BrainParrot

The Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2026

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: PRS Legislative Research · Read the original ↗

Summary

  • The Bill was introduced in Lok Sabha on August 10, 2026 (PRS lists its status as Passed). It restricts states' power to tax mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands.
  • The restriction responds to the Supreme Court's 2024 ruling that states can tax mineral rights and mineral-bearing land.
  • It invalidates unpaid or unrecovered pre-commencement state levies. Amounts already paid are not refunded.
  • PRS flags three constitutional issues: legislative competence over mineral-bearing land, the retrospective override of the 2024 judgment, and excessive delegation.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Federalism, legislative competence; GS3 — Economy: mining sector

Key facts for Prelims

  • Entry 54 (Union List): regulation of mines and mineral development.
  • Entry 23 (State List): states' regulation of mines and mineral development, subject to the Union List.
  • Entry 50 (State List): taxes on mineral rights, subject to limitations imposed by Parliament by law.
  • Entry 49 (State List): taxes on lands and buildings.
  • Entry 18 (State List): land.
  • The MMDR Act, 1957 is the principal central law for mines and minerals.
  • Major minerals are regulated by the Centre and minor minerals by states. Concessions are granted by states under Centre-set rules, and the Centre fixes royalty.
  • 2024 Supreme Court (MADA v. SAIL):
  • Royalty is not a tax. It is a payment arising from the contractual obligation to enjoy mineral rights.
  • States can tax mineral rights, but Parliament can limit this by law, including by prohibition.
  • The MMDR Act contains no such restriction.
  • States' power to tax land covers mines and quarries, with mineral value, produce, quantity or royalty payable as the measure. Parliament cannot limit this.
  • Article 366(28) defines "taxation" and was the test the Court applied to royalty.
  • The Bill defines "mineral-bearing land" as land with mineral content per parameters the central government prescribes.
  • The Bill adds the central government's power to regulate mineral-bearing lands. It bars states from levying any tax, cess or levy on mineral rights or mineral-bearing lands except per central conditions.
  • Constitutional principles PRS cites:
  • Parliament may retrospectively alter a law's basis but cannot nullify a judicial decision by simply declaring it invalid (State of Haryana v. Karnal Co-op Farmers' Society, 1993).
  • Essential legislative functions cannot be delegated (Re Delhi Laws Act, 1951).
  • Article 14 prohibits arbitrary classification.

Key points

  • The Bill amends the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (MMDR Act) to bring "mineral bearing land" under central government regulation.
  • It bars state governments from taxing mineral rights or mineral bearing land except in accordance with conditions the central government prescribes.
  • Unpaid or unrecovered state dues on such levies from before the Bill's commencement are deemed invalid; amounts already collected will not be refunded.
  • PRS flags four constitutional concerns: possible lack of legislative competence over mineral bearing land, potentially unconstitutional retrospective negation of a 2024 Supreme Court judgment, possible Article 14 violation from treating compliant and non-compliant taxpayers unequally, and possible excessive delegation to the executive in prescribing state taxation limits.

Understanding the topic

Data and details

  • Introduced August 10, 2026. 2024 judgment dated July 25, 2024.
  • The Court directed tax demands could be raised for the period beginning April 1, 2005, with a phased payment schedule.
  • Statement of Objects and Reasons lists five problems with state levies:
  • A heavy tax burden on mining.
  • Unpredictable post-commencement taxes, cess and levies.
  • Multiple levies on production or dispatch.
  • Non-uniform rates across states.
  • Retrospective imposition.
  • The SoOR says these raise mining costs, discourage extraction and can make operations commercially unviable.
  • Unpaid or unrecovered pre-commencement dues are deemed invalid. Levies already deposited or recovered are not refunded.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The Seventh Schedule splits mining and taxation powers across lists:
    • Parliament may regulate mines and mineral development to the extent it declares expedient in the public interest (Union List, Entry 54).
    • States regulate mines and mineral development subject to the Union List (State List, Entry 23).
    • States tax mineral rights "subject to" limitations Parliament imposes by law relating to mineral development (State List, Entry 50).
    • States tax land (State List, Entry 49) and legislate on land (State List, Entry 18).
  • The question is whether a Union "mineral development" law can cap state taxation. The Court says yes for mineral rights (Entry 50) but not for land (Entry 49).
  • Article 265 says no tax can be levied or collected except by authority of law. The law must be within the legislature's competence and consistent with the Constitution.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Federalism, Union–State legislative relations, separation of powers; GS3 – Economy: Mineral resources and industry

Background primer

Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (MMDR Act)

What it is:
the principal central law governing development and regulation of mines and minerals.
Founded:
enacted in 1957 under Parliament's Entry 54 power. Its purpose is the conservation and systematic development of minerals.

Mineral Area Development Authority v. SAIL (2024)

What it is:
a nine-judge Constitution Bench judgment of July 25, 2024.

Additional context

  • On August 14, 2024, the Supreme Court rejected the plea to give the 2024 judgment only prospective effect. It directed that state tax demands must not operate on transactions before April 1, 2005. Payment was to be staggered in instalments over twelve years starting April 1, 2026. This is the past-period arrangement that the Bill's invalidation provision overrides.
  • The Bill inserts a new Section 9D in the MMDR Act. It bars states from imposing taxes or levies on mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands, whether based on quantity, value or royalty, except as permitted by central conditions. It also amends Section 13 so the Centre can make rules prescribing those conditions or restrictions.
  • PIB states that the Bill has been passed by both Houses of Parliament.

Mains dimensions

  • Fiscal federalism: the Bill takes back from states a taxing space the Constitution Bench recognised. It centralises a resource-linked revenue stream and raises the "who owns the resource rent" question.
  • Legislative competence: the Court held Entry 54 is a general regulatory power. Its limitation power operates on mineral-rights taxation (Entry 50), not on land taxation (Entry 49). Regulating "mineral bearing lands" and capping land-linked levies may therefore exceed Parliament's competence.
  • Retrospectivity and separation of powers: the Bill invalidates dues the Court allowed from April 1, 2005. PRS argues it overrides the Court's directions without altering the basis of the judgment, contrary to the 1993 principle.
  • Article 14: defaulters get relief while those who paid cannot recover. The scheme rewards non-payment, which is arguably arbitrary.
  • Excessive delegation: states may tax only per "conditions or restrictions" the Centre prescribes, with no guiding principles in the Bill.
  • Economic rationale: industry certainty and a uniform national mining regime versus state revenue autonomy. The dissent's concern about unhealthy inter-state competition supports uniformity.
  • Way forward: a legislated, principled cap or a cooperative mechanism (for example via the GST-style council model) to reconcile uniformity and autonomy.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Supreme Court in 2024 recognised states' power to tax mineral rights and mineral-bearing land. Critically examine the constitutional and federal issues raised by the MMDR Amendment Bill, 2026."

Related topics

  • Seventh Schedule: Union, State and Concurrent Lists; residuary power
  • Fiscal federalism; GST Council; Article 265 and taxing powers
  • Doctrine of colourable legislation and legislative override of judgments
  • Delegated legislation and excessive delegation
  • Mineral auctions, the District Mineral Foundation and the National Mineral Exploration Trust

Topics: GS2Passed

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 13 August 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs