BrainParrot

The pitfalls of mandatory FIRs

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 September 2026

Summary

  • On August 5, in G. Ganesh v. State of Tamil Nadu, the Supreme Court reiterated that police must register an FIR on information about any missing "person", not only missing children.
  • The author, writing as a former police officer, argues that this works for children but is problematic for adults who leave home of their own volition. He wants the Court to review the direction and allow a short preliminary enquiry window.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: judiciary, police and criminal procedure; GS2 — Social Justice: child protection, trafficking

Key facts for Prelims

  • Section 154 CrPC corresponds to Section 173 BNSS (information in cognizable cases).
  • Zero FIR: can be registered at any police station irrespective of jurisdiction. Cognizable offences only.
  • Section 173(3) BNSS: preliminary enquiry for offences punishable with 3 to under 7 years, with DSP-level permission, within 14 days.
  • Lalita Kumari v. Government of U.P.: Constitution Bench; FIR registration is mandatory for cognizable offences, with limited exceptions.
  • Bachpan Bachao Andolan v. Union of India: missing children; presumption of abduction or trafficking; FIR mandatory.
  • Section 63 JJ Act, 2000: Juvenile Welfare Officer (per the article). Juvenile Justice Rules, 2007 on Special Juvenile Police Units.
  • AHTU (Anti-Human Trafficking Unit): the district unit to which an unrecovered missing child's case is forwarded after four months.
  • The May directions in the editorial: an MHA special portal on human trafficking; FIR without preliminary enquiry; AHTUs activated in districts; recovered child restored to rightful guardian per law; Aadhaar verification or issuance.

Data and details

  • August 5: G. Ganesh v. State of Tamil Nadu reiterated mandatory FIR for any missing "person".
  • The Court's directions in May included an MHA portal, no waiting for preliminary enquiry or for guardians to search first, activating district AHTUs, restoring the child to the rightful guardian, and Aadhaar verification or issuance.
  • BBA (January 2013) concerned only missing children. Directions: mandatory FIR, and a Special Juvenile Police Unit in each police station under the JJ Rules, 2007.
  • May 2013: after Madhya Pradesh's doubt about Section 154 CrPC (now Section 173 BNSS), the Court laid down the presumption of abduction or trafficking, a Juvenile Welfare Officer per police station and an AHTU referral if the child is not found within four months of the FIR.
  • G. Ganesh facts: a child aged one year and ten months went missing from Chennai in 2011.
  • The case moved from the Central Crime Branch to a Special Investigation Team, and the child remained untraced for 14 years.
  • The petitioner alleged MHA guidelines of June 2013 were not followed and the case was not transferred to the AHTU after four months.
  • The Madras High Court dismissed the petition in March 2025, saying police had made all efforts and the 2013 guidelines did not apply in 2011.
  • The author's points:
  • The May judgment does not indicate the States were heard on missing adults.
  • There was no occasion for the Court to take up missing adults suo motu.
  • A week or fortnight for a preliminary enquiry could filter cases where the person was clearly neither abducted nor trafficked.

Static–dynamic linkage

Under criminal procedure, a police officer must register an FIR when information discloses a cognizable offence. The offence of kidnapping or trafficking is cognizable, but a missing adult need not be a victim of any offence. Children cannot legally consent, so a presumption of abduction or trafficking is protective for them. For adults it collides with autonomy and the privacy of consenting couples. The issue is how far a court's blanket direction can displace the discretion built into statute.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Role of judiciary and directions (Art. 142 style court-led guidelines); fundamental rights (Arts 14, 19, 21 and personal liberty); GS2 – Social Justice: protection of children, human trafficking; GS3 – Internal security (organised crime).

Background primer

FIR, cognizable offences and Section 173 BNSS

What it is:
The First Information Report is the first record of information about a cognizable offence. It sets the investigation in motion.
Founded:
Governed earlier by Section 154 CrPC. The BNSS has replaced the CrPC, and registration of a cognizable offence is now under Section 173 BNSS.
Members:
Information can be given orally or electronically to the officer in charge. Section 173 introduced Zero FIR, electronic communication, a copy to the informant and a preliminary enquiry provision.

Bachpan Bachao Andolan (BBA) v. Union of India and the missing-children framework

What it is:
A long-running Supreme Court PIL (W.P. (C) 75 of 2012) in which the Court gave directions on missing children.
Founded:
On 17 January 2013 the Court gave an interim direction that any complaint of a missing child be reduced into an FIR. The article says it also directed Special Juvenile Police Units at every police station.
Members:
Per the article, one specially trained officer per police station is designated Juvenile Welfare Officer (Section 63, JJ Act, 2000). Cases unresolved after four months go to the Anti-Human Trafficking Unit (AHTU). Details on the establishment of AHTUs are not confirmed from a trusted source here.

Additional context

  • Government follow-up:
    • The MHA circulated an advisory on mandatory FIR in missing-child cases on 25 June 2013.
    • The Ministry of Women and Child Development launched the "Track Child" web portal to maintain real-time data on missing children.
    • The WCD Ministry developed a model Standard Operating Procedure for missing children, following a Supreme Court direction of January 13, 2015 in the BBA case.
    • The SOP says that on a complaint regarding a missing child, an FIR should be registered forthwith as a case of trafficking or abduction.
  • The BNSS has a built-in filter the editorial's argument relies on:
    • Under Section 173(3) BNSS, for offences punishable with three years or more but less than seven, the officer in charge may, with prior permission of an officer not below Deputy Superintendent of Police, hold a preliminary enquiry within fourteen days to see whether a prima facie case exists.

    • Whether a missing-person report falls within this window depends on the offence alleged. The article does not say how the Court's August 5 direction interacts with it.

Mains dimensions

  • Why presume for children: Consent is legally irrelevant for a child, and early FIR triggers tracing machinery (Juvenile Welfare Officer, Special Juvenile Police Unit, AHTU referral). The 14-year, still-untraced G. Ganesh case shows the cost of weak follow-through, not of FIRs themselves.
  • Why adults differ: Adults may leave voluntarily, for example to live together or marry against family wishes.
  • Mandatory FIRs oblige police to trace them and hand them to parents.
  • The author notes that in "honour" cases couples have been killed after being found, with or without police help.
  • Even a prior statement of willingness would not stop police tracing and verification, so consenting couples face unnecessary investigation.
  • Judicial method:
  • The directions extend a child-specific regime (BBA) to all persons, apparently without hearing States.
  • Courts issuing detailed protocols raise concerns of judicial legislation. They also need empirical grounding.
  • The author calls the blanket presumption of kidnapping or trafficking "against the spirit of the statute".
  • Balance of interests: Trafficking is a serious organised crime, so the direction's intent is sound. Yet an FIR-first rule can overload police and chill adult autonomy (Art. 21).
  • Possible middle path: a short, time-bound, recorded preliminary verification for adults. It would fit with Section 173(3) BNSS and the limited enquiry the Lalita Kumari bench allowed for certain categories.
  • Implementation gaps: The portal, AHTU activation and Aadhaar verification depend on state capacity and data protection.
  • Way forward: Distinguish minors from adults in protocol. Provide a short, supervised preliminary enquiry for adults. Add privacy safeguards around Aadhaar use. Make the Court review its direction after hearing States.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Mandatory registration of FIRs in all missing-person cases may protect trafficking victims but can infringe the autonomy of consenting adults. Critically examine the Supreme Court's recent directions in this light."

Related topics

  • Lalita Kumari v. Government of U.P. and Section 173 BNSS (Zero FIR, e-FIR, preliminary enquiry)
  • Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015; Child Welfare Committees; SOPs for missing children
  • Human trafficking laws and AHTUs; Art. 23 (prohibition of trafficking)
  • Honour crimes and the right of consenting adults (Arts 19, 21)
  • Judicial overreach vs judicial activism; guidelines by courts in the absence of legislation

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs