BrainParrot

India and the plausible multilateralism of BRICS

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 24 September 2026

Summary

  • The editorial argues that the 18th BRICS summit (New Delhi, 12–13 Sept 2026) was a success. India secured consensus in the Delhi Declaration among 11 members despite the West Asia war and rivalries.
  • It argues BRICS gives India room for strategic autonomy. India can restore its West Asia balancing posture, keep engaging China, and avoid becoming a frontline in US–China rivalry.
  • It holds that BRICS's internal divisions prevent domination by any one member, while external convergence keeps the group together.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — International Relations: BRICS, strategic autonomy, India–US/China/West Asia

Key facts for Prelims

  • BRICS: 2006 formalised; first summit Yekaterinburg 2009; South Africa joined 2011; expanded to 11 members (incl. Iran, UAE, Egypt, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Saudi Arabia).
  • NDB: Shanghai HQ; set up at 2014 Fortaleza summit; $100 bn authorised and $50 bn subscribed capital; CRA is the companion liquidity arrangement.
  • 18th BRICS Summit: New Delhi, 12–13 Sept 2026; India's fourth BRICS chairship; outcome: New Delhi Declaration.
  • G-7 vs BRICS: G-7 members accept western order and American primacy (editorial's contrast); BRICS does not.
  • SCO's Bishkek resolution (September) condemned the strikes on Iran.
  • Strategic autonomy / multi-alignment ("sabke sath" formulation).

Data and details

  • Timeline: US and Israel launched war on Iran on February 28, 2026. The Delhi summit was the first BRICS summit since then. Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei was assassinated.
  • Attendance: Presidents of Iran, Russia and China, among others. India is a close strategic partner of the US and Israel.
  • Consensus: 11 members, including UAE and Iran, which are in an "undeclared conflict".
  • Modi's visit: PM Modi was in Israel two days before the bombing began. India initially refrained from condemning the attacks or the assassination.
  • Pakistan's move: it stepped in as mediator between the US and Iran while India watched from the sidelines.
  • India's repositioning: endorsed SCO's Bishkek resolution in September, hosted President Masoud Pezeshkian, and the Modi–Pezeshkian hand-in-hand image is unlikely to be forgotten in Washington or Tel Aviv.
  • US pressure: India was hit by "varying tariffs" a few months ago and was among the countries most affected economically by the war. On September 16, the US House passed the Russia sanctions Bill seeking tariffs of up to 100% on countries including India.
  • China: border problems "continue to simmer", but there is momentum to reset ties. BRICS lets India and China stay engaged when high-level bilateral visits are not taking place.
  • Convergence: on AI regulation, trade and finance rules, climate change, border conflicts and multilateral bodies, members differ on approach but share opposition to unilateralism.
  • Examples of frontline costs: Pakistan, UAE and Ukraine. Ukraine has fought Russia (NATO-backed) for more than four years and has no direct platform with Moscow; its options depend on Brussels and Washington.
  • UAE–Iran bilateral meeting on the Delhi sidelines: an acknowledgement of the value of multilateral platforms.
  • Modi's early statement about overcoming the "hesitation of history" with Washington, versus India's "hesitations of its strategic realism".
  • Editorial claims: US approach is predictable (dominance), and recently it is "pushing the envelope" to draw India into a subordinate relationship. The editorial calls the war "unprovoked", which is the authors' characterisation.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Static concept: strategic autonomy, non-alignment and multi-alignment in India's foreign policy, and the role of plurilateral groupings (BRICS, SCO, Quad) in reforming global governance.
  • The editorial treats the Delhi summit as an instance of India's "multi-alignment" (the 'sabke sath' formulation). India pursues several partnerships at once instead of choosing a camp.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: bilateral/regional/global groupings and agreements affecting India; effects of policies of developed countries on India; India and its neighbourhood; GS3 – Economy: multilateral development finance

Background primer

BRICS

What it is:
A grouping of major emerging markets and developing countries. The 2026 chair's page lists eleven members: Brazil, China, Egypt, Ethiopia, India, Indonesia, Iran, Russia, Saudi Arabia, South Africa and the UAE.
Founded:
BRIC was formalised at the first meeting of BRIC Foreign Ministers on the sidelines of UNGA in New York in 2006. The inaugural summit was in Yekaterinburg, Russia, in 2009. South Africa joined as a full member in 2011, turning BRIC into BRICS.
Mandate:
Political coordination and development cooperation. The agenda broadened from economics to development, finance, health, climate, technology and trade. There is no permanent secretariat or voting-rule structure like the UN or G-7; decisions are by consensus.
Why it matters:
The founding members shared an aspiration for a more representative and equitable global order.

New Development Bank (NDB), the main BRICS institution

Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO)

Additional context

  • India hosted the 18th BRICS Summit as its fourth chairship, under the theme "Building for Resilience, Innovation, Cooperation and Sustainability". It ended with unanimous adoption of the New Delhi Declaration.
  • The summit was held at Bharat Mandapam and marked the 20th anniversary of BRICS.
  • The Declaration records China's and Russia's support for the aspirations of Brazil and India to play a greater role in the UN, including the Security Council.
  • It called for a restored two-tier WTO dispute settlement mechanism and opposed unilateral tariffs and measures such as CBAM.
  • It promoted settlement and investment in BRICS local currencies rather than creating a single top-down currency.
  • It called for swift adoption of the Comprehensive Convention on International Terrorism (CCIT).
  • Members noted support for India's proposal to host a BRICS Risk Lab at GIFT City.
  • Members stopped short of turning the group into an ideological anti-Western coalition.
  • The Declaration proposed a BRICS Implementation Mechanism via the Troika.

Mains dimensions

  • Strategic autonomy: India's concern is to avoid becoming a frontline in the US–China contest. BRICS gives space to pursue this without an anti-US agenda or damaging US cooperation.
  • Balancing West Asia: India initially refrained from condemning the strikes, then repositioned through SCO and BRICS. Multilateral platforms let it restore balance without bilateral damage. The UAE–Iran meeting is an example of using such platforms to ease bilateral disputes.
  • Managing China: Continued engagement, bilateral and multilateral, creates "guardrails for competitive coexistence". The editorial warns that lack of engagement deepens mistrust and the security dilemma.
  • US relations: Tariffs and the Russia sanctions Bill that could hit India at up to 100% show the cost of dependence on a single partner, though the editorial says the US partnership remains important.
  • Internal contradictions as strength: Divisions stop any single country (Russia or China) from dominating. Shared belief that the post-war order is unfair gives the group coherence. The authors use a dialectical argument.
  • Three schools of thought (as the editorial frames the debate): optimists see BRICS as an institution that could multipolarise the global order or speed that transition; sceptics stress its internal divisions and fear Russian/Chinese domination; a third group dismisses it as an annual gathering of "strategic noise" and urges India to focus on its US partnership instead.
  • Critical view: Sceptics say BRICS is open to Russian/Chinese domination and may jeopardise the US partnership. The editorial notes the Delhi consensus came through compromises by all parties, including India. A balanced answer would also note limited institutional capacity, differing member interests, and that consensus declarations may be vague on contested issues.
  • Way forward: Use chairship to push Global South priorities (UN and IMF reform, local-currency payments, DPI), while keeping BRICS "non-Western rather than anti-Western".

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "BRICS enables India to pursue strategic autonomy amid intensifying great-power rivalry. Critically examine, in light of the 2026 New Delhi summit."

Related topics

  • India's foreign policy: non-alignment, strategic autonomy, multi-alignment
  • SCO, Quad, G-20, G-7; UN Security Council reform
  • New Development Bank and Contingent Reserve Arrangement; IMF quota and WTO Appellate Body issues
  • India–China border management; West Asia and India's energy security; CBAM and unilateral trade measures

Topics: GS2Economy

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 24 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs