Pakistan picks vocal India critic for SCO dialogue in New Delhi
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 15 November 2026
Summary
- Pakistan said Climate Change Minister Musadik Masood Malik will represent it at the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue in New Delhi (20–22 November). India had invited Pakistan's culture and heritage minister instead.
- Malik has criticised India's decision to hold the Indus Waters Treaty "in abeyance" since the April 2025 Pahalgam attack.
- India's Culture Minister stressed a shared civilisational past, while the MEA reiterated its "national policy" on Pakistan.
Key facts for Prelims
- SCO: founded 15 June 2001 in Shanghai. Ten members including India (since 2017), Pakistan (2017), Iran (2023) and Belarus (2024). Secretariat in Beijing. RATS in Tashkent. English was added as an official language by charter amendment at the Bishkek summit.
- SCO's "three evils": terrorism, separatism, extremism.
- IWT (1960): Eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas, Sutlej) to India, Western rivers (Indus, Jhelum, Chenab) to Pakistan. World Bank is a signatory. Disputes go through the Permanent Indus Commission, the Neutral Expert and the Court of Arbitration.
- Harappan heritage: Mohenjo-daro (Sindh, Pakistan) is a UNESCO World Heritage Site (1980). Dholavira (Gujarat) was inscribed in 2021.
- 2023 SCO Foreign Ministers meeting was in Goa (Bilawal Bhutto Zardari attended).
- Four themes of the Dialogue: cultural expression, art and architecture, language and literature, religious and philosophical traditions.
Data and details
- Event dates: 20–22 November, New Delhi. Pakistan's announcement came on Saturday (14 November).
- Pakistan's representative: Musadik Masood Malik, Federal Minister for Climate Change and Environmental Coordination, a technocrat-turned-minister. In June this year he said Pakistan would "cut off those hands" trying to control Indus waters.
- India's invitee: The Hindu reported on 28 October that India invited Pakistan's Minister for National Heritage and Culture, Aurungzeb Khan Khichi. This was the first such ministerial-level invitation since 2023. Pakistan nominated someone else.
- Last Pakistani minister in India: Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, at Goa in May 2023 for the SCO Foreign Ministers meeting.
- Background to the IWT stance: India and Pakistan engaged in military hostilities after the Pahalgam attack, following which India placed the 1960 treaty "in abeyance".
- Pakistan's statement: committed to dialogue among civilisations and people-to-people contacts in the SCO framework, in a spirit of mutual respect.
- Pakistan's heritage messaging: on World Heritage Day (18 April), PM Shehbaz Sharif referred to the Indus Valley civilisation. Pakistan has highlighted Mohenjo Daro and Harappa in recent months to assert its claim on the Indus.
- India's cultural messaging (Culture Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat, Friday): India and Pakistan share a civilisational and cultural past. Pakistan separated from India less than 100 years ago. The Dialogue was first proposed by PM Modi to take the SCO beyond geopolitical, strategic and bilateral ties.
- Participants confirmed (at that time): China, Kazakhstan, Iran, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan.
- MEA response: India will follow "national policy" on Pakistan after Pahalgam. This signals possible refusal of clearance for Punjab CM Bhagwant Singh Mann to attend an international Punjabi cultural conference in Lahore at the end of the month.
Static–dynamic linkage
- India uses multilateral forums such as the SCO to project civilisational and cultural diplomacy (soft power) while holding a firm line on terrorism.
- Pakistan is using the Indus Valley civilisation (Mohenjo Daro, Harappa) to strengthen its narrative of historic claim over the Indus. Water and civilisation have become linked in the diplomatic contest.
- The Indus Waters Treaty (1960) is a rare durable water-sharing treaty. India's "abeyance" stance since Pahalgam changes the baseline of the relationship.
- Hosting an SCO event means India invites all members, including Pakistan. Pakistan's choice of representative signals its position.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – IR: bilateral relations (India–Pakistan), international groupings (SCO), treaties (Indus Waters Treaty) | GS1 – Culture: Indus Valley (Harappan) civilisation, heritage and soft power | Prelims – Current events: SCO, IWT
Background primer
Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO)
- What it is:
- a Eurasian intergovernmental organisation founded in Shanghai on 15 June 2001.
- Founded:
- It grew out of the "Shanghai Five" (formed in 1996 to address border security among China, Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Uzbekistan joined in 2001 and the group was renamed SCO.
- Members:
- China, Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, India, Pakistan, Iran and Belarus. India has been a full member since 2017 (admitted at the Astana summit). The Heads of State Council is the supreme decision-making body. The Secretariat is in Beijing and the RATS Executive Committee in Tashkent.
- Mandate:
- strengthening mutual trust, regional peace and security, and tackling the "three evils" of terrorism, separatism and extremism.
- Why it matters:
- managing Central Asian security and cooperation after the Cold War through consensus, non-interference and equality of members.
Indus Waters Treaty (IWT), 1960
- What it is:
- signed on 19 September 1960 at Karachi between India and Pakistan, with the World Bank as a signatory.
Additional context
- About the forum: India hosts the first SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi on 20–22 November, focusing on cultural expression, art and architecture, language and literature, and religious and philosophical traditions. Fifteen countries have confirmed participation (as per the Culture Minister's briefing).
- Origins: India originally proposed it at the 2025 Tianjin summit. Rajnath Singh announced the hosting on 20 October 2026 at the SCO Council of Heads of Government meeting in Dushanbe. Member states welcomed the initiative at the 26th SCO Summit.
- Invitation: India invited all 10 SCO members, including Pakistan.
- IWT recent stance: India's UN envoy reiterated at a World Water Day 2026 event that the treaty stays in abeyance until Pakistan ends support for terrorism. India has also refused to participate in the Court of Arbitration constituted in 2023 at Pakistan's request, arguing the matter belongs with the Neutral Expert.
- PCA ruling: Insights on India reports that in August 2026 the Permanent Court of Arbitration held that the IWT remains binding and cannot be unilaterally held in abeyance. India rejected the ruling, calling the arbitration illegally constituted and its decisions null and void.
Mains dimensions
- Signalling through representation: India invited the culture minister, but Pakistan sent the climate and environment minister who has attacked India's IWT stance. Pakistan thus attends while shifting the focus to water.
- Civilisation as contested terrain: Pakistan stresses the Indus Valley as its heritage to support its claim on the Indus. India stresses shared civilisation. Culture and water now overlap in diplomacy.
- Mixed messaging in India: the Culture Minister's shared-past remarks came just before the MEA's "national policy" line. This is a tension between soft-power outreach and the post-Pahalgam hard line.
- SCO as arena: India engages Pakistan only within multilateral frameworks (SCO) while keeping bilateral engagement frozen. The last Pakistani minister visit was in 2023.
- Soft power: a civilisational dialogue showcases India's cultural leadership in Eurasia and builds Track-II and people-to-people ties. The forum's four themes cover art, language, literature and religion.
- Treaty law and the abeyance stance: the unilateral abeyance is a legal grey area. Pakistan's rhetoric ("cut off those hands") shows how water has become a security issue.
- Way forward: keep the SCO process cultural and avoid linkage with bilateral disputes, while maintaining a clear line on terrorism.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "India uses cultural diplomacy in multilateral forums such as the SCO even as its bilateral ties with Pakistan remain frozen. Discuss the opportunities and limitations of this approach, with reference to the Indus Waters Treaty."
Related topics
- India's SCO engagement: SCO summits, RATS, India's "Security, Connectivity, Opportunity" approach
- Indus Waters Treaty and Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties
- Harappan sites in India and Pakistan; UNESCO World Heritage Sites
- India–Pakistan bilateral framework (Simla Agreement) and post-Pahalgam measures
- Cultural diplomacy and soft power (ICCR, Buddhist diplomacy)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 15 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs