BrainParrot

India slams Sharif’s UN speech, asserts right to defend itself

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 27 September 2026

Summary

Pakistan PM Shehbaz Sharif's UNGA speech criticised Operation Sindoor, raised Kashmir and accused India of "weaponising water". India first used its Right of Reply on Friday night, through First Secretary Petal Gahlot. On Saturday EAM S. Jaishankar's National Statement firmly rebutted him, asserting India's right to defend itself against terrorism. He also used the platform to highlight the costs of the Ukraine and West Asia wars for the Global South. Meanwhile, US President Donald Trump shared a clip of Sharif thanking him for halting Operation Sindoor.

UPSC relevance: GS2 – International Relations (India–Pakistan, UN, Global South); GS3 – Security (terrorism)

Key facts for Prelims

  • UNGA: 193 members; one vote each; General Debate each September; 81st session (2026).
  • Right of Reply: procedural right in the UNGA to answer remarks about a State.
  • Indus Waters Treaty (1960): Eastern rivers (Ravi, Sutlej, Beas) to India; Western rivers (Indus, Jhelum, Chenab) to Pakistan with limited Indian use. India has held it in abeyance since the Pahalgam attack (April 2025).
  • Operation Sindoor: launched 7 May 2025 in retaliation for the Pahalgam attack of 22 April 2025.
  • UN Charter Article 51: inherent right of self-defence against armed attack.
  • Four Fs: Food, Fuel, Fertilizers, Finance (the impact channels Jaishankar named).
  • Two-state solution for Israel–Palestine is India's stated position.
  • The post-1945 order refers to the UN-centred global architecture created after WWII.

Data and details

  • Sequence: Sharif spoke on Friday; India's Right of Reply came Friday night (Petal Gahlot, First Secretary); Jaishankar's National Statement was on Saturday. Indian and Pakistani diplomats also exchanged sharp words earlier on Saturday.
  • Sharif's claims: Operation Sindoor criticised; Kashmir called Pakistan's "jugular vein"; India accused of human-rights violations in Kashmir and a "reign of terror" against minorities; India "weaponising water" by holding the IWT in abeyance; Trump's "timely intervention" credited; he thanked Trump's "resolute and visionary leadership".
  • Jaishankar's line: Sharif is a "serial practitioner of terrorism" who misrepresented facts. There can be "no dilution" of zero tolerance. India's right to defend against terrorism "will be exercised". States practising cross-border terrorism must be held to account.
  • On water: goodwill cannot co-exist with terrorism, so understandings premised on it will be questioned.
  • Gahlot's reply: Pakistan is a "puppet" regime with "falsehoods" and "deceit". Its capital is being fortified against its own people at the very moment of its speech. J&K is an integral part of India, "and will always remain so". "Terrorists will have nowhere to run, nowhere to hide."
  • Operation Sindoor: 7 May 2025, against terror infrastructure in Pakistan and PoK; Pahalgam attack on 22 April 2025 killed 26 civilians.
  • Global conflicts: wars in Ukraine and West Asia penalise countries "far from the conflicts" through the Four Fs. Those most affected have least say. Attacks on seafarers in both conflicts have killed 18 Indians. India has joined Liberia and 23 other partners to rally global opinion against such targeting.
  • Gaza: peace requires a two-state solution. India continues to send humanitarian relief.
  • Jaishankar says a multipolar world is coming and the post-1945 order must give way to "new realities".
  • Trump shared a video clip of Sharif's speech on social media.

Static–dynamic linkage

The UNGA is where States address each other and the world, and Right of Reply is the procedural tool for answering remarks. The news illustrates three static themes. First, India's doctrine on cross-border terrorism and self-defence. Second, treaty law and "abeyance" in the Indus Waters Treaty. Third, India's positioning as a voice of the Global South in a changing multipolar order.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: India and its neighbourhood, India's foreign policy, effect of policies of developed and developing countries, international institutions (UN) | GS3 – Security: terrorism and state sponsorship

Background primer

United Nations General Assembly (UNGA)

What it is:
the principal deliberative organ of the UN where all members are represented. The UN has 193 member countries.
Founded:
1945, with the UN, after the Second World War.
Members:
all member States, each with one vote. Resolutions are generally non-binding.
Mandate:
discussing global issues and recommending action. Each year opens with a General Debate. The 81st session's General Debate runs 22–28 September under the theme "Restoring trust, managing transformation: A United Nations that delivers for all."
Why it matters:
a universal forum where every member State can put its position before the world.

Indus Waters Treaty (IWT), 1960

What it is:
the water-sharing treaty between India and Pakistan. The three Eastern rivers (Ravi, Sutlej, Beas) go to India for unrestricted use, and the Western rivers (Indus, Jhelum, Chenab; average flow about 135 MAF) go to Pakistan, with India keeping limited domestic, non-consumptive and agricultural use.
Founded:
signed in 1960 after years of negotiation, with the World Bank as broker (textbook). Reason: apportioning the Indus basin after Partition.
Members:
bilateral, between India and Pakistan, with the World Bank as broker.
Mandate:
allocation of rivers and a dispute mechanism (Permanent Indus Commission, Neutral Expert, Court of Arbitration).
Why it matters:
cooperative management of shared transboundary river waters.

Operation Sindoor (May 2025) – doctrine

Additional context

  • IWT in abeyance. India placed the treaty in abeyance with immediate effect until Pakistan credibly and irrevocably abjures support for cross-border terrorism. The MEA reiterates that it remains in abeyance because of Pakistan's sponsorship of cross-border terrorism.

  • Legal contest. India rejects the jurisdiction of the Permanent Court of Arbitration and says that with the treaty in abeyance it is not bound to perform its obligations. Sharif told the UNGA that India's decision has "no legal basis" and that India's claims were rejected by UN experts and the Court of Arbitration.

  • Sharif's Friday speech. He said any attempt to stop, impede or divert Pakistan's Indus waters "will be treated as an act of war". He said Pakistan exercised self-defence under Article 51 of the UN Charter against "external aggression" and credited Trump's intervention with averting war.

  • India's Global South posture. At the 2025 UNGA Jaishankar described India as responsible for more than 600 development projects in 78 countries.

Mains dimensions

  • Terrorism and self-defence: India's formulation (no distinction between terrorists and sponsors, no nuclear blackmail) is being pressed at the UN. Its legal footing rests on Article 51 and attribution to a State. Pakistan invokes Article 51 too, so both sides claim self-defence.
  • Water as a lever: India links the IWT to terrorism ("friendship and goodwill cannot co-exist with terrorism"), while Pakistan frames it as "weaponising water" and an "act of war" if diverted. Issues include treaty-law concepts of abeyance vs. termination and the competence of the Court of Arbitration. Practical constraints in India include storage and project capacity.
  • Third-party mediation: Sharif credits Trump, and Trump amplified the clip. The reported Indian excerpts do not directly engage the mediation claim, though India's established position is bilateralism. This is a diplomatic sensitivity for India–US ties.
  • Global South leadership: Jaishankar's Four Fs framing positions India as a spokesperson for countries bearing conflict spillovers, supported by the seafarer-safety initiative.
  • UN reform and multipolarity: the call for the post-1945 order to give way to "new realities" ties to the Security Council reform debate.
  • Domestic–international link: accusations on Kashmir and minorities are met with a rebuttal on terrorism. Answers should separate rights-based criticism from state-sponsorship arguments.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "India has asserted its 'right to defend itself' against cross-border terrorism and placed the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance. Critically examine the legal and strategic implications of these steps for India–Pakistan relations."

Related topics

  • UN system: UNGA vs. UNSC; UN Charter Articles 2(4) and 51; UNSC reform
  • Indus Waters Treaty: Permanent Indus Commission, Neutral Expert, Court of Arbitration
  • Pahalgam attack, Operation Sindoor and India's counter-terror doctrine
  • Simla Agreement and bilateralism; Kashmir issue
  • Global South diplomacy: Voice of Global South Summit, G20, BRICS

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 27 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs