Choosing faith over fear
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 14 November 2026
Summary
- Christian groups in West Bengal report a string of attacks on churches and prayer gatherings between May and November 2026. One prominent incident was the October 31 attack at the inauguration of a new church in Narayantala village, Basanti.
- Survivors, a people's tribunal and Christian bodies allege targeted mob violence and coerced "rituals". Police and the state's Minority Affairs Minister say they have no compiled data and have received no report.
- Police describe the Basanti case as a dispute between two churches. Christian leaders allege a larger pattern and say police are soft on perpetrators.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 25: freedom of conscience and free profession, practice and propagation of religion, subject to public order, morality and health. Articles 25–28 form the Right to Freedom of Religion. Article 25 applies to all persons.
- Rev. Stanislaus v. State of Madhya Pradesh (1977): upheld Odisha (1967) and Madhya Pradesh (1968) anti-conversion laws. No fundamental right to convert another person.
- No central anti-conversion law exists. Public order is a State List subject. States have enacted conversion-regulating laws; 11 had done so by 2025.
- West Bengal Religious Buildings and Places Act, 1985 (West Bengal Act XXXII of 1985): permission from the Collector or Commissioner of Police for public religious buildings or temporary use of public places. A 250 m rule applies for buildings of a different religious community.
- Census 2011: Christians are 0.72% of West Bengal's population (as cited in the article).
Data and details
- Basanti, South 24 Parganas (Oct 31, 2026 – Saturday):
- William Cary Memorial Church at Narayantala village, Basanti block, was attacked at its inauguration. It had been opened "for the first and last time".
- Purnima (65, name changed), whose family donated the land, was hit with a stick and hospitalised for a day. The church is now closed.
- Narayantala has about 300 families, mostly Christian, and an old church locals claim is about 200 years old.
- Seven families, including Purnima's, set up a separate church about two years ago after disagreements in the old church.
- Villagers say the mob raised "Jai Shri Ram" slogans and was largely made up of non-villagers.
- Basanti police say prima facie it is a dispute between two churches within 100 metres of each other.
- Priest Samiran Mondal says the mob used rods and bricks. Families were beaten, and women were told to remove sakha (white bangles) and sindoor.
- Scale and response:
- The BJP government has been in power since May 2026, and attacks are reported for May–November 2026.
- Herod Mullick, founder-secretary of the Bangiya Christiya Pariseba (Bengal Christian Council), has recorded 48 incidents. Seven involve mainline denominations and the rest independent congregations.
- The worst-hit districts are South 24 Parganas, North 24 Parganas, Purba Medinipur and Paschim Medinipur.
- No group has claimed responsibility. Only 16 FIRs have been registered, according to Mullick.
- Minister of Minority Affairs Kshudiram Tudu says he has heard nothing from Christian representatives and could not verify media reports.
- ADG (Law and Order) Ajay Mukund Ranade says there is no compiled data on attacks or arrests, though local police are acting where FIRs exist.
- People's Tribunal on Christian Persecution (Nov 2, Muslim Institute, Kolkata, opposite the Lord Jesus Church):
- Organised by Karwan-e-Mohabbat, Sabar Institute and Aamra Ek Sachetan Prayas.
- Jury members included Wajahat Habibullah (former Chief Information Commissioner), Jawhar Sircar, John Dayal, Aakar Patel, Vidya Dinkar and Harsh Mander.
- Alt News's Ankita Mahalanobis analysed 35 incidents between July 1 and September 30. In most, perpetrators uploaded videos claiming allegiance to Hindutva groups.
- Habibullah said the attacks harm Bengal's spiritual tradition. Mander asked how it took only four months of BJP rule to "brutalise society". Patel stressed the timing.
- Individual accounts:
- Keshpur, Paschim Medinipur (October 2, Gandhi Jayanti): a prayer meeting was attacked by a mob of 80–100. A woman says she was disrobed and beaten and was asked why she wore sankha and sindoor.
- Chandrakona police station FIR (October 20) for an October 18 incident: alleges coercion into Hindu rituals, a threat to rape and kill if they did not renounce their faith, a forced "purification" bath, and being taken to a Durga Puja pandal.
- Trinity of Joy Church, Brajanath Chak, Purba Medinipur (Digbijoy Manna): attacked on May 4 and September 7. Seven were injured the second time. CCTV and the cross were damaged, and prayers are now online.
- Asansol, Paschim Bardhaman (Mamata Joshua): attacked on May 31 and August 7 despite permission from the local BJP MLA to continue prayers.
- Midnapore (priest Anup Kumar Ghosh): attacked July 3 during a post-wedding feast. He was booked on charges including attempted murder, spent 41 days in jail, reports weekly to the police station and lives 16 km away.
- Ajaya village, Khejuri-I, Purba Medinipur (Swapan Kumar Barui): threatened by phone on July 22 and attacked the next morning. He says he was told to convert to Hinduism and has been ostracised for five months. Attackers allegedly said officials would be asked to strike their names off government schemes. His family converted in 2017.
- Counter-mobilisation and responses:
- On November 5 at Basanti, locals burned effigies of church priests in a procession organised by Adivasi Eikya Parishad, which alleges Adivasis are being lured to convert by promises of cures.
- Christian bodies held a march in Kolkata on November 5.
- A five-member Christian delegation met RSS leader Dr Jishnu Basu. He said dialogue would continue, voiced "genuine concerns about forced conversions", and said both the attacks and the conversion allegations should be investigated.
- Mullick says repeated appeals to Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari are unheeded. He says Christians were not mentioned in the election campaign and are not a vote bank.
- The Chief Minister, asked about a proposed Murshidabad mosque, said temples, mosques, churches and gurdwaras are matters of constitutional rights.
- The government's election slogan was "Bhoy out, bhorsa in" (Fear out, Faith in). Christmas will be the first under the BJP regime.
- Rev. Arpan Rana (National Christian Council) says targets are mostly home fellowships run by women, and sees the attacks as a precursor to an anti-conversion law.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Article 25(1) gives all persons freedom of conscience and the right to profess, practise and propagate religion, subject to public order, morality and health. The state has a duty to protect this freedom from private mobs.
- Maintaining public order and policing are primarily State responsibilities, so the pattern of FIRs, arrests and data compilation depends on the state government and police.
- The tension at the centre of the story is between religious freedom and anti-conversion concerns. States regulate conversions through "force, fraud, allurement" laws. Allegations of forced conversion and of coercive "reconversion" rituals both claim the protection of Article 25 and public-order law.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental Rights (Articles 25–28, freedom of religion), role of the state in protecting minorities, law and order as a State subject, police accountability; GS1 – Society: communalism and secularism.
Background primer
Article 25 and the freedom of religion (Articles 25–28)
- What it is:
- Article 25 guarantees the freedom to profess, practise and propagate religion, subject to public order, morality, health and other provisions of the Constitution. Articles 25 to 28 together form the Right to Freedom of Religion.
- Founded:
- Part III of the Constitution (1950). The Constituent Assembly debated the "right to propagate" and considered replacing "propagate" with "practise privately", fearing forced conversions.
- Mandate:
- In *Rev. Stanislaus v. State of Madhya Pradesh* (1977) the Supreme Court read "propagate" as transmitting or spreading religion through exposition of its tenets. It held that Article 25 does not give a right to convert another person. The Court upheld the Madhya Pradesh Dharma Swatantraya Adhiniyam (1968) and the Orissa Freedom of Religion Act (1967). There is no central law regulating religious conversions. As of 2025, 11 states had passed laws to regulate religious conversion on public-order grounds.
- Why it matters:
- The Court said what is freedom for one is freedom for the other in equal measure. Critics argue that vague terms like "inducement" permit arbitrary enforcement.
Mains dimensions
- Constitutional duty vs private violence: Article 25 protects worship, but the practical guarantee depends on police and administration. The state's duty is to prevent and prosecute mob violence on prayer meetings. The article reports no compiled police data on attacks or arrests, and Mullick says only 16 FIRs have been registered against the 48 incidents his group recorded. That points to a possible institutional gap, whatever one concludes about individual cases.
- Competing narratives: Police frame the Basanti attack as an inter-church dispute. Villagers say outsiders chanting slogans attacked. Adivasi Eikya Parishad and the RSS leader cite "forced conversion". Christian groups call the attacks planned. Resolving this needs credible independent investigation of both the attacks and the conversion claims, as the RSS leader himself suggested.
- Misuse of procedural law: The allegation that the 1985 Act is used to book those holding prayers rather than to register FIRs against attackers raises a rule-of-law issue about neutral enforcement. Priest Ghosh's arrest and 41 days in jail under attempted-murder charges after his church was attacked is the illustrative case.
- Coercion and gender: Several women allege forced rituals, disrobing and threats of sexual violence. Targets are largely women-led home prayer meetings. This links to dignity (Article 21) and women's safety.
- Social boycott and welfare: Ostracism and threats to remove names from government schemes show how exclusion can be used as coercion.
- Anti-conversion law debate: States regulate conversions under public order, and Stanislaus supports that. Critics say such laws are vague and open to misuse. Rev. Rana's fear is that the attacks lay the ground for such a law.
- Governance and ethics (GS4): The gap between the "Bhoy out, bhorsa in" slogan and reported ground reality tests political leadership. The tribunal and the Alt News analysis show the role of civil society and fact-checking in documenting incidents when official data is lacking.
- Way forward: Compile and publish data on attacks on religious places. Ensure prompt FIRs and a neutral police response. Hold independent inquiries. Protect survivors and rebuild community trust through dialogue.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Recurring mob attacks on minority places of worship challenge both the constitutional promise of religious freedom and the rule of law. Examine the role of the state and police in safeguarding Article 25 rights, with reference to the debate on conversion."
Related topics
- Articles 14, 15, 21, 25–30; secularism as a basic feature (S.R. Bommai)
- Anti-conversion laws of states; Rev. Stanislaus; Hadiya and Puttaswamy on autonomy and choice
- Mob-violence and hate-crime jurisprudence (Tehseen Poonawalla guidelines); police reforms
- National Commission for Minorities; NHRC; role of data collection (NCRB)
- Centre–State relations on law and order (State List Entries 1 and 2)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 14 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs