BrainParrot

SC reserves orders on plea over OBC creamy layer policy

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 25 September 2026

Summary

  • A Supreme Court Bench of Justices P.S. Narasimha and R. Mahadevan reserved orders on the Centre's application. The Centre wants the 11 March 2026 judgment (Union of India v. Rohith Nathan) applied prospectively, and two years to frame a uniform policy on creamy layer status.
  • The judgment required re-assessing OBC non-creamy layer status under the 1993 Office Memorandum, which excludes parental salary income and agricultural income from the income/wealth test.
  • The Centre warned that retrospective implementation would cause administrative chaos; the candidates' counsel said it was an attempt to delay or undo a final judgment.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity/Social Justice: Reservation, OBC creamy layer, Art. 142

Key facts for Prelims

  • Creamy layer introduced by Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992) — upheld 27% OBC reservation under Art. 16(4); 50% ceiling; creamy layer exclusion.
  • DoPT Office Memorandum of 8 September 1993 prescribes creamy layer criteria; Ram Nandan Prasad Committee recommended them.
  • Under the 1993 OM, parental salary income and agricultural income are excluded from the Category VI income/wealth test.
  • Art. 142: Supreme Court's power to do "complete justice". Art. 16(4): reservation for backward classes not adequately represented in State services.
  • Supernumerary posts: additional posts created to accommodate candidates without displacing others.
  • DoPT = Department of Personnel and Training; OBC-NCL = OBC non-creamy layer.

Data and details

  • Judgment under challenge: 11 March 2026, Union of India v. Rohith Nathan. It directed DoPT to create supernumerary posts within six months for eligible OBC-NCL candidates wrongly denied service allocation because of improper creamy layer classification.
  • Centre's plea (represented by SG Tushar Mehta and ASG Aishwarya Bhati): prospective operation of the judgment, so that ongoing and past recruitment is not affected; and a "reasonable time" of two years to establish equivalence of posts, consult stakeholders and frame a uniform policy or mechanism.
  • Centre's argument on retrospectivity: affects "lakhs" of cases across recruitment, service allocation, cadre allocation, seniority, admissions and OBC reservation administration; allocations since 2012; railways, banks, postal service, paramilitary forces; higher education admissions and ongoing examinations; and employees who were not parties to the litigation.
  • Candidates' side (senior advocate P. Wilson): the Centre is merely trying to delay, even undo, a final judgment.
  • Background: the 2004 DoPT clarification counted salaries of parents in PSUs, banks and private companies, but ignored salaries of government employees in equivalent posts. Wards of PSU employees were therefore disqualified from OBC benefits.
  • Outcome: the Bench reserved orders.

Static–dynamic linkage

The "creamy layer" rule keeps reservation for the genuinely backward by excluding the socially and economically advanced within OBCs. Under Art. 142 the Supreme Court can do "complete justice", including limiting the temporal effect of its own rulings. The Centre's plea is an invitation to use that power to avoid disturbing settled appointments while the government fixes the policy gap the Court identified.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Judiciary (Art. 142, binding effect of judgments), reservation and Art. 14/15/16; GS2 – Social Justice: Welfare of backward classes.

Background primer

OBC creamy layer

What it is:
A concept introduced by the Supreme Court in Indra Sawhney (1992): while upholding 27% reservation for OBCs, it directed the exclusion of the socially and economically advanced sections within them.
Why it matters:
Relative equality; reservation benefits must reach the most deserving within the backward classes.

Art. 142 and prospective operation

Additional context

  • The 11 March 2026 judgment (reported as 2026 INSC 230) held that the DoPT's 14 October 2004 clarificatory letter could not override the 8 September 1993 Office Memorandum. Para 9 of that letter, which brought in PSU/private-sector salary income, was struck down. The Court also held that a parent's PSU or private-sector salary cannot by itself be the determinative criterion for creamy layer exclusion.
  • The litigation arose from civil services candidates whose parents worked in PSUs or the private sector. They were treated as creamy layer because the department applied the Category VI income/wealth test to parental salary, since equivalence of their parents' posts with government posts had not been established. The Central Administrative Tribunal had held that, under the 1993 OM, salary and agricultural income stood excluded from the income/wealth test.
  • Unlike the OBC creamy layer test, which excludes salary and agricultural income, the EWS quota (introduced in 2019) counts these incomes.

Mains dimensions

  • Finality of judgments vs. administrative feasibility: The Centre invokes Art. 142 to prevent "administrative chaos"; the candidates say the plea reopens a final judgment. Courts usually protect finality, but they have limited retrospective effect where there is large-scale reliance (appointees who were not parties).
  • Discrimination within the OBC class: The 2004 clarification created a hostile classification: PSU/private employees' salaries were counted, while salaries of government employees in equivalent posts were ignored. That is arguably an Art. 14 problem, which is why the Court had to correct it.
  • Equivalence-of-posts gap: The 1993 OM envisaged determining equivalence between government and PSU/bank/private posts, but it has remained incomplete for over three decades. The Centre's request for two more years is open to criticism on that ground.
  • Reservation design: Status-based criteria vs. income criteria; the income ceiling was last revised in 2017 to Rs 8 lakh, and OBC (salary excluded) and EWS (salary included) rules differ; there are calls for a single uniform and periodically revised creamy layer policy.
  • Impact on stakeholders: Candidates wrongly excluded (denied service allocation), those already appointed, the services and employers (railways, banks, postal, paramilitary), and universities.
  • Way forward: Prospective relief for current appointees combined with a firm timeline and reservation of vacancies (supernumerary posts) for wronged candidates; a transparent equivalence exercise; and periodic review by the National Commission for Backward Classes.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The creamy layer principle seeks to ensure that the benefits of reservation reach the truly backward. Discuss the challenges in its implementation, with reference to the recent Supreme Court verdict on parental income and salary."

Related topics

  • Indra Sawhney (1992), Mandal Commission, Art. 15(4), 15(5), 16(4), 16(4A)
  • EWS reservation (103rd Amendment; Janhit Abhiyan 2022) and its income criteria
  • Jarnail Singh (creamy layer for SC/ST promotions) and Sub-categorisation of OBCs (Rohini Commission)
  • National Commission for Backward Classes (Art. 338B)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 25 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs