Light on truth
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 29 September 2026
Summary
The Tamil Nadu government issued a G.O. exempting its Public (Law and Order) Department from the RTI Act, 2005 under Section 24(4). After protests by political parties and transparency activists, it was withdrawn without explanation. The editorial argues that the episode shows a tendency toward secrecy, that existing exemptions already protect sensitive information, and that Tamil Nadu should strengthen its State Information Commission rather than defeat the Act.
Key facts for Prelims
- Section 24(1)-(3): central intelligence and security organisations (Second Schedule); Section 24(4): States may notify their own.
- Section 24(5) (as cited in the editorial): a State's notification must be placed before the State legislature.
- Section 24(2)-(3): the Centre may amend the Second Schedule by Gazette notification, and each such notification is laid before both Houses of Parliament.
- Section 8 contains the general list of exemptions from disclosure.
- Section 24 proviso: allegations of corruption and human-rights violations are not excluded.
- Second Schedule bodies include IB, RAW, ED, NCB, SFF, BSF, CRPF, ITBP.
- The Digital Personal Data Protection Act is a concern to RTI advocates for diluting the RTI Act.
Data and details
- G.O. issued on 21 September under Section 24(4) notifying the Public (Law and Order) Department as an "intelligence and security organisation".
- The G.O. surfaced publicly only on 27 September. The department's designated authorities began citing it to deny information from 22 September.
- State Law Minister C.T.R. Nirmalkumar was initially defensive. He said the exemption was meant to protect sensitive district-level inquiries into communal clashes and the like, and was not sweeping. He then announced the withdrawal without giving reasons.
- Chief Minister: C. Joseph Vijay.
- Satark Nagrik Sangathan's 2024-25 report card on Information Commissions: backlog of over 41,000 appeals and complaints before the Tamil Nadu State Information Commission (TNSIC) as of June last year.
- TNSIC is functioning with only half of its sanctioned eight Information Commissioners (that is, four) and has no Chief Information Commissioner.
Static–dynamic linkage
- RTI makes access to information a statutory right (flowing from Article 19(1)(a)). Section 8 lists exemptions and Section 24 excludes intelligence and security organisations. The tension is between secrecy for genuine security needs and the citizen's right to know.
- Section 24(4) lets a State notify "intelligence and security organisations" it has established. The editorial's concern is that a department as broad as Law and Order is not an intelligence/security organisation in the intended sense, and that the power can be misused as a blanket shield.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Governance: Transparency and accountability, RTI Act, 2005; Statutory bodies (Information Commissions).
Background primer
RTI Act, 2005 — Section 24 (exemption for intelligence and security organisations)
- What it is:
- Nothing in the Act applies to the intelligence and security organisations specified in the Second Schedule, which are established by the Central Government, or to information they furnish to that Government. Information on allegations of corruption and human rights violations is not excluded. Human-rights information can be given only after the Central Information Commission's approval, within forty-five days.
- Why it matters:
- To protect the operational secrecy of genuine intelligence and security work, with a safety valve for corruption and human-rights cases.
Information Commissions (CIC/SICs)
- What it is:
- Statutory appellate and monitoring bodies under the RTI Act. The Central Information Commission and the State Information Commissions hear second appeals and complaints.
- Mandate:
- Adjudicating appeals and complaints, imposing penalties on defaulting officers, and monitoring implementation of the Act.
Additional context
- By a Gazette notification (G.S.R. 442(E)) dated 9 June 2011, the Centre added the CBI, NIA and NATGRID to the Second Schedule under Section 24(2). This is a central precedent for using the exemption route to widen the list.
- The Schedule has since been amended further. It now also lists bodies such as the Strategic Forces Command and CERT-In, and its entries include the Special Protection Group, DRDO and the Financial Intelligence Unit, India.
Mains dimensions
- Procedural opacity: The G.O. issued on 21 September surfaced publicly only on 27 September, but officials were citing it from 22 September, one day after issue. The editorial notes that the State was required to place the notification before the legislature under Section 24(5), and calls the decision unilateral.
- Misuse of Section 24(4): The Law and Order department is a general administrative arm and not an intelligence organisation. Exemption could cover routine policing records and weaken accountability. Existing Section 8 exemptions already protect sensitive material.
- Government's rationale: District-level communal-clash inquiries need confidentiality. The counter is that Section 8 can protect specific sensitive records without exempting an entire department.
- Wider erosion of RTI: Delays, vague rejections by information officers, and concerns about the DPDP Act diluting the RTI Act.
- Institutional weakness: More than 41,000 pending cases, only half the Commissioners in place and no Chief Information Commissioner at TNSIC. This shows that capacity is a larger issue than new exemptions.
- Political lesson: Public and political pressure forced the withdrawal. The editorial says that "change" governments must show commitment to transparency.
- Way forward: Fill vacancies on time, digitise appeals, proactive disclosure under Section 4, and publish reasons and consult before any Section 24 notification.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Exemptions and institutional weaknesses are said to be eroding the Right to Information. Discuss with reference to Section 24 of the RTI Act and the functioning of Information Commissions."
Related topics
- Article 19(1)(a) and the right to know (Raj Narain, S.P. Gupta)
- RTI Act, 2005: Sections 4, 8, 22 and Section 8(1)(j)
- DPDP Act, 2023 and its interaction with RTI (privacy vs transparency)
- Information Commissions: appointments, vacancies and backlog
- Official Secrets Act, 1923 and the Whistle Blowers Protection Act
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 29 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs