Should permanent membership, veto powers of the UNSC be abolished?
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 25 September 2026
Summary
- At the ongoing UN General Assembly (UNGA) session, France's President Emmanuel Macron (speaking on 22 September) renewed a push to "regulate" the use of the veto in the UN Security Council (UNSC) in humanitarian crises such as Sudan and Lebanon, and in cases of genocide. France treats the veto as a responsibility, not a privilege.
- Two JNU professors discuss whether permanent membership and the veto should be abolished, and what incremental reforms are realistic.
Key facts for Prelims
- P5: US, UK, France, China, Russia. The veto is codified in Article 27(3) of the UN Charter. The word "veto" is not in the Charter.
- Article 27(3): a party to a dispute abstains from voting (Chapter VI decisions).
- UNGA resolution 76/262 (2022): the Liechtenstein initiative. The General Assembly meets within 10 working days after a veto.
- French-Mexican initiative: launched in 2015. It asks P5 to voluntarily forgo the veto in atrocity situations.
- ACT Code of Conduct: Accountability, Coherence and Transparency. It is addressed to all Council members, not just the P5.
- Abolishing the veto needs a Charter amendment, with the consent of the P5.
- UNGA: the ongoing session; Macron spoke on 22 September.
Data and details
- France and Mexico announced this week that 128 states support the declaration, of which 21 joined in the last four months.
- The UK, another P5 member, has joined France in accepting the principle. For the first time, two of the five permanent members have committed to voluntary veto restraint.
- Syria civil war in 2013: Chinese and Russian vetoes blocked every Council resolution condemning Syria. After the August 2013 chemical weapons attack in Ghouta, then French President Francois Hollande proposed a "code of good conduct" at the UN.
- Current crises cited by France: Sudan, Lebanon, genocide cases. Gaza is raised by the moderator.
- Mattoo calls the French proposal "modest incremental" institutionally but potentially significant normatively.
- Singh notes France and the UK are not the heavyweights among the P5, so it is easier for them to take a principled position.
- Singh says none of the P5 is talking of eliminating the veto, and the five hold multiple versions of how to reform the Council.
- Mattoo: the strength of the ACT initiative is moral and political, not legally coercive.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Static concept: The UN Charter gives the five permanent members (P5: US, UK, France, China, Russia) the power to block substantive Council decisions. Abolishing the veto or adding permanent members needs a Charter amendment, which itself needs the consent of the P5. That is why reform proposals focus on political restraint and accountability.
- Distinction the article draws: Three questions are often conflated:
- the use of the veto;
- accountability for its use;
- structural reform of the Council.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: International institutions, their structure and mandate (UN, UNSC); India's stand on UNSC reform
Background primer
UN Security Council and the veto
- What it is:
- The UN organ with primary responsibility for international peace and security, with 15 members (5 permanent and 10 elected non-permanent).
Additional context
- The Liechtenstein initiative is General Assembly resolution A/RES/76/262, "Standing mandate for a General Assembly debate when a veto is cast in the Security Council". It was adopted by consensus in April 2022.
- The resolution decided that the General Assembly President would convene a formal meeting within 10 working days of a veto by one or more permanent members. It also invited the Council to submit a special report to the General Assembly.
- The resolution was co-sponsored by over 80 UN member states.
- Assessments of impact are mixed. India's statement at the UN General Assembly said the resolution has not been an effective deterrent, citing 24 vetoes cast on 20 draft resolutions since adoption (a count as of that statement; later UN debate statements cite higher totals). Another delegate noted that such a debate cannot reverse the negative impact of the veto on the affected country and region.
- Some states go further. One speaker at the General Assembly said that until the veto is abolished, it must be strictly regulated and its use in mass atrocities prohibited completely.
Mains dimensions
- Abolition is a non-starter: Formal abolition needs a Charter amendment consented to by the P5, the very members whose privilege would be removed. The realistic path is incremental change in political behaviour.
- Self-restraint (French-Mexican): It changes P5 behaviour without rewriting the Charter. Momentum is real (128 states, the UK on board). It is voluntary, and it leaves out the US, China and Russia. It addresses only the use of the veto, not accountability or structural reform.
- Accountability route (Liechtenstein): It makes a vetoing state explain itself to all UN members. This does not stop a veto where real national interest is at stake, but it makes P5 more cautious.
- Multiple overlapping approaches: Abolition, extending the veto to new permanent members (in the name of equality), voluntary restraint, political accountability and broader structural reform. The debate should not be reduced to "retain or abolish".
- Power realism vs. sovereign equality: Singh argues that no organisation survives a decision against a major power's core interests. The Syria paralysis of 2013 shows the cost of veto use, and also why the P5 would not accept being overruled.
- P5 divisions: France and the UK move toward restraint while Russia, the US and China resist. This split is shaped by relative power and by interpretation of conflicts. Singh says words like honesty and justice are among the most misused in international relations.
- India's interest: India seeks a permanent seat. The article notes proposals to extend the veto to new permanent members. India's position should weigh restraint initiatives against its own reform goals.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Regulating the veto may be more feasible than abolishing it. Examine the initiatives on veto restraint and accountability in the UN Security Council and their implications for the reform agenda, including India's aspirations."
Related topics
- UN Charter: Chapters V, VI and VII; Articles 23, 27 and 108–109 (amendment)
- Uniting for Peace resolution (1950)
- G4, L.69 and Uniting for Consensus (UfC) groupings; Ezulwini Consensus; IGN (Intergovernmental Negotiations on UNSC reform)
- India's bid for permanent UNSC membership
- Responsibility to Protect (R2P); International Criminal Court
- UN Pact for the Future (2024)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 25 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs