BrainParrot

Jharkhand govt. opposing mines Act to facilitate coal theft: Minister

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 27 September 2026

Summary

Union Minister Annpurna Devi (BJP) addressed a press conference in Ranchi on Saturday. She defended the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment (MMDR) Act, 2026 and accused the JMM-led Jharkhand government, along with Congress and RJD, of misleading people about it. The State government had earlier called the law a "black Bill", and the Minister alleged that the State opposes the Act to facilitate coal theft and to raise "personal revenue".

UPSC relevance: GS2 – Polity: Centre–State fiscal relations / GS3 – Economy: mining & mineral policy

Key facts for Prelims

  • MMDR Amendment Act, 2026 amends the MMDR Act, 1957. It inserts Section 9D (limits on State levies on mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands) and amends Section 13 (Centre's rule-making power).
  • Constitutional hooks: Entry 54, List I (Union regulation of mines and minerals), Entry 23, List II (State regulation of mines, subject to Entry 54), Entry 50, List II (State tax on mineral rights, subject to Parliament's limits) and Entry 49, List II (State tax on lands and buildings).
  • Royalty is not a tax: MADA v. SAIL (2024), 9-judge Constitution Bench, 8:1.
  • Major minerals (coal, iron ore, bauxite) are regulated by the Centre. Minor minerals (about 50, such as sand, gravel and granite) are controlled by States.
  • District Mineral Foundation (DMF) payments are among the existing State mining receipts (royalty, auction premium, dead rent, DMF, GST, transit fee). The government says States continue to receive them under the Act.
  • The Act brings "mineral-bearing lands" within the Union's regulatory ambit (Section 2).

Data and details

  • Speaker: Annpurna Devi, Union Minister of Women and Child Development and a Jharkhand BJP leader, at the BJP State office in Ranchi on Saturday.
  • Parties accused of "misleading" people: JMM, Congress and RJD.
  • Her claims: the State fails to conduct auctions on time and does not seek legitimate revenue for the exchequer. She alleges it wants "personal revenue" and that opposition to the Act is meant to facilitate coal theft.
  • Promised benefits (as claimed): new investment, jobs within the State and less migration. Streamlined and transparent mining taxation and curbs on "arbitrary actions" of the State. The Centre would implement uniform taxes and levies nationwide with "no interference" from the State.
  • Alleged past State conduct: new taxes and cesses imposed after auctions, with harassment of operators over cesses and outstanding dues.
  • She says the Act is already implemented in Odisha, West Bengal, Chhattisgarh, Karnataka and Kerala. She claims it is welcomed in many Congress-ruled States, and says implementation will end "red-tapism".
  • She further alleged that the State government intends to keep revenue from reaching the State exchequer, keep administrative systems dysfunctional, deny facilities to legitimate business operators, and let the illegal-mining racket flourish.
  • Counter-position: CM Hemant Soren called it a "black Bill" and an injustice to Jharkhand. His argument: minerals and land belong to Jharkhand, so why should Delhi decide its rights and entitlements?

Static–dynamic linkage

Mining is a Union-regulated subject. Entry 54 of the Union List lets Parliament regulate mines and mineral development once it declares this expedient in the public interest. States tax mineral rights under Entry 50 of the State List, which is "subject to" limits Parliament imposes by law. This news is an instance of the old Centre–State tug-of-war over who controls and taxes mineral wealth. Mineral-rich States (Jharkhand, Odisha, Chhattisgarh) treat levies as a core revenue source. The Union wants a uniform, predictable tax regime to attract investment and secure critical minerals.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Centre–State relations, fiscal federalism, Seventh Schedule distribution of powers | GS3 – Economy: mining sector, resource mobilisation, investment, industrial policy

Background primer

Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (MMDR Act)

What it is:
the central law that governs mining and mineral development in India. Mining is governed by this Act, and the Union controls mine regulation and mineral development in the wider public interest under Section 2.
Founded:
enacted in 1957. It rests on Parliament's power over mines under Entry 54, List I. Entry 54 gives Parliament this power, while the State List's Entry 23 gives States regulatory power over mines, explicitly subject to Parliament's laws under Entry 54.
Members:
not a body. It is a statute administered by the Ministry of Mines, with States granting leases. The Centre regulates major minerals and fixes royalty rates, while State governments grant mining leases and collect royalty from lessees.
Mandate:
the Act lets the Centre regulate major minerals such as coal, iron ore and bauxite, while minor minerals like building stones, gravel and ordinary clay are regulated by State governments.
Why it matters:
a single national framework for mineral development, so that a resource found in a few States can serve the national economy.

Mineral Area Development Authority (MADA) v. SAIL (2024) – the judgment behind the 2026 amendment

What it is:
a Supreme Court Constitution Bench ruling on royalty and State taxing power. A 9-judge bench held 8:1 that royalty under Section 9 of the MMDR Act is a contractual consideration paid to the mineral owner, not a sovereign tax.

Additional context

  • What the Act actually does. New Section 9D bars State governments from imposing any tax, cess or levy, by whatever name, on mineral rights or mineral-bearing lands, whether based on quantity, value, royalty or otherwise. Such levies are allowed only under conditions the Central Government prescribes.
  • Rule-making power. Section 13 is amended so the Centre can make rules prescribing the conditions or restrictions for State levies.
  • Past levies. Levies not yet paid or collected by the State before the amendment applies are treated as invalid. Amounts already deposited or recovered are not refundable.
  • Mineral-bearing lands. The Bill amends Section 2 to bring "mineral-bearing lands" under the Union's regulatory control.
  • Parliamentary passage. Both Houses of Parliament passed it on 13 August 2026.
  • Government's stated rationale. States impose around 14 taxes, charges and fees on mining, including royalty, auction premium, dead rent, DMF payments, GST and transit fee. Some States also tax mineral-bearing land, in certain cases at rates as high as 20 percent. The government sees a viable domestic mining sector as essential for energy security, critical-mineral security and lower import dependence.
  • Government's claim on State revenue. Nearly 90 per cent of mining-sector revenue currently accrues to the States. In its iron-ore example, at ₹3,000 per tonne the miner pays ₹3,150, of which ₹3,016 goes to the State. Major mineral States' revenue rose from ₹13,586.16 crore in FY 2013-14 to ₹82,366.19 crore in FY 2025-26.
  • What stays with States. Nearly 50 minor minerals, including sand, gravel, clay, silica, granite, marble, gypsum and laterite, remain entirely under State control. The government says States will continue to receive royalty, auction premium, DMF payments and their share of GST.
  • Criticisms on record. The Bill invalidates unpaid past levies but does not refund paid ones, which may create unequal treatment between companies and raise Article 14 concerns. Critics also say leaving the conditions and restrictions to executive rule-making is excessive delegation. One UPSC-coaching analysis says Jharkhand, Odisha, Chhattisgarh, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Karnataka draw 75–80% of their non-tax revenue from mining.
  • Suggested reform ideas. A GST-Council-style Mineral Taxation Council where the Union and States jointly decide floor and ceiling rates.

Mains dimensions

  • Federalism and fiscal autonomy: Soren's "why should Delhi decide" frames this as erosion of State taxing power. The Union argues Entry 50 itself makes State taxes "subject to" parliamentary limits, so the Act is within the constitutional design. Mineral-rich States have few autonomous revenue levers left after GST.
  • Judiciary–legislature dialogue: the Act follows MADA v. SAIL (2024), which upheld State power to tax. Parliament is using the limitation clause of Entry 50 to respond. Concerns have been raised about Parliament's power to restrict land taxation under Entry 49, and about the retrospective invalidation of unpaid levies.
  • Investment and critical minerals: uniform and predictable levies lower costs, support downstream steel, power and manufacturing, and keep critical-mineral extraction viable.
  • Political economy of the dispute: both sides trade allegations. The Minister alleges revenue leakage and "coal theft". The State alleges Centralisation. The article gives no independent evidence for either claim, so answers should treat them as positions, not findings.
  • Resource curse and social costs: mining regions bear forest loss, pollution and displacement. Reduced State revenue may squeeze remediation and welfare unless DMF and CAMPA-type funds are strengthened.
  • Way forward: a GST-Council-like Centre–State forum (or Inter-State Council, Article 263), statutory principles for ceilings rather than pure executive rules, and a time-bound compensation mechanism for mining-dependent States.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The MMDR Amendment Act, 2026 restricts State taxes on mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands. Examine its implications for fiscal federalism and the future of resource governance in India."

Related topics

  • Seventh Schedule and legislative relations (Articles 245–246); Article 301 (inter-State trade and commerce)
  • GST Council and cooperative federalism; Finance Commission devolution
  • District Mineral Foundation, PMKKKY, CAMPA
  • Inter-State Council (Article 263); Fifth Schedule and tribal rights in mining areas
  • Coal auctions, critical minerals mission and mineral auction regime

Topics: GS2Economy

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 27 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs