BrainParrot

Milking power

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 12 November 2026

Summary

  • Maharashtra approved an ordinance on November 4, promulgated by the Governor on November 6. It amends the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act and allows the government to nominate directors to certain large cooperative institutions. It was used immediately at the Kolhapur District Cooperative Milk Producers' Union (Gokul Dairy).
  • The editorial opens by linking this to a wider nationwide outcry over electoral malpractices. It argues this overturned an election mandate won by a Congress-led panel, and that the Bombay High Court declined to restrain the nominees from voting. It places this within a wider pattern of the ruling party seeking dominance over cooperatives.
  • This is an opinion piece: its claims about motive and "pattern" are the author's stance, not findings of fact.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity & Governance: cooperative governance, ordinance power, Centre–State/political federalism, role of Governor and judiciary

Key facts for Prelims

  • Part IXB (Articles 243ZH–243ZT), inserted by the Constitution (97th Amendment) Act, 2011.
  • Article 243ZJ: maximum 21 directors; one seat for SC/ST, two for women; five-year term; up to two co-opted experts.
  • Article 243ZI: State legislature regulates incorporation, regulation and winding up of cooperatives.
  • Entry 32 of List II (State List): cooperative societies; Union of India v. Rajendra N. Shah (2021) restricted Part IXB to multi-State cooperatives.
  • The Governor promulgates ordinances under Article 213, when the legislature is not in session. They must be laid before the legislature and lapse after six weeks from its reassembly.
  • Ministry of Cooperation: created under Home Minister Amit Shah (as stated in the editorial).

Data and details

  • Gokul board election on October 19: Congress-led Rajarshi Shahu Shetkari Samvichari Aghadi (led by Satej Patil) won 13 of 25 elected seats.
  • Gokul: annual turnover about ₹4,000 crore; linked to several lakh milk producers in western Maharashtra.
  • October 29: the chairman's election was deadlocked. BJP-allied members stayed away, and the meeting was short of the quorum of 14. Congress-allied directors declared Shashikant Patil Chuyekar chairman, but the administration refused to recognise it for want of quorum.
  • Ordinance: approved November 4, promulgated November 6. It lets the government nominate five directors to certain large cooperative institutions, four of them with voting rights.
  • Four nominees were immediately named to the Gokul board. They voted with the BJP and allies in the chairman election on November 10, turning a 13–12 mandate into a 16–13 result.
  • November 9: the defeated side approached the Bombay High Court to restrain the nominees from voting, but no relief was granted.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Cooperative societies are a State subject (Entry 32, State List). The 97th Amendment added Part IXB to give them constitutional status and democratic governance norms.
  • The Supreme Court narrowed Part IXB in 2021 to multi-State cooperatives. Intra-State societies such as a district milk union are thus governed by State law, which gives State governments wide room to amend rules.
  • The editorial argues the nomination of voting directors reverses members' verdict. The constitutional norms of democratic member control are the yardstick against which this should be judged.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Cooperative societies (Part IXB, 97th Amendment), Governor's ordinance-making power (Article 213), State legislative competence (Entry 32, List II), role of judiciary; GS3 – Economy: cooperatives and dairy.

Background primer

Part IXB – Constitution (97th Amendment) Act, 2011

What it is:
the constitutional framework for co-operative societies. The 97th Amendment Act incorporated Part IXB, which deals with provisions relating to cooperative societies.
Founded:
the amendment was passed in 2011 and came into force in February 2012. It added a fundamental right to form cooperatives (Article 19(1)(c)) and a Directive Principle (Article 43B).
Members:
the number of directors is set by State law, subject to a maximum of 21, with reservation of one seat for SC/ST and two for women. The term of the board and elected members is five years. State law may provide for co-option of up to two expert members, who have no voting rights in board elections and cannot become office-bearers.
Mandate:
Article 243ZI says State legislatures may legislate on incorporation, regulation and winding up of cooperatives based on voluntary formation, democratic member-control, member-economic participation and autonomous functioning.
Why it matters:
before the amendment, governance of cooperatives often suffered from political interference and lack of accountability.

Union of India v. Rajendra N. Shah (2021)

Ministry of Cooperation

Mains dimensions

  • Democratic member control: the 13–12 mandate was reversed by state-nominated voters. This conflicts with the spirit of Part IXB (democratic member-control) and the non-voting status of co-opted members under Article 243ZJ.
  • Executive law-making: the amendment was made via ordinance (Articles 213 and 243ZI-based State legislation), used for an immediate, specific outcome. This raises the question of whether the ordinance route is being used to avoid legislative debate. The Supreme Court has held in Krishna Kumar Singh that ordinances are subject to judicial scrutiny.
  • Federalism and politics of cooperatives: cooperatives are a State subject, but the Centre has set up a Ministry of Cooperation. The editorial sees political control of cooperatives as part of a larger design.
  • Judicial role: it criticises the High Court's refusal to grant interim relief as diffidence about intervening for democratic principles. Counterpoint: courts are usually reluctant to stay legislation or ordinance operation at the interim stage.
  • Economic angle: dairy cooperatives (the Amul/Anand model) are central to rural livelihoods. Politicisation can weaken professional management and farmers' trust.
  • Way forward: limit government nominees to non-voting experts (as in Article 243ZJ(3)), strengthen independent election authorities for cooperatives, and ensure ordinances are not used for targeted ends.

Possible Mains question

**GS Paper II, 15 marks:** "Cooperative societies are a State subject, yet political control over them has become a federal and democratic concern. Examine the constitutional framework for cooperatives and the issues raised by executive nomination of directors."

Related topics

  • 97th Amendment, Part IXB, Article 19(1)(c) and Article 43B
  • Governor's ordinance power (Article 213) and judicial review of ordinances
  • Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002 (as amended) and the Ministry of Cooperation
  • Anand/Amul model and dairy cooperatives; State vs Union legislative lists

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 12 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs