Policing the line between publicity and justice
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 25 September 2026
Summary
- Photographs of arrested persons, often handcuffed, flanked by police and sometimes garlanded with placards listing the alleged crime, now spread on social media within minutes of an arrest. This often happens before the accused is produced before a magistrate.
- A PIL in the Supreme Court seeks a nationwide media protocol and rules for police media briefings. The article argues the legal basis for this practice is weak and that a codified national protocol is needed.
Key facts for Prelims
- BNSS 2023, Section 84 corresponds to CrPC Section 82 (proclamation of absconders). It is a judicial process triggered after a warrant fails.
- The Police Act, 1861 is the base for State Police Regulations on rewards. Sanction runs from the SHO up to the State government. No warrant or proclamation is needed.
- Criminal Procedure (Identification) Act, 2022: covers taking, storage and use of measurements, including photographs. It is silent on circulating them.
- Article 21 and the presumption of innocence are the constitutional anchor.
- Juvenile in conflict with the law: no identification except in the child's best interest and with Juvenile Justice Board permission. A sexual-assault survivor's identity is protected by law.
- Bureau of Police Research and Development (BPR&D) drafted the manual on media briefings by police personnel.
- Terms: "Hue and Cry Notice", "Station House Officer (SHO)", "amicus curiae".
Data and details
- BPR&D shared the draft manual with MHA in July 2024.
- In January 2026 the Supreme Court said the amicus had prepared a Police Manual for Media Briefing. It directed States to evolve policies within three months.
- The Rajasthan High Court called such circulation "institutional humiliation".
- Photographs and reward notices have solved crimes, helped recover missing children and brought fugitives to book years after trails went cold.
- Comparison: American law treats "wanted" notices as public-record exceptions to privacy law, but agencies are trained to say "alleged" or "wanted for questioning". British policing withholds arrested persons' identities altogether.
- Proposed protocol elements:
- a uniform national protocol across States;
- blackout categories (juveniles, sexual-offence complainants);
- time-bound review and takedown once the investigative purpose ends, or on discharge or acquittal.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Static concept: Article 21 includes the right to a fair trial and the presumption of innocence. Police powers must rest on a valid law (procedure established by law), not on habit or inherited practice.
- Gap in the law: No statute expressly permits or bars police from publishing photographs of an accused. The practice rests on a patchwork of colonial-era police manuals and regulations, and general criminal procedure.
- The test the article proposes: A photograph should go public only if disclosure is necessary to the investigation, and not merely convenient to the police narrative. This is a proportionality test.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Judiciary, fundamental rights (Article 21), police reforms; GS2 – Governance: transparency vs. due process; GS3 – Internal Security (police administration)
Background primer
Police media briefing / "media trial" framework (Supreme Court-driven)
- What it is:
- A set of rules, still being built, on what police may tell the media and the public about criminal cases under investigation. The aim is to protect the accused's fair-trial rights and the victim's dignity.
- Founded:
- The Supreme Court's 2023 order asked the Ministry of Home Affairs to prepare a comprehensive manual. The BPR&D draft went to MHA in July 2024. In January 2026 the court noted the amicus's Police Manual for Media Briefing and told States to frame policies on it within three months. The 2023 order is not in the article; it was confirmed from the Supreme Court's 13 September 2023 order. The BPR&D draft and the January 2026 direction are from the article.
- Members:
- There is no new body. The manual binds State police forces once States adopt policies. The Supreme Court is supervising through the PIL, with an amicus curiae assisting.
- Mandate:
- Separate legitimate investigative disclosure (tracing absconders, finding witnesses) from publicity that prejudges guilt. Hard limits already exist for juveniles in conflict with the law (identification only in the child's best interest and with Juvenile Justice Board permission) and for sexual-assault survivors.
- Why it matters:
- The presumption of innocence. Digital circulation is permanent, searchable and indifferent to a later acquittal, so harm can be irreversible.
Legal sources the article lists for police publicity
Additional context
- In its September 2023 order, the Supreme Court said the Ministry of Home Affairs should prepare a comprehensive manual on media briefings by police personnel. It asked all State DGPs to send their suggestions to the Ministry. It also directed that media organisations and the NHRC's views be taken into account.
- The January 15 order noted the work of amicus Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan. The 60-page manual has four parts and aims at a principled, rights-compatible and investigation-safe framework for police–public–media communication. A bench of Justices M M Sundresh and N Kotiswar Singh was hearing the batch of petitions.
- The amicus's earlier suggestions to the court included a Media Briefing Cell in each district or town, with press interactions in writing and authorised by a senior police officer.
- The 2023 order stressed that police disclosures must be objective and must not carry subjective opinion that pre-judges the accused's guilt.
Mains dimensions
- Legality gap: The practice rests on colonial manuals, the broad Hue and Cry language and administrative discretion. The Identification Act is wrongly cited as enabling publication. The article argues for a clear legal basis, not "a habit inherited from mere precedent".
- Rights vs. utility: Publicity solves crimes, but the presumption of innocence and Article 21 are strained when an unconvicted adult's face circulates as a fait accompli of guilt. Online circulation is permanent and survives acquittal.
- Purpose-based scale: Legitimate investigative need (crime prevention, public order, tracing absconders, finding witnesses) sits at one end. Showcasing police achievements sits at the other. The latter serves police optics at the accused's expense and can prejudice public opinion before trial.
- Federal and institutional angle: Police is a State subject, so practice varies. The Supreme Court asked States to frame policies, and the article argues for uniformity.
- Comparative models: The US uses careful "alleged" framing. The UK withholds identities. India needs a middle path, with proportionate disclosure rather than a ban.
- Way forward:
- codified national protocol;
- necessity test before release;
- blackout categories;
- takedown on discharge or acquittal;
- accountability for officers who flout it.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Police publication of photographs of arrested persons raises a conflict between investigative utility and the presumption of innocence. Examine the existing legal framework and suggest a rights-compatible protocol."
Related topics
- Article 21: fair trial, dignity, right to reputation
- Media trial; Contempt of Court Act and sub judice
- Juvenile Justice Act, 2015; Section 228A IPC (now BNS) on victim identity
- Police reforms (Prakash Singh case); Police Act, 1861 and State Police Acts
- BNSS 2023 vs CrPC 1973; Criminal Procedure (Identification) Act, 2022
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 25 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs