BrainParrot

In need of an overhaul

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 September 2026

Summary

  • The ECI issued a press note on Saturday, after it emerged that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had recorded 14 objections to decisions taken under CEC Gyanesh Kumar. The editorial reads the note as damage control that concedes only administrative complaints and implicitly admits the SIR was badly implemented.
  • It argues that the SIR shifts the onus of enrolment from the state to the elector, deletes names before verifying them, and imposes onerous conditions for re-entry. It also argues the Supreme Court's May 27 ruling came too late and deferred too much. Its remedy is to reconstitute the ECI through a selection committee that does not give the government an overriding majority.
  • The same issue shows the political fallout:
    • Opposition leaders demand the CEC's resignation.
    • An INDIA bloc meeting is set for September 30.
    • Over 2,000 citizens wrote to the CJI.
    • A new party, the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), is campaigning on the issue.
    • The BJP is countering on the ground.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: ECI independence, electoral rolls, right to vote

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art. 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of elections in the ECI. Art. 324(5): the CEC is removable "in like manner and on like grounds" as a Supreme Court judge (linked to Art. 124(4)). Other ECs can be removed only on the CEC's recommendation.
  • CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023: it repeals the 1991 Act. It sets a three-member selection committee (PM, LoP in Lok Sabha, Union Cabinet Minister), a six-year or age-65 tenure, and unanimity-where-possible business rules. Per the Text article, Section 17 requires business to follow the Act, and Section 18 lets the Commission regulate its procedure by unanimous decision, with majority decision on differences.
  • Art. 326: elections to Lok Sabha and Assemblies on adult suffrage. The Constituent Assembly's Advisory Committee rejected making voting a Fundamental Right, though Ambedkar and K.T. Shah proposed it.
  • Legal status of the right to vote:
  • Kuldip Nayar v. Union of India (2006), Constitution Bench: a statutory right under Section 62 of the RP Act, 1951.
  • Rajbala v. State of Haryana (2015): a two-judge bench called it a constitutional right, but the larger Kuldip Nayar bench prevails.
  • Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023): the Court declined to revisit. Justice Ajay Rastogi dissented, linking it to Art. 19(1)(a) and the essence of Art. 21.
  • Kesavananda Bharati (1973): democracy is part of the basic structure. Lakshmi Charan Sen v. A.K.M. Hassan Uzzaman (1985): parties should help ensure eligible voters are included and ineligible ones removed.
  • Courts have held that only substantial, systemic errors that "materially affected" the outcome vitiate an election on roll grounds.
  • ADM Jabalpur: the Emergency-era ruling the editorial cites as a judicial failure.
  • Form 6 is the form for inclusion in the roll. SSR (Special Summary Revision) is the routine revision, as opposed to the SIR.
  • Sukumar Sen, the then CEC, introduced election symbols to make universal adult suffrage workable for about 173 million largely illiterate voters.

Data and details

  • 14 objections recorded over 10 months by ECs Sandhu and Joshi against CEC Kumar.
  • They covered alleged unilateral changes to rules, voter additions and deletions, and centralised data access without the Commission's full approval.
  • The ECI's concessions:
  • Agendas to be circulated before meetings and minutes afterwards.
  • Officers' foreign trips to need ECI approval.
  • EROs to run a "special drive" to enrol anyone "left out".
  • A review of ECINet's compliance with law.
  • BLO visits to electors who got notices, instead of public hearings.
  • Unanswered: Sandhu's question on who authorised 16.1 lakh appeals to remove voters whom judicial officers had included in West Bengal.
  • More than 13 crore names were removed from draft rolls through the SIR (editorial). Congress puts it at nearly 14 crore across three phases.
  • Deleted electors are being told to reapply as new applicants.
  • Over 9 in 10 appeals decided by West Bengal's tribunals restored deleted voters, months after the Assembly polls.
  • In one-third of Delhi's seats, the draft rolls have fewer electors than voted in 2025.
  • The Supreme Court ruled on May 27 on the SIR, after it was a settled fact in Bihar, West Bengal and the other Phase 2 States.
  • The editorial says it brushed aside the 1995 ruling that every removal must be individually reasoned.
  • It also says the Court read an exceptional, targeted-revision provision as a licence for a statewide sweep.
  • 97 eligible Goa voters were excluded because ECINet stopped ground-level EROs from reversing decisions.
  • The EROs flagged it by email, but corrections were not restored.
  • Roll status gates State schemes. Goa's Mediclaim Scheme covers dialysis, angioplasty, open-heart surgery, transplants, chemotherapy and cochlear implants, and is open only to State voters.
  • The U.K. restricted the franchise to male property owners initially, with universal male suffrage in 1918 and women's vote in 1928 (as given in the article).
  • In the U.S., the 15th Amendment (1870) and 19th Amendment (1920) extended the vote, but poll taxes and literacy tests continued to exclude many.
  • Called the ECI's steps "a desperate attempt at damage control" and "piecemeal".
  • Said BLO visits earlier were "sparse and sporadic".
  • Said the review of ECINet's legality was an admission that it was in question.
  • Alleged ECINet was used to delete eligible voters and override EROs.
  • Questioned lack of transparency on ECINet and on the use of AI in roll preparation.
  • Asked whether the Goa problems also occurred in West Bengal.
  • Form 6:
  • The ECI relied on the May 27 judgment to defend a new declaration in Form 6.
  • Ramesh said the July change applied to the online Form 6 for all voters, not only SIR voters.
  • He also noted the same judgment bars the ECI from departing from statutory procedure without a rational basis.
  • The non-SIR Form 6 route is "misleading" because the SSR has been frozen since 2024 and no non-SIR roll is being published.
  • Keralam CM V.D. Satheesan demanded the CEC's resignation after former Chief Secretary Jiji Thomson's claim that Kumar urged him in 2019 to join the BJP and contest from Pathanamthitta.
  • Thomson told The Hindu it was a friendly suggestion, not an offer, made on a shared flight to Delhi.
  • The UDF and LDF both seized on it. Satheesan alleged Kumar overruled two ECs to exclude lakhs, chiefly minorities and marginalised groups.
  • West Bengal's Mamata Banerjee alleged the SIR helps the BJP capture Bengal and demanded fresh elections on the pre-SIR roll.
  • CPI(M)'s M.A. Baby met AAP's Arvind Kejriwal on Sunday.
  • They discussed the CEC allegedly ignoring the two ECs' objections and the ED action against former Keralam CM Pinarayi Vijayan.
  • Baby had written to INDIA bloc and other non-NDA parties, and spoke to Mamata after three decades of differences. She agreed the situation warranted coordinated action.
  • The INDIA bloc meeting is on Sept 30. Its agenda includes the ECI's functioning, the SIR and seeking the CEC's removal.
  • Over 2,000 citizens wrote to CJI Surya Kant, seeking:
  • suo motu proceedings on the ECI's conduct on the SIR and ECINet;
  • an immediate stay and rescission of the SIR in all States and UTs pending independent judicial review;
  • a court-monitored probe into unauthorised changes to registration software and forms;
  • penal or procedural action against the CEC and officials for overriding statutory procedure and the multi-member mandate;
  • an independent expert audit of ECINet, appointed by the Supreme Court, restoring decentralised control to EROs and checking whether non-statutory persons had access;
  • reinstatement of deleted voters.
  • Signatories include Aditya Nigam, Aditya Seth, Admiral Vishnu Bhagwat (retd), Aditi Mehta (retd IAS), Amrita Johri, Anjali Bhardwaj, Anita Rampal, Nivedita Menon, Prashant Bhushan and Prakash Raj.
  • BJP fielded Chief Ministers Yogi Adityanath, Devendra Fadnavis, Himanta Biswa Sarma, Bhajan Lal Sharma, Bhupendra Patel, Nayab Singh Saini, Vishnu Deo Sai, Pushkar Singh Dhami, Rekha Gupta, Samrat Choudhary, Mohan Yadav and Suvendu Adhikari against Rahul Gandhi. They called the allegations fabricated and said the ECI had issued a press note and clarification.
  • Sai said Congress had lost "more than 100 elections".
  • Patel alleged double standards on election outcomes.
  • Adhikari said Congress backed the SIR in Kerala after winning but opposed it in West Bengal after losing, and that judicial officers were handling names rejected on logical discrepancies.
  • Adhikari also said Trinamool was formed to end 34 years of CPI(M) rule.
  • The CJP reports about 20,000 registrations in Keralam, the highest from any State. About 150 attended its first official Kochi meet.
  • Assam Police detained CJP co-convener Ashutosh Ranka and 41 volunteers in Guwahati.
  • Six of them were women.
  • They were taken to Dispur police station and released that evening.
  • The CJP says no notice or legal sections were given.
  • It alleged intimidation of civil society, and raised Kaziranga evictions and alleged redrawing of Assam's constituency boundaries.
  • It cited the NSA detention of land-rights activist Pranab Doley.
  • Mumbai Police denied the CJP permission for an Oct 2, 3–9 pm protest at Shivaji Park.
  • Reasons: court curbs on non-sporting events, no BMC permission, noise and traffic.
  • The CJP may seek another venue. Shiv Sena (UBT) is expected to join.

Static–dynamic linkage

The Constitution gives the ECI "superintendence, direction and control" of elections (Art. 324). Its independence rests on three things: a collegial structure, security of tenure (the CEC can be removed only like a Supreme Court judge), and a statutory business-transaction rule of unanimity where possible and majority otherwise. This story tests all three:

  • A CEC accused of acting without the full Commission.
  • A removal route that is hard for the CEC and, for other ECs, depends on the CEC's own recommendation.
  • A selection committee weighted towards the executive.

It also tests the status of the right to vote. It is anchored in Art. 326 but held by the Supreme Court to be statutory, so roll revision is governed by ordinary law and administrative design.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI, Art. 324); Representation of the People Acts, 1950/1951; electoral reforms; GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability of institutions. Prelims – Polity: Elections.

Background primer

Election Commission of India (ECI)

What it is:
A permanent constitutional body under Art. 324. It holds the "superintendence, direction and control of elections" and consists of the CEC and such number of other ECs as the President fixes. It manages the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of the President and Vice-President.
Founded:
Established under Art. 324 when the Constitution came into force (textbook date: 25 January 1950). The framers wanted a central, independent election machinery rather than one controlled by governments of the day.

Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls

What it is:
Unlike routine annual summary revisions, an intensive revision means fresh preparation of the rolls through house-to-house verification by Booth Level Officers. The current SIR is a hybrid and adds a new step: documentary proof at the enumeration stage.
Why it matters:
Cleaning rolls of duplicates, dead and migrated electors, and enrolling eligible citizens.

Electoral-roll law and ECINet

Additional context

  • What the May 27 verdict actually held:
    • The Court found the SIR proportionate: structured enumeration, verification and remedies, and a statewide SIR proportionate to the scale of the problem.
    • The ECI may examine citizenship for electoral purposes but cannot make final determinations of citizenship.
    • It ordered persons deleted on citizenship grounds to be referred to the competent authority within four weeks, with restoration if they are found to be citizens.
    • The Bihar exercise covered about 7.9 crore voters and ended with a final roll of 7.42 crore.
  • Challenge that the SIR reversed a presumption:
    • Petitioners argued the SIR reversed the presumption of eligibility for names already on the roll. The Court held that inclusion gives a rebuttable presumption of validity, and that Lal Babu Hussein v. ERO (1995) concerned individual adjudication and does not bar a systemic verification exercise. It also described the right to vote as a constitutional right that is not absolute.
  • Earlier judicial unease over West Bengal:
    • In West Bengal, a bench led by CJI Surya Kant noted that about 1.25 crore voters figured on the "logical discrepancies" list. It ordered the names displayed so that those affected could file documents or objections. Later, it noted that 30–34 lakh appeals were pending before the appellate tribunals.
  • How the current selection law arose:
    • On March 2, 2023 the Supreme Court ruled that a panel of the PM, the Leader of Opposition and the CJI should select the CEC.
    • The 2023 Act replaced the CJI with a Union Minister in the panel.
    • Gyanesh Kumar was appointed CEC on February 17, 2025, over Rahul Gandhi's dissent note.
    • The exclusion of the CJI has been challenged in petitions, including Jaya Thakur v. Union of India.
  • Removal of a CEC, step by step:
    • The notice needs at least 100 Lok Sabha or 50 Rajya Sabha MPs, and the Speaker or Chairman decides whether to admit it.
    • A three-member committee then investigates: a Supreme Court judge, a High Court Chief Justice and a jurist.
    • The motion needs a majority of total membership and two-thirds of those present and voting in each House.
    • No CEC has ever been removed.
    • In March 2026 Trinamool-led opposition MPs submitted removal notices in both Houses, reportedly signed by 130 Lok Sabha and 63 Rajya Sabha members. The Lok Sabha Speaker and the Rajya Sabha Chairman refused to admit them under Section 3 of the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968.

Mains dimensions

  • Collegiality eroded: 14 objections in 10 months, and a centralised ECINet that overrides EROs, suggest decision-making has moved away from the Commission and from statutory officers.
  • The ECI's remedy (agendas and minutes) is procedural. It does not answer who authorised the 16.1 lakh appeals.
  • Section 18 of the 2023 Act expects consensus, with majority rule on differences.
  • Onus shift and burden of proof:
  • The SIR makes enrolled voters re-prove eligibility. It deletes before verifying. It treats the earlier presumption of eligibility as rebuttable.
  • Appellate outcomes (over 9 in 10 appeals restoring voters in West Bengal) and the Delhi roll shortfall are the empirical evidence.
  • Judicial deference and timing: The Supreme Court delayed deciding for months and ruled when the SIR was a fait accompli.
  • Compare ADM Jabalpur. The Court's proportionality reasoning has been criticised for engaging the SIR "in theory and not in practice".
  • Technology governance:
  • ECINet (AI use, access by non-statutory persons, no override by EROs) raises questions of legality, transparency and accountability.
  • Welfare linkage (the Goa Mediclaim scheme) turns a roll error into loss of health access.
  • Independence design:
  • Executive-heavy selection committee (the CJI was replaced by a Union Minister).
  • Asymmetric removal: ECs depend on the CEC's recommendation. Removing a CEC needs a two-thirds Parliamentary process, which has never succeeded.
  • Suggested reforms: a balanced selection committee (the editorial's demand), equal removal safeguards for ECs, and an independent secretariat.
  • Political polarisation: Allegations (the Thomson episode, "BJP's agent") and the BJP's "maligning institutions" counter-narrative both erode trust.
  • Cross-party consolidation (CPI(M)–AAP–TMC outreach) and new actors such as the CJP show institutional distrust becoming electoral politics. It also draws state responses such as detentions and permission denials.
  • Way forward:
  • Judicial review that examines the SIR's practice, not just its legality.
  • A statutory, reasoned, appealable deletion process.
  • Independent audit of ECINet.
  • Consider elevating the right to vote's legal status (see the Text article's argument).

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The credibility of the Election Commission depends on its collective functioning and the integrity of electoral rolls. In the light of recent controversies over the Special Intensive Revision and internal dissent within the Commission, critically examine the adequacy of existing safeguards for the ECI's independence and suggest reforms."

Related topics

  • Right to vote: statutory vs constitutional vs fundamental, and Arts 325–326
  • Art. 329(b) and the bar on judicial intervention in elections
  • Basic structure doctrine and free and fair elections
  • RP Acts 1950 and 1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
  • Removal of constitutional office-holders (Art. 124(4); Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968)
  • Delimitation and its challenge (Assam constituency boundaries allegation)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs