BrainParrot

Bengal police gun down man accused of shooting at constable

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 16 November 2026

Summary

  • Ratan Sheikh, accused of shooting constable Biswajit Das at Bolpur (Birbhum) on Friday, was killed in a police operation on Sunday at a brick kiln in Nanoor. Police say he fired at the team while trying to evade arrest.
  • This is the fifth such killing in West Bengal in the six months since the BJP came to power. A civil-rights body calls all of them extrajudicial killings, while the Chief Minister defends the police.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Police, rule of law, Fundamental Rights (Art. 21), judiciary; GS2 — Governance: human rights

Key facts for Prelims

  • PUCL v. State of Maharashtra (2014): 16-point guidelines on encounters, binding as law declared under Article 141.
  • Article 21 (life and personal liberty); Article 14 (equality before law).
  • Article 141: law declared by the Supreme Court is binding on all courts.
  • "Police" and "Public Order" are State List subjects (List II).
  • NHRC and SHRCs are statutory bodies (Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993).
  • Magisterial inquiry and FIR are mandatory in encounter deaths. No out-of-turn promotions or gallantry awards for the officers involved.
  • APDR (Association for Protection of Democratic Rights) is a civil-rights organisation based in West Bengal.

Data and details

  • Incident:
  • The shooting of constable Biswajit Das at Bolpur happened on a Friday.
  • Das sustained bullet injuries.
  • Sheikh was killed on Sunday at a brick kiln in Nanoor, Birbhum.
  • Sheikh had recently been released on bail in a separate matter.
  • Pattern:
  • It is the fifth accused killed in a police operation in six months since the BJP came to power.
  • The four earlier cases were at Baruipur, Gaighata, Shamsherganj and Raiganj.
  • Chief Minister's response:
  • Suvendu Adhikari reacted sharply to media queries.
  • He essentially asked whether police should be hospitable to someone who fires at them.
  • During the assembly campaign he had said that those accused of heinous crimes, including crimes against women, would be locked up in the morning and finished by evening.
  • APDR's position:
  • It says all five "encounters" were extrajudicial killings.
  • It accuses the government of belittling the judiciary and the Constitution.
  • Vice-president Ranajit Sur alleges Sheikh was captured and then killed, regardless of the police's claim of self-defence.
  • Negative facts:
  • The article does not report any FIR, magisterial inquiry or independent investigation into the killings.
  • It does not say whether any of the five encounters has been reviewed by the NHRC, the SHRC or a court.

Static–dynamic linkage

The static concept is that "encounter" killings by police are not a legal category. Police may use force in self-defence or to prevent escape, but every death in police action must be investigated like any other killing. The Supreme Court has laid down guidelines to prevent staged encounters, and a government's political rhetoric endorsing such killings is seen as undermining the rule of law.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Right to life (Art. 21), due process, role of police and judiciary; State List (Police/Public Order); human rights institutions (NHRC/SHRC). GS4 – Ethics: means and ends in law enforcement.

Background primer

PUCL v. State of Maharashtra (2014) — Supreme Court guidelines on police encounters

What it is:
a Supreme Court judgment laying down procedural norms for investigating deaths in police encounters.
Founded:
judgment date: 23 September 2014. The case arose from writ petitions questioning 99 encounters by the Mumbai Police in which 135 alleged criminals were killed between 1995 and 1997. A bench of CJI R.M. Lodha and Justice R.F. Nariman set out a 16-point guideline.
Members:
not an institution, but a set of directions. The Court directed that they be strictly observed in all cases of death and grievous injury in police encounters, as law declared under Article 141.

Additional context

  • Political change in Bengal: Suvendu Adhikari took oath as the first BJP Chief Minister of West Bengal in May 2026.
  • Earlier incidents (All India Radio):
    • The CM said police have "full freedom" to ensure the rule of law.
    • In Gaighata (North 24 Parganas), Prahlad Das, accused in the rape and murder of a minor, died in police firing. Police said he snatched a firearm and fired during a crime reconstruction.
    • A second accused, in the murder of a BJP worker, died in similar circumstances during a CID reconstruction in Murshidabad.
    • In Dhulian (Murshidabad), the accused who died was Samayun Sheikh, wanted in the murder of BJP worker Sujit Mondal. Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury questioned the incidents, saying they deprived investigators of crucial information from the accused.
  • Court enforcement of the guidelines: in 2026 a High Court order in a bail matter (Bail No. 45637 of 2025), arising from a police encounter that caused grievous injury, held that where the PUCL guidelines are not followed, the officer who led the team and the district police chief (SP/SSP/Commissioner) would be liable for contempt, apart from departmental disciplinary action.

Mains dimensions

  • Rule of law and Article 21: an accused has a right to a fair trial. Self-defence by police is lawful, but each use of lethal force must be independently examined. A pattern of five similar incidents in six months raises a question about institutionalised extrajudicial punishment.
  • Politics of "encounters": rhetoric about eliminating accused persons "by evening" blurs the line between policy and extrajudicial killing. Governments elsewhere have drawn similar criticism for treating encounters as proof of performance.
  • Safeguards: the PUCL guidelines (FIR, independent investigation, magisterial inquiry, NHRC reporting, no rewards) are the benchmark. Compliance and enforcement remain the weak link.
  • Counter-arguments: police face genuine danger (a constable was shot), public demand for swift justice is strong, and delays in trials weaken deterrence. This explains public support for such action.
  • Federal and institutional angle: police are a State subject, so accountability depends on state governments, courts and human-rights commissions. High Court contempt action (as in the 2026 bail order above) and SHRC activity are the main checks.
  • Ethics (GS4): ends do not justify means. Police should act with legitimate force and accountability. Politicians' statements shape police culture.
  • Way forward:
  • Mandatory FIR and independent probe in every case.
  • NHRC/SHRC oversight with timelines.
  • Police reforms in line with the Prakash Singh directions (separating investigation from law and order, security of tenure, State Security Commissions).
  • Faster trials and witness protection to reduce pressure for "instant justice".

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "'Encounter' killings by police undermine due process and the rule of law. In the light of the Supreme Court's guidelines in PUCL v. State of Maharashtra (2014), discuss the safeguards needed to ensure accountability in police use of force."

Related topics

  • Police reforms: Prakash Singh case (2006), Model Police Act
  • Right to life and due process: Maneka Gandhi, D.K. Basu guidelines on custodial deaths
  • NHRC: composition, powers and limits
  • Custodial violence and use of force: BNS provisions on self-defence and culpable homicide
  • Fast-track courts and criminal justice reform

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 16 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs