demands from 1 April 2005, with phased payment.
  • What the Act does: A new Section 9D bars a State from imposing any tax, cess or other levy on mineral rights or mineral-bearing lands. Section 13 is amended so the Centre can frame rules specifying the parameters for future State levies. Unpaid or unrecovered earlier State levies are deemed invalid, but amounts already deposited or recovered are not refunded.
  • Government's case: States currently impose around 14 taxes, charges and fees on mining, including royalty, auction premium, dead rent, DMF payments, GST and transit fee. Some States have also taxed mineral-bearing lands at rates as high as 20 percent. The Centre says States have collected ₹2.32 lakh crore in royalty from 1,200 working mines since 2015, plus ₹96,000 crore in auction premium from 100 auctioned mines. It says minor minerals remain under State control.
  • Legal critique (PRS): Entry 54 is a general regulatory power, and Parliament's power to limit tax operates only on mineral rights (Entry 50), not on land (Entry 49). The retrospective scheme treats miners differently depending on whether they had paid, which may violate Art. 14. PRS also flags that it may negate the Supreme Court's 2024 directions.

Mains dimensions

  • Constitutional questions: Is Parliament's power under Entry 50 (limits on taxing mineral rights) wide enough for a near-total bar? The land-tax limit under Entry 49 is a different question, because the SC said Entry 54 cannot curb it. Does legislative reversal of a Constitution Bench ruling respect separation of powers? A legislature can remove the legal basis of a judgment, but it cannot simply overrule it.
  • Retrospectivity and equality: Invalidating unpaid dues, while refunds are denied for paid ones, treats similarly placed miners differently.
  • Delegation: The Union will prescribe the conditions for future State levies. This is a question of excessive delegation, since the Act hands the key policy content to rules.
  • Fiscal federalism: An asymmetric structure already leaves States with expenditure burdens and the Centre with larger taxes, borrowing and transfer control. Reduced own-revenue autonomy worsens this for mineral-rich States, especially Jharkhand and Odisha.
  • Politics of federal challenge: Material stake (revenue dependence) interacts with political alignment (NDA vs. non-NDA) in deciding which States litigate.
  • Economic rationale vs. federal balance: Tax uniformity, investment certainty and import reduction vs. State autonomy and local compensation. The way forward could be a Centre-State consensus through the GST Council-type mechanism or the Finance Commission, and strengthening DMFs for affected communities.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Act, 2026 has reopened the debate on fiscal federalism. Examine the constitutional issues involved and suggest a cooperative way forward."

Related topics

  • Seventh Schedule (Union/State/Concurrent Lists), Arts. 245–254, 268–293
  • Finance Commission and GST Council (cooperative federalism)
  • District Mineral Foundations; National Mineral Exploration Trust
  • State of West Bengal v. Kesoram, India Cement and earlier "royalty vs. tax" case law
  • Basic structure: federalism; Doctrine of separation of powers

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 6 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs