BrainParrot

SIR made so many eligible electors lose vote for the first time, says former CEC

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 1 October 2026

Summary

  • Former CEC O.P. Rawat told The Hindu that this is the first time since Independence that so many eligible electors have lost their right to vote in a revision. He said ECs Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi should have had every decision taken against their will annulled at the next meeting, rather than stopping at dissent notes.
  • On Wednesday a full bench of the EC (the second such meeting in four days) extended the dates for final rolls in Andhra Pradesh and Meghalaya, where SIR is under way.
  • In Belagavi (Karnataka), pre-filled bulk Form-7 deletion applications targeting Muslim names surfaced at polling stations.
  • In West Bengal, a retired judge heading an SIR appellate tribunal offered to resign over his long commute.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Elections, Election Commission, electoral rolls, quasi-judicial redress

Key facts for Prelims

  • SIR: Section 21(3) RP Act, 1950 + Article 324; objective "no eligible left out, no ineligible included".
  • ERO (SDM-level) per Assembly constituency; BLO per polling station; BLA = party's Booth Level Agent.
  • Form 6 (+ Declaration Form) = enrolment; Form 7 = deletion/objection.
  • Sections 16 and 19 of RP Act, 1950: disqualification (e.g., non-citizens) and qualification (18+, ordinarily resident).
  • Article 326: universal adult suffrage. Article 329(b): bar on courts in electoral matters during elections.
  • EC decisions by majority where members differ; CEC has no veto.
  • The Bengal SIR has 19 appellate tribunals, headed by retired judges, set up after the SC's 10 March 2026 order.
  • Voter categories in Bengal SIR: mapped, unmapped, logical discrepancy.

Data and details

  • Rawat headed the EC from 23 January 2018 to 1 December 2018 and had been an Election Commissioner since 2015. The current three-member Commission: CEC Gyanesh Kumar, ECs Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi.
  • Sandhu and Joshi formally objected to aspects of SIR 14 times over 10 months. Objections covered several EC decisions, including changes to Form 6 and a declaration added on the ECINet portal asking new voters whether they, their parents or grandparents appeared in the last SIR roll.
  • Rawat: with the majority, they should have annulled decisions at the very next meeting when their first objections went unheard. He said that deadlock in the EC is a "one in a million" occasion, and that the CEC "does not have any veto".
  • On Bengal: "damage had already been done before the election". 93% of deleted voters whose appeals tribunals have decided were found eligible and missed voting.
  • Andhra Pradesh: final roll now 16 October (earlier 3 October); claims and objections extended to 10 October.
  • Meghalaya: final roll now 26 October (earlier 7 October).
  • Attended by CEC Gyanesh Kumar, Sandhu and Joshi, the second full-bench meeting in four days.
  • Sources: the Commission also reviewed measures announced on 26 September, including stopping physical hearings for voters flagged under "unmapped" or "logical discrepancy" categories.
  • BLA Meersab Sanadi, 15 years a BLA at polling station 196 in Belagavi North, found at least 380 Form-7 applications at Veerabhadra Urdu Model School seeking deletion of his own, his brother's, relatives' and neighbours' names.
  • Seen in at least six polling stations in Belagavi North: parts 194, 195, 196, 199 (Veerabhadra Nagar) and 209, 210 (Government Kannada Higher Primary School, Shettigali).
  • Two men claiming to be from the Belagavi City Corporation brought forms already printed, seeking deletion of Muslim names only. Voter details were pre-filled; objectors' names were handwritten or blank.
  • When BLOs refused, the men phoned someone who posed as ERO Udayakumar Basavantappa Talawar and instructed them to sign. ERO Talawar says his name was falsely used and he gave no such instructions. Some BLOs signed under pressure; others could not reach supervisors or the AERO.
  • In Bhalki, bulk Form-7 filings continued after the claims and objections period ended on 23 September. Applications filed after that will be taken up only after the final roll is published.
  • Justice Indrajit Chatterjee (retd), Calcutta HC, presides over SIR tribunal no. 11 in Murshidabad. He has asked Calcutta HC Chief Justice Ravindra Vithalrao Ghuge to let him discontinue from 2 November, citing a 70–80 km commute taking three to four hours a day with a pilot car. He said another judge is also likely to resign.
  • His tribunal covers a district where about 4.55 lakh electors were deleted.
  • About 27.1 lakh voters were removed in Bengal for "logical discrepancies" before the Assembly election this year. Over 22 lakh have appealed, per the EC's affidavit in the Supreme Court.
  • 19 retired judges were appointed to the tribunals, and 19 resigned in May this year, including former Calcutta HC Chief Justice T.S. Sivagnanam. The EC constituted 19 tribunals in total.

Static–dynamic linkage

The right to vote (Art. 326) depends on being on the electoral roll. The roll is prepared and revised by the EC through the ERO/BLO machinery under the RP Act, 1950, and a revision is only as fair as its checks against wrongful exclusion. These stories show the checks being tested. Inside the EC, a collegial three-member body is only meaningful if dissent has consequences. At the field level, Form 7 is open to misuse unless officers verify it. At the appellate level, tribunals are the last safeguard against wrongful deletion, and they depend on judges who are willing and able to sit.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Election Commission and electoral rolls (Art. 324, 326; RP Act 1950); statutory/quasi-judicial redress bodies; free and fair elections.

Background primer

Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls

What it is:
an intensive voter-roll verification and re-enumeration drive by the ECI, building fresh rolls by house-to-house enumeration and purging deceased, shifted, duplicate and ineligible voters.
Why it matters:
removing ghost voters and duplicate entries reinforces "one person, one vote". Critics raise risks for migrants and fears of a de facto citizenship test.

West Bengal SIR appellate tribunals

What it is:
the ECI constituted 19 Appellate Tribunals in West Bengal to hear appeals on inclusion/exclusion of voters under SIR.

Collegial functioning of the Election Commission

Additional context

  • The Supreme Court has been hearing the West Bengal SIR matters (Mostari Banu v. ECI). It had judicial officers deployed to adjudicate claims and objections of those in the logical-discrepancy/unmapped category. By its 10 March 2026 order, the Calcutta HC Chief Justice had reported that over 10.16 lakh objections were disposed of. The Court said administrative officers of the EC cannot examine the judicial officers' decisions in appeal, and asked the EC to set up an appellate body of former HC judges, which became these 19 tribunals.
  • The Court has also declined to entertain a plea against deletions in Bengal as premature, directing petitioners to approach the Appellate Tribunals.
  • Commentary notes the Court's direction in ADR v. ECI to refer suspected non-citizen cases to competent citizenship tribunals. The Insights on India commentary also says the exercise has seen rising deletion percentages across phases.

Mains dimensions

  • Collegiality in a constitutional body: 14 objections in 10 months and Rawat's critique show that a dissent note has no effect if the majority will not hear it. His argument is that the two ECs held the numbers and should have used them. The corollary is that if the CEC does not hold a veto, the majority's silence is a choice.
  • Exclusion vs inclusion: a 93% eligibility rate among decided appeals points to wrongful deletion at scale. Voters excluded before polling bore the loss even if later restored. This links to the proportionality of "logical discrepancy" flags and the burden of proof on the elector.
  • Process changes mid-exercise: a declaration on ECinet about parents' or grandparents' presence in the last SIR roll, and changes to Form 6, reflect how documentary requirements can create a de facto lineage test. The EC's 26 September measures (ending physical hearings for flagged voters) concede some of these concerns.
  • Misuse of deletion procedure: the Belagavi episode shows how Form 7 can be weaponised (bulk, pre-filled, community-targeted, with impersonation of an ERO), and how junior BLOs lack protection and supervisor access. Safeguards: elector verification of objections, limits on bulk filings, digital audit trails.
  • Judicial capacity as electoral infrastructure: tribunal members resigning (19 in May; a commute-linked offer now) shows how adjudication of rights can fail for logistical reasons. With 22 lakh appeals, tribunal capacity decides whether remedy is meaningful.
  • Timelines: repeated extensions of final-roll dates (AP, Meghalaya) show the trade-off between speed and accuracy.
  • Way forward: an independent audit of deletions, public lists with reasons, a minimum-service guarantee for tribunals (location, staff), time-bound appeals tied to polling schedules, and clear dissent-recording rules inside the EC.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Special Intensive Revision aims to ensure that no eligible voter is left out and no ineligible voter is included. Examine how far its design and implementation have balanced these two goals, and suggest safeguards."

Related topics

  • Representation of the People Act, 1950 (Sections 16, 19, 21, 22, 23) and Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
  • Article 324, 326, 329; Mohinder Singh Gill (1977)
  • Role of ERO/BLO/BLA; ECINet; Aadhaar–EPIC linking debate
  • Disenfranchisement of migrants; citizenship and the Citizenship Act
  • Tribunals and access to justice; Article 323A/323B; judicial officers on election duty
  • Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 1 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs