BrainParrot

Civil society groups seek SIR rollback, say polls must use previous voter list

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 29 September 2026

Summary

  • Lawyers and civil society members under the "Together We Stand" banner asked the Election Commission (EC) to roll back the special intensive revision (SIR) nationwide. They also wanted CEC Gyanesh Kumar to resign or face removal proceedings.
  • The Congress, the CPI and the BJP responded the same day with protests, a Supreme Court application and counter-charges. A press conference in Delhi was followed by protests in Patna, Agra and Bhopal.
  • The Opposition's main evidence is a recent report that the other two Election Commissioners objected to several EC decisions during the SIR. The BJP says the same Commission members have now rebutted the Opposition's allegations.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Election Commission, electoral rolls, CEC's removal

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections vests in the ECI. Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950 is the statutory hook for a special revision of rolls.
  • Article 324(5): the CEC is removable like a Supreme Court Judge. Other ECs are removable only on the CEC's recommendation.
  • The CEC and Other ECs Act, 2023 replaced the Election Commission (Conditions of Service) Act, 1991. Its Selection Committee is PM, LoP (Lok Sabha) and a Union Cabinet Minister.
  • Removal grounds: proved misbehaviour or incapacity. The Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968 applies. The signature thresholds are 100 (Lok Sabha) and 50 (Rajya Sabha).
  • Manual on Electoral Rolls (issued December 2023): provides for a public social audit of the roll. Verification is at gram sabha/ward sabha/booth level in the presence of the BLO and the Electoral Registration Officer (ERO), with immediate correction of wrongful deletions.
  • Form 6 is the form for new voter enrolment. Its changes are on the Congress Working Committee agenda.
  • Appellate Tribunals in West Bengal hear appeals by electors deleted in the SIR.
  • West Bengal SIR case: a pending Supreme Court case in which Prasenjit Bose is the petitioner.

Data and details

  • Civil-society demands (Delhi press conference, Monday):
  • Roll back the SIR and restore every elector removed.
  • Hold all forthcoming elections on pre-SIR rolls, with a summary revision if required.
  • CEC to resign, failing which removal proceedings should begin.
  • Repeal the CEC and Other ECs Act, 2023.
  • Hold an independent inquiry into the constitutionality and legality of all decisions taken under Mr. Kumar.
  • Put every SIR document in the public domain.
  • Restore welfare benefits wrongly denied after deletion.
  • Public social audit of the roll.
  • Kapil Sibal: the Supreme Court should scrap all EC decisions, because they are not decisions of the full Commission. He cited the report that the other two ECs objected to a number of the poll body's decisions during the SIR.
  • West Bengal figures (Prasenjit Bose application, Supreme Court):
  • Prayer: an independent panel of former SC judges, retired CECs/ECs and experts for a time-bound inquiry into the SIR across 20 States and UTs.
  • Prayer: stay on further SIR proceedings during the inquiry.
  • Prayer: restoration of names of electors who appealed to the Appellate Tribunals in West Bengal.
  • Of 22 lakh applications by deleted electors, only 1,607 were reinstated in time to vote in April.
  • Bose is chairperson of the West Bengal Pradesh Congress Committee's SIR panel.
  • Congress (Kharge, Venugopal):
  • A Congress Working Committee meeting on Tuesday on "internal differences" in the EC, the SIR, and Form 6 changes.
  • Kharge flagged additions and deletions and "centralised control" over the electoral roll database.
  • Kharge said the Congress would also discuss its demand for Mr. Kumar's removal, and that action should follow even after any resignation.
  • Congress alleges the SIR could exclude Gen Z voters.
  • Venugopal alleged the CEC acts as a "dictator" without consulting the ECs, and said this was shown by the Commissioners' own statements, not Congress allegations.
  • The INDIA bloc meets Wednesday and may move another removal notice in Parliament.
  • Patna (States_01): a CPI-led march from Gandhi Maidan towards Lok Bhawan (the Governor's residence) saw police barricades at the Dak Bungalow thoroughfare and water cannon use, followed by clashes.
  • Participants: CPI, AISF, AIYF, Bihar Mahila Samaj, Bihar State Kisan Sabha, Bharatiya Khet Mazdoor Union, AITUC and Tanzim-e-Insaf. Students of Bihar University of Health Sciences joined over academic delays and financial irregularities.
  • Patna SSP Kartikeya Sharma cited "antisocial elements", stone pelting and injuries. CPI general secretary D. Raja condemned the lathi-charge and water cannon.
  • Memorandum to the Governor: the CEC's resignation, cancellation of the SIR, repeal of the Waqf (Amendment) Act, MGNREGS reinstatement with 200 days of work and minimum wages, and a comprehensive Central law for agricultural labourers.
  • Agra: two Congress leaders (Mukesh Dhangar and Anil Yadav) were arrested for allegedly writing "traitor" and "thief" slogans on the wall and gate of the CEC's home. A case was registered at Hari Parvat police station. Stickers and pamphlets were also put up (ACP Bajrang Prasad). In Bhopal, police used water cannon on Congress workers.
  • BJP (J.P. Nadda):
  • Named Rahul Gandhi, Arvind Kejriwal, Akhilesh Yadav and Mamata Banerjee as having a "toolkit mentality".
  • Accused them of defaming constitutional institutions and derailing the path to Viksit Bharat.
  • Said earlier "fabricated" allegations collapsed when tested against facts.
  • Claimed that all members of the Election Commission had now exposed the Opposition's "false allegations".
  • This directly contradicts the Opposition's reading of the same Commissioners' stance.

Static–dynamic linkage

The ECI draws its power from Article 324. It has "superintendence, direction and control" over the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections. Its independence rests on three safeguards:

  • the CEC's security of tenure, with removal only like a Supreme Court judge;
  • a statutory selection process for Election Commissioners;
  • collegial decision-making (CEC plus two ECs).

The news tests all three. The demands include rolling back a roll-revision exercise, auditing the rolls socially, and repealing the 2023 Act that governs the Commission's appointments and conduct.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional/statutory/quasi-judicial bodies (ECI); Representation of the People Act; GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability.

Background primer

Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls

What it is:
In Bihar, electors had to submit eligibility documents along with the enumeration form. In Phase II, only the pre-printed enumeration form was needed at first, and electors could link themselves to the 2002–04 rolls.

Election Commission of India and the CEC

What it is:
A constitutional body under Article 324. It consists of the CEC and such number of other Election Commissioners as the President decides.
Why it matters:
The Commission is both an administrative and a quasi-judicial body. It adjudicates symbol allotments and party registrations. Insulation from the executive is therefore central to its legitimacy.

Removal of the CEC (process)

Additional context

  • An earlier removal notice against CEC Gyanesh Kumar was filed in the Lok Sabha on 12 March 2026. It was signed by 130 Lok Sabha and 63 Rajya Sabha members and invoked Article 324(5) read with Article 124(4).

  • The Rajya Sabha Chairman and the Lok Sabha Speaker rejected the notice. The "another removal notice" the INDIA bloc is considering therefore follows a rejected first attempt.

  • The 255th Law Commission report (2015) had recommended amending Article 324(5) to give ECs the same protection as the CEC.

Mains dimensions

  • Independence vs accountability: The Opposition's central evidence is intra-Commission dissent. Under the 2023 Act, the Commission is to try to transact business unanimously and, failing that, by majority. The question is whether decisions taken without the other Commissioners' concurrence are valid. The article gives no detail of what the two ECs objected to. That absence matters, because the Commissioners' own statement is the most probative evidence either side could produce.
  • Appointment and removal asymmetry: The CEC enjoys judge-like removal protection. ECs can be removed only on the CEC's recommendation, which is a structural weakness. The Selection Committee has the executive in a majority, with the CJI dropped. The civil-society demand to repeal the 2023 Act puts this design on trial.
  • Constitutional threshold for removal: Disagreement with policy is not "proved misbehaviour". No CEC has ever been removed. The March 2026 notice (130 Lok Sabha + 63 Rajya Sabha signatures) was rejected at the admission stage. The "scrap all EC decisions" demand is a far-reaching judicial remedy with no easy precedent.
  • Inclusion vs purity of rolls: The Supreme Court upheld the SIR in Bihar and allowed limited citizenship checks. Critics point to the documentary-proof burden, the West Bengal appeals backlog (1,607 of 22 lakh restored in time for April) and centralised database control. The demand for a gram-sabha-level social audit (Manual of December 2023) is an alternative, participatory verification model.
  • Federal and social spillovers: Wrongful deletion has knock-on effects on welfare entitlements, which is why the civil-society groups asked for benefits to be restored. The protests bundle unrelated grievances (MGNREGS, Waqf Act, agricultural labour law). This shows how an institutional-trust issue becomes a wider political mobilisation.
  • Political discourse: The BJP frames the Opposition's attacks as a "toolkit" to defame institutions. The Opposition frames the Commission as compromised. Arrests over defacing the CEC's home and the use of water cannon raise questions about proportionate policing and the limits of protest.
  • Way forward: Publish SIR records and deletion reasons. Allow independent audits. Document the dissent record and resolve it through the Commission's own rules or the courts. Consider parity of removal protection for ECs, as the 2015 Law Commission suggested.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The independence of the Election Commission depends as much on its internal functioning as on the security of tenure of its members. In the light of the controversy over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, critically examine the adequacy of existing safeguards and suggest reforms."

Related topics

  • Articles 324–329; Representation of the People Acts, 1950 and 1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
  • Anoop Baranwal (2023) and ADR v. ECI (Bihar SIR) judgments
  • Removal of judges: Article 124(4) and the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968
  • Election Commission's quasi-judicial powers (symbol allotment, party registration)
  • Citizenship Act and the question of who decides citizenship (competent authority vs ECI)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 29 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs