Centre moves SC to stay Nicobar project hearings
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 30 September 2026
Summary
- The Union government, through the Environment Ministry, filed a special leave petition (SLP) in the Supreme Court. It wants a stay on the Calcutta High Court's order and on further proceedings in petitions alleging Forest Rights Act (FRA) violations in obtaining consent for the ₹92,000-crore Great Nicobar Island (GNI) project.
- The High Court had earlier rejected the Centre's challenge to the petitioner's standing and cleared the way for a final hearing.
- The Centre calls the petitions an abuse of process. The Supreme Court has listed the SLP tentatively for October 5, while the High Court final hearing is set for November 25–26.
Key facts for Prelims
- Forest Rights Act, 2006: full title as above; nodal ministry is the Ministry of Tribal Affairs; the Gram Sabha is the initiating authority.
- SDLC (Sub-Divisional Level Committee) is a body under FRA. The petitions challenge its constitution and the Gram Sabha resolutions.
- Campbell Bay and Galathea Bay are National Parks on Great Nicobar Island. The petitions also question notifications reducing their buffer zones.
- Locus standi is the right to approach a court. A Special Leave Petition (SLP) lies under Article 136.
- Niyamgiri case (2013): Orissa Mining Corporation v. MoEF, on the role of Gram Sabhas.
- PVTGs: the Shompen of Great Nicobar are a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group (semi-nomadic hunter-gatherers with little immunity to outside diseases).
Data and details
- Project cost: ₹92,000 crore.
- May 6: the Calcutta High Court (then Chief Justice Sujoy Paul and Justice Partha Sarathi Sen) overruled the Centre's preliminary objections and cleared the way for a final hearing.
- The petitioner is Meena Gupta, a retired IAS officer who served as Secretary in both the Environment and Tribal Affairs Ministries. The High Court said she had "sufficient interest" and was espousing the cause of the vulnerable tribal community. She was involved in drafting the Bill that became the FRA.
- The High Court said it would not enter the merits at this stage on cost and importance. It said a project involving huge expenditure must proceed in accordance with governing laws and is not beyond judicial review.
- Centre's SLP: filed July 24 per Supreme Court records. It argues the petitioner has no locus standi, that the challenges are an abuse of process, and that the government must ensure growth is not stopped by claims of private individuals (as The Hindu learnt).
- Timeline puzzle: as of September 24, the High Court records show the Centre consented to final hearing on November 25 and 26. The Supreme Court website shows the SLP tentatively listed for October 5.
- Petitions filed over two years challenge: the Gram Sabha resolutions consenting to forest land diversion under the FRA; the constitution of the sub-divisional level committee; notifications reducing buffer zones for Campbell Bay and Galathea Bay National Parks; and the validity of the A&N administration's certificate that all FRA rights were identified and settled.
Static–dynamic linkage
The Forest Rights Act, 2006 requires forest rights of Scheduled Tribes and other forest dwellers to be recognised and settled before forest land is diverted. The Gram Sabha has a central role. A court's task in a challenge to a big project is not to weigh its cost or importance, but to check that the law governing the field was followed. The Calcutta High Court framed it this way, and the Centre is now contesting it.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: forest diversion and clearances, conservation; GS2 – Polity/Social Justice: tribal rights, Gram Sabha; Judiciary: locus standi, PIL and judicial review of mega-projects.
Background primer
Forest Rights Act, 2006
- What it is:
- The Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006, recognising the forest rights of forest-dwelling communities over forest land and resources.
- Founded:
- Enacted in 2006 to correct the historical injustice of non-recognition of customary rights during State forest consolidation. The petitioner in this case, per the High Court, was involved in drafting the Bill.
- Mandate:
- Recognises individual and community rights, including habitation, cultivation, grazing, fishing, minor forest produce and community resource rights. Rights recognition under the FRA must be completed before formal forest land diversion. Section 5 empowers the Gram Sabha to protect wildlife, forests, biodiversity and community forest resources.
- Why it matters:
- Participatory forest governance and rights-based conservation.
Great Nicobar Island project
- What it is:
- A mega project with a transshipment port at Galathea Bay, an international airport (dual civil-military use), a gas-based power plant and an integrated township. More than 13,000 hectares of forest land is proposed for diversion.
Additional context
- The Protection of Aboriginal Tribes Regulation, 1956 (PAT56) gives the A&N Administrator overriding powers to divert forest land in notified areas, creating tension with the FRA, which requires prior settlement of rights.
- The A&N administration cited three Gram Sabha resolutions as evidence of tribal consent for diverting 166.10 sq km of forest, but reports said these were largely signed by settlers rather than the indigenous Nicobarese and Shompen. At least 60 signatures were repeated across multiple resolutions. These are allegations raised in the petitioner's challenge.
- Environmental challenges to the project went to the National Green Tribunal. In its 16 February 2026 order, the NGT declined to interfere with the environmental clearance, noting the project's strategic importance and compliance with ICRZ/CRZ norms. That order dealt with the environmental and coastal clearances, not the FRA-consent challenge now before the Calcutta High Court.
- The government's position (PIB FAQs) is that no displacement of tribal populations will be permitted and that the project has a No Objection Certificate from the Ministry of Tribal Affairs, in adherence to the FRA.
- Niyamgiri (2013): the Supreme Court upheld the Dongria Kondh Gram Sabhas' right to decide on bauxite mining in their sacred hills.
- The Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2022 removed the requirement for Gram Sabha consent before forest clearance, per critics, allowing approval before forest-rights settlement.
Mains dimensions
- Development vs. tribal and ecological rights: The Centre frames the project as national growth and strategy. The petitions raise questions about FRA compliance, forest rights of the Nicobarese and Shompen, and buffer-zone reductions near national parks.
- Rule of law over project importance: The High Court's position is that cost and strategic importance do not exempt a project from compliance with governing laws and judicial review. The Centre, through the SLP, contests this.
- Locus standi and PIL: The Centre says a private individual cannot stall national projects. The High Court accepted standing on the strength of the petitioner's expertise and her role in the FRA's drafting. This is the classic PIL debate between access to justice and abuse of process.
- Procedural integrity of consent: The challenged items are the Gram Sabha resolutions, the constitution of the SDLC, and the A&N certificate that rights were "settled". Each is a link in the consent chain.
- Federal/UT administration and the FRA: The nodal ministry delegates implementation to the UT administration, which both certifies compliance and drives the project. This raises conflict-of-interest questions.
- Strategic and environmental balance: The project's strategic rationale (Andaman Sea presence, port capacity) must be weighed against the loss of rainforest and the risk to PVTGs.
- Forum and timing: A stay sought in the Supreme Court while a High Court hearing is listed for November 25–26 raises questions about the forum for such challenges and how litigation delays affect large projects.
Possible Mains question
**GS3 (Environment) / GS2, 15 marks:** "Examine the legal and ethical issues in reconciling large strategic infrastructure projects with the rights of Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups, with reference to the Great Nicobar project and the Forest Rights Act, 2006."
Related topics
- Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2022 (Stage-I/Stage-II clearance)
- PESA Act, 1996; Fifth and Sixth Schedules; Gram Sabha powers
- Niyamgiri judgment and free, prior and informed consent (FPIC)
- Island Coastal Regulation Zone (ICRZ), CRZ norms, NGT's role and EIA
- Locus standi, PIL and Article 136 (SLP); Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 30 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs