BrainParrot

Two or three?

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 5 October 2026

Summary

  • The editorial argues that the Supreme Court's repeated interventions are exposing aspects of CBSE's three-language policy that the Board does not seem to have thought through.
  • In its latest ruling, the Court said current Class 6 students should get the same relief as Classes 7, 8 and 9. For those classes the final Class 10 exam in the third language will be an internal assessment, not a Board exam.
  • The editorial's own position: English is a de facto Indian language, and the best policy is two languages (English + mother tongue). A third language of the student's choice should be tested only by internal assessment.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity/Governance: Education policy, federalism, role of judiciary; GS1 — Society: language and diversity

Key facts for Prelims

  • Three-language formula: first formally proposed by the Kothari Commission (1964–66); present in NEP 1968, 1986, 1992 and 2020.
  • NEP 2020 + NCF-SE 2023 are the policy bases for CBSE's language scheme.
  • Eighth Schedule: 22 scheduled languages. Art. 350A: mother-tongue instruction at the primary stage. Art. 351: directive for the promotion of Hindi.
  • Education is a Concurrent List subject.
  • CBSE is an autonomous organisation under the Ministry of Education.
  • R3 (third language) is assessed through school-based internal assessment for the exempted batches, and by Board exam for Class VI 2026–27 and later batches.

Data and details

  • The Court's latest ruling extends to current Class 6 the relief given to Classes 7, 8 and 9, whose Class 10 third-language assessment is internal and not a Board exam.
  • The Court had earlier asked whether the policy could start from 2027, not 2026.
  • English has been in use in India for at least 300 years, per the editorial. It is the leading language of education, courts and professions, and a preferred link language.
  • The Court also mooted whether English should be treated as indigenous, which puts its "foreign language" categorisation in question.
  • NEP 2020, though it advocates two Indian languages, also stresses learning foreign languages to help Indians' global mobility for employment.
  • The Hindu's reporting (cited by the editorial) shows English, being the medium of instruction in other subjects, will become the only "foreign language" students take in CBSE schools.
  • Many schools will keep Sanskrit as the second Indian language up to Class 10, with Hindi first. Some southern schools will continue with the regional language (Tamil, Kannada) as the other Indian language.
  • Practical consequence: Spanish, French and other foreign languages are being removed from schools.
  • CBSE "stubbornly resisted compromise" at various stages. The Court earlier warned that learning a new language suddenly in Class 9 is disruptive for students who had not studied a second Indian language until Class 8.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Education is on the Concurrent List, so the Centre (through NEP 2020 and CBSE) and the States both have a say. Language policy therefore sits at the intersection of federalism, cultural diversity and individual choice.
  • The constitutional anchors for the language question are the Eighth Schedule (22 scheduled languages), Art. 343/351 (Hindi as official language and its development), Art. 350A (mother-tongue instruction at the primary stage) and Art. 29(1) (right to conserve one's language and culture). These are stable textbook provisions.
  • The Court is acting as a calibrator, not a final decider. It is testing preparedness, proportionality and the impact on students. This is the "reasonableness of executive action" lens in Indian administrative and constitutional law.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity/Governance: Government policies and interventions in education; judicial review and judicial activism; Centre-State relations (GS2). GS1 — Society: diversity, language and regionalism.

Background primer

Three-Language Formula

What it is:
an education-policy formula under which students learn three languages, intended to promote national integration and linguistic diversity.
Founded:
proposed by the Kothari Commission (1964–66). It was incorporated in the 1968 policy (Hindi, English and a regional language), retained in 1986 and 1992, and kept in NEP 2020 with more flexibility in language choice.
Mandate:
the CBSE guidelines align the scheme of studies with the National Education Policy 2020 and the National Curriculum Framework for School Education 2023.
Why it matters:
multilingualism, cultural understanding and, in the editorial's reading of the Court's view, strengthening the federal structure through learning more Indian languages.

CBSE

What it is:
an autonomous organisation under the Ministry of Education, Government of India. It frames the scheme of studies and conducts Class 10/12 Board exams for affiliated schools.

Additional context

  • CBSE's rollout design. The CBSE guidelines apply from the 2026–27 academic session. For the earlier batches, the third language (R3) is assessed only by the school, with no Board exam for it. The Class VI 2026–27 batch and later Class VI batches take a Board exam in R3 when they reach Class X. R3 performance is reflected in the CBSE certificate, and no student is barred from the Class 10 Board exam because of R3.
  • One-time relaxation. Class IX students in 2026–27 who study two non-native languages (e.g. English + French) may continue with them and add one Bhartiya Bhasha as the third language.
  • Preparedness. CBSE refers to dedicated R3 textbooks for Class VI in the 22 scheduled Bhartiya Bhashas. Earlier reporting flagged a shortage of language teachers and appropriate textbooks in schools.
  • Court proceedings. The Court was hearing challenges to the policy but had not stayed it. Petitioners cited language as a personal choice and questioned CBSE's authority to impose the mandate without legislative backing. On September 17 the Court asked CBSE to consider applying the three-language mandate for Class 6 from the 2027 session. One summary reports the Court suggested mandatory application for Class 6 from January 1, 2027.
  • Centre's stand. The Solicitor General said about 99% of schools had adopted the policy and about 1.2% had not, and the Centre was not inclined to exempt the current Class 6 batch. Justice Bagchi suggested deferring implementation for current Class 6 students to give CBSE time to put infrastructure in place.
  • Bench. The bench comprised Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana.

Mains dimensions

  • Judicial role / calibration. The Court is not striking down the policy. It is pointing out pitfalls and softening rough edges: relief for Classes 7–9, the query on a 2027 start, and the extension to Class 6. This shows courts testing proportionality, preparedness and student welfare in executive policy. Critics may call it overreach into academic policy; supporters call it a check on abrupt implementation.
  • Federalism and cultural diversity. The Court saw merit in learning more Indian languages to strengthen the federal structure. The editorial doubts that cross-regional learning will actually happen: schools will default to Hindi + Sanskrit, and southern-State schools to Tamil or Kannada. The result may be a formula that is nominally pan-Indian but in practice reinforces existing regional defaults.
  • English as a de facto Indian language. The editorial's case rests on its 300-year presence, its role in courts, professions and education, and its role as a link language. It also rests on India's competitive edge in global industries such as IT and the government's reliance on global jobs as a route to prosperity.
  • Internal tension in NEP 2020. NEP 2020 pushes two Indian languages but also recognises foreign-language learning for mobility. The CBSE rules, as reported, push foreign languages out.
  • Opportunity cost and pedagogy. A late third-language start (Class 9) can disrupt learning. An internal assessment lowers stakes but does not resolve teacher and textbook readiness.
  • Policy process. The editorial says CBSE did not think through the aspects the Court is flagging. This points to the need for consultation, piloting and phased rollout in education reform, which was also raised in the petitioners' concern about the absence of legislative backing.
  • Way forward (editorial's view). Adopt a two-language policy (English + mother tongue), and test a third language of the student's choice through internal assessment only.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The three-language formula has been a recurring source of tension between national integration and linguistic autonomy. In the light of recent judicial interventions on the CBSE's language policy, critically examine the formula's relevance and the challenges in its implementation."

Related topics

  • Kothari Commission and National Policy on Education 1968/1986/1992; NEP 2020 and NCF-SE 2023
  • Eighth Schedule, Art. 343–351 (Language provisions), Art. 29 and 30 (cultural and educational rights)
  • Concurrent List and Centre-State relations in education; Navodaya Vidyalayas and language politics
  • Judicial review of executive policy; doctrine of proportionality

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 5 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs