Govt. yet to decide how open-field caste data will be sorted, tabulated
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 26 September 2026
Summary
- More than a month after the second-phase 2027 Census questionnaire was notified with an open-column method for caste, officials say no decision has been taken on how to sort, tabulate and rationalise the data.
- Critics say the method may repeat the 2011 SECC's 46 lakh-plus caste names.
- Separately, the Registrar General & Census Commissioner reviewed the ongoing Population Enumeration phase in Ladakh, the first UT where phase two is under way.
Key facts for Prelims
- Census is a Union subject (Entry 69, Union List, Seventh Schedule). It is conducted under the Census Act, 1948 and Census Rules, 1990.
- Office: Registrar General & Census Commissioner of India (Ministry of Home Affairs).
- Census 2027: 16th Census; 8th after Independence; two phases; first fully digital.
- Caste enumeration: decided by the Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs on 30 April 2025; recorded in the Population Enumeration phase.
- Self-enumeration (a secure online portal) is offered for the first time. It is available in both phases, and a unique SE ID is generated for the enumerator to verify.
- Open-column method vs list-based method (Bihar and Telangana surveys).
- SECC 2011 is distinct from the Census.
- Rank/designation: Chief Principal Census Officer (CPCO) and Director of Census Operations.
Data and details
- The Phase-2 questionnaire is 40 questions, of which 13 are new compared with 2011 (which had 29). New items include caste, family particulars, ID proofs and COVID vaccinations.
- Caste option: non-SC/ST respondents write caste in an open column. They can opt for "no-caste" or not disclose.
- 2011 SECC: over 46 lakh different caste names, and the report was shelved by successive governments (per critics).
- Decision chain: Office of the RG&CCI proposal on sorting method → Union Home Secretary → Ministry or Union Cabinet. Each division of the Census office handles tabulation for its own questions.
- An official said discussions on making sense of the caste data have not begun and will take place as fieldwork progresses. Other new questions are also at various stages of discussion in the Census Commissioner's office.
- G.N. Devy: experts should ideally have been included while finalising the questions. That would have addressed doubts about post-collection analysis.
- Phase 2 has begun in Ladakh and in snow-bound parts of Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand and J&K. An image caption notes the phase was inaugurated across snow-bound areas in Udhampur on 1 Sept.
- Four-day visit to review Population Enumeration, covering remote and snow-bound areas, the Census mobile app and staff preparedness.
- Ladakh is the first State/UT where the second phase is under way ahead of the rest.
- An enumerator spends 30 to 60 minutes per household on the app. The exercise is to end by 30 Sept.
- He was accompanied by Amit Sharma, CPCO and Director of Census Operations for J&K and Ladakh.
- Field inspections: Nubra, Chumathang and Chushul (Nyoma). Enumerators gave feedback on the app, and authorities said it would be considered for future refinements.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Why the method matters. A closed list (the Bihar and Telangana surveys) bounds the categories, while an open column records what respondents say and then needs a classification step. That step decides how many castes appear, how OBC, EBC or SC groups are grouped, and what policy can be built on it.
- Link to policy. Census data feeds reservations, welfare targeting and delimitation. Caste data therefore carries policy weight beyond demography.
- Governance process. The decision chain runs from division-level methodology to the Registrar General's office, the Home Secretary and the Ministry or the Cabinet. This shows how the civil service and Cabinet handle sensitive statistical choices.
Syllabus mapping: GS1 – Society: population and caste; GS2 – Governance: government data systems and policy; Polity: Union subject (Census, Seventh Schedule).
Background primer
Census of India
- What it is:
- The largest administrative and statistical exercise in the world. It provides village, town and ward-level data on housing, demography, religion, SC/ST, language, literacy, economic activity, migration and fertility.
- Founded:
- The first non-synchronous census was conducted in 1872. Post-Independence it was given a statutory mandate in the Census Act of 1948. Census is a Union subject (Entry 69, Union List, Seventh Schedule).
- Mandate:
- Count the population and record socio-economic characteristics at the micro level.
- Why it matters:
- Evidence for planning, representation and welfare.
Census 2027
Additional context
- The Union Cabinet approved the scheme for conducting Census 2027 on 12 December 2025, at an outlay of Rs 11,718.24 crore.
- The reference date for most of the country is 00:00 hours of 1 March 2027. For Ladakh and the snow-bound areas of J&K, Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand, it is 1 October 2026.
Mains dimensions
- Data quality: The 2011 SECC outcome (over 46 lakh names) shows the risk of spelling variations, synonyms, sub-castes and clan names. The open column needs a sound classification protocol before tabulation.
- Sequence problem: Fieldwork has started while sorting and tabulation are undecided. Critics (experts, Opposition, OBC associations) say this repeats the SECC experience. An official says the plan will emerge as fieldwork progresses.
- Expert consultation: Devy's point is that experts should have helped design the questions, to settle how analysis will work.
- Rights and privacy: The "no-caste" and non-disclosure options safeguard respondents but may produce gaps, which analysis must handle.
- Policy stakes: Caste data affects reservation debates, targeted welfare and political representation. Method choices may be contested for that reason.
- Technology and logistics: Digital collection, remote terrain and enumerator feedback loops (the Ladakh visit) show the execution side. The first fully digital census has to work in snow-bound areas.
- Federal cooperation: Teachers and State staff do the fieldwork, though the exercise is a Union subject.
Possible Mains question
**GS1/GS2, 15 marks:** "Caste enumeration in Census 2027 raises as many questions about method as about politics. Discuss the challenges of recording and classifying caste data and their implications for policy."
Related topics
- SECC 2011 and its outcome
- Census Act, 1948; Seventh Schedule (Union List) – Census
- Caste in earlier censuses (1931 as the last comprehensive caste count)
- Reservation framework (Articles 15(4), 16(4); OBC sub-categorisation)
- Delimitation and the constitutional freeze
- Bihar and Telangana caste surveys
- Digital governance and data privacy
Topics: GS1Polity
All current affairs of 26 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs