BrainParrot

Former CEC calls for disclosure of SIR decision records

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 21 November 2026

Summary

  • Former CEC S.Y. Quraishi gave the 17th V.M. Tarkunde Memorial Lecture in Delhi on "Constitutional Institutions of India: Where Are They Headed?". He warned that the ECI's credibility "may take years, perhaps decades, to repair".
  • He said the ECI, judiciary and executive need strong safeguards against misuse of power. He listed the strains on the ECI as follows.
    • Credibility has been under strain since 2019.
    • The 2024 Lok Sabha turnout-figure controversy.
    • Former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa's dissent.
    • Concerns over the SIR.
  • Using West Bengal as his example, he called for an independent audit of the SIR, disclosure of decision records and digital audit trails, and restoration of names deleted without lawful authority.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Election Commission, electoral roll revision (SIR), constitutional institutions

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 324(1): superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament and State Legislatures vests in the ECI.
  • RP Act, 1950, Section 21(3) empowers the ECI to order a special revision of the roll. Section 16 disqualifies a non-citizen from enrolment.
  • Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 lay down the procedures for enrolment and revision.
  • Article 326: universal adult suffrage for citizens aged 18+ who are not disqualified by law.
  • Mohinder Singh Gill v. CEC (1977) upheld the ECI's broad Article 324 powers, with judicial review restricted during elections under Article 329(b).
  • The ECI is a constitutional body; the CEC is removable only like a Supreme Court judge (Article 324(5)).

Data and details

  • West Bengal: 27 lakh voters deleted during adjudication. Of these, 22 lakh appealed for restoration (roughly four-fifths).
  • Only 1,607 names were restored before the Assembly election, because hearings had not been held. The overwhelming majority could not vote.
  • Quraishi said the Supreme Court could have allowed the 2.7 million affected persons to vote given the size of the number.
  • Appellate tribunal decisions reportedly found 93% of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions incorrect.
  • ECI credibility is said to have been under strain since 2019.
  • The 2024 Lok Sabha turnout-figure controversy and Ashok Lavasa's dissent are named as aggravating factors.
  • Demands: independent audit of the SIR, disclosure of decision records and digital audit trails, restoration of names deleted without lawful authority.
  • Event: 17th V.M. Tarkunde Memorial Lecture, Delhi, theme "Constitutional Institutions of India: Where Are They Headed?".

Static–dynamic linkage

Article 324 gives the ECI superintendence, direction and control over the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections. Article 326 ties the franchise to adult citizens not otherwise disqualified. The Representation of the People Act, 1950 supplies the statutory machinery for roll revision. Wide discretion without transparent reasoning, records and appeal makes decisions hard to audit. That is why the speaker asks for disclosure of "decision records" and "digital audit trails". The question is how much of the Commission's constitutional autonomy is matched by accountability.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional/statutory bodies (ECI); Representation of the People Act; electoral reforms; GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability.

Background primer

Election Commission of India (ECI)

What it is:
A constitutional body (Article 324) that runs elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President. It also prepares and revises electoral rolls.
Founded:
25 January 1950, under the original Constitution, to run free and fair elections for the new Republic.
Members:
Chief Election Commissioner plus other Election Commissioners, appointed by the President. Under Article 324(5) the CEC cannot be removed except in the manner and on the grounds applicable to a Supreme Court judge. Appointments are now governed by the 2023 Act on CEC/EC appointment.
Mandate:
Superintendence, direction and control of elections and electoral rolls, along with delimitation support, party registration and the Model Code of Conduct.
Why it matters:
An independent umpire insulated from the executive, so that elections are free and fair.

Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls

What it is:
A focused, time-bound, house-to-house exercise ordered by the ECI to update and verify the accuracy of electoral rolls, as opposed to the routine summary revision.
Why it matters:
To remove deceased, shifted and duplicate entries, and to include all eligible citizens.

Additional context

  • Supreme Court on SIR: In ADR vs. ECI (27 May 2026, 2026 INSC 564), the Court upheld the Bihar SIR. It held that the Commission can order SIR under Article 324 read with Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950 and the 1960 Rules, and that the exercise met the proportionality test. The ECI may inquire into citizenship for the limited purpose of enrolment. A deletion on that ground does not declare the person a non-citizen, because citizenship is for the competent authority to decide. The Court ordered the ECI to refer persons deleted on citizenship grounds to the competent authority within four weeks.
  • Procedural safeguards in the SIR framework: As described in the Supreme Court's judgment summary on the Bihar SIR, doubtful entries after the draft roll require a show-cause notice, a chance to respond and a reasoned order. A two-tier appellate mechanism exists under Section 24 of the RP Act. The Court also directed the ECI to publish the list of excluded electors with reasons. The ECI also asks political parties to appoint Booth Level Agents (BLAs). These are the mechanisms against which the demand for an independent audit and decision records is made.
  • Phasing: Phase I was Bihar (order of 24 June 2025), ahead of the Assembly election held in November 2025. Phase II covered 12 States/UTs, including West Bengal. Phase III, ordered on 14 May 2026, covers 16 States and 3 UTs (including Delhi). Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh were left for a later schedule.

Mains dimensions

  • Institutional credibility: Quraishi dates the strain on the ECI to 2019 and cites the 2024 turnout figures, Lavasa's dissent and the SIR. Public trust is central to the ECI's authority as a constitutional umpire.
  • Disenfranchisement vs roll purity: The roll-cleaning goal is legitimate. In West Bengal, though, 22 lakh appealed and only 1,607 were restored before polling, so a very large number could not vote. A deletion that cannot be heard in time becomes a de facto loss of the franchise.
  • Quality of adjudication: If tribunals later found 93% of over 1.2 lakh exclusions incorrect, the original decisions were poor. This supports the call for decision records and audit trails to test the process.
  • Judicial role: Quraishi suggested the Supreme Court could have let the 2.7 million vote. This raises the question of how far courts should use their powers to secure the franchise when administrative remedies are slow.
  • Accountability: Autonomy under Article 324 needs matching transparency, such as independent audit, reasoned orders and traceable digital decisions. Safeguards against misuse apply to the judiciary and executive as well.
  • Way forward: Independent audit, publication of reasons, time-bound hearings before polls, and restoration of unlawfully deleted names.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Election Commission's constitutional autonomy must be balanced with transparency and accountability. In light of the controversies around the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, critically examine."

Related topics

  • Article 324, and the CEC/EC appointment and removal framework
  • Representation of the People Acts, 1950 and 1951 (roll preparation, qualification, disqualification)
  • Article 326 and universal adult suffrage
  • Delimitation of constituencies and the role of the Delimitation Commission
  • Electoral reforms and judicial review of ECI decisions

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 21 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs