Transparency is essential to institutional credibility
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 11 November 2026
Summary
- The op-ed responds to the proposed amendments to the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 2010. Civil society, the Opposition and Christian institutions have reacted strongly. The Bill is with a Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC).
- The Government says the aim is transparency, accountability and preventing misuse of foreign funds. Critics fear curbs on legitimate civil society work and a disproportionate hit on minority institutions.
- The author argues for "accountable autonomy". The state must not use transparency as a pretext to weaken minority institutions. Minority institutions, for their part, should voluntarily disclose audited accounts and funding sources to their own stakeholders.
- He also asks why the Church has not pushed the Scheduled Caste (SC) status of Dalit Christians with the same intensity as it has pushed against the FCRA changes.
Key facts for Prelims
- FCRA, 2010 is administered by the Ministry of Home Affairs. Registration is valid for five years, and organisations can alternatively get one-time prior permission.
- Proposed vesting authority: a "Designated Authority" for assets of organisations whose FCRA certificate is cancelled, surrendered or ceased.
- A JPC has 31 members here (21 LS + 10 RS); the Speaker and RS Chairman nominate their Houses' members.
- Minority educational institutions: Article 30. Religious freedom: Arts. 25–28. SC status is determined under Article 341 (Presidential Order). Under the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950, SC status is limited to specified religions (Hindu, later Sikh and Buddhist) — textbook fact.
- Organisations named in the op-ed: Catholic Bishops' Conference of India (CBCI), Society of Jesus (Jesuits), Salesians of Don Bosco.
Data and details
- Referral status: the Bill has been sent to a JPC "for further scrutiny" (the article gives no dates or figures).
- Provisions the article names: "assets created or acquired through foreign contributions" are in scope of the tighter regulation.
- Absent or pending, per the article: Dalit Christians' SC status has been "awaited for decades" and is pending before the Supreme Court. The Church's institutional reach and finances are described as "considerable".
- CBCI memorandum to the Union Government covers (a) concerns on the FCRA Amendment Bill and (b) continued denial of SC status to Christians of SC origin, with a plea for early resolution.
- Allegations of capitation or admission-related donations in sought-after courses are stated to be public concerns. The author says they must not be treated as established fact against any institution without evidence.
- Author's suggested voluntary disclosures: audited annual accounts, broad income-and-expenditure statements, major funding sources and the purposes of expenditure. He explicitly excludes confidential individual transactions.
Static–dynamic linkage
- FCRA regulates the receipt and use of foreign money by individuals, associations and companies. It restricts foreign funding in areas such as politics and media and in activities "detrimental to national interest".
- Counter-pole: minority institutions have constitutional protection (Art. 30 for educational institutions; Arts. 25–28 on religious freedom and management of religious affairs). Art. 19(1)(c) protects the right to form associations. Regulation must therefore be reasonable and proportionate. It cannot be a pretext to suppress legitimate charity.
- Accountability runs in two directions: the state's accountability to civil society (due process, no arbitrary executive discretion) and civil society's accountability to donors and beneficiaries (voluntary disclosure).
- Parliamentary scrutiny via a JPC is the institutional mechanism for the "reasoned debate" the author asks for.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: statutory and regulatory frameworks, role of NGOs and civil society, Parliamentary committees, minority rights (Arts. 25–30), SC status (Art. 341); GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability
Background primer
Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA), 2010
- What it is:
- the law regulating the acceptance and use of foreign contributions by individuals, associations and organisations in India, so that the funds are used for the purposes for which they were received.
- Founded:
- enacted in 2010 (it replaced the earlier FCRA, 1976 — textbook fact). It is administered by the Ministry of Home Affairs.
- Mandate:
- it prohibits use of foreign funds for activities detrimental to national interest. The government may cancel a certificate for violations or other specified circumstances. A cancelled NGO is ineligible for re-registration for three years. No more than 20% of annual foreign contribution may go to administrative expenses.
- Why it matters:
- financial transparency and national security against foreign influence, balanced against the NGO sector's role in welfare delivery.
Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC)
- What it is:
- an ad hoc committee with members from both Houses, set up by motion to examine a Bill or issue in depth.
- Mandate:
- detailed examination of Bills, questioning officials, consulting experts and clause-by-clause scrutiny.
Additional context
- The FCRA (Amendment) Bill, 2026 was introduced in the Lok Sabha on 25 March 2026. It creates a Designated Authority to take over, manage and dispose of assets of an organisation whose FCRA registration is cancelled, surrendered or ceased.
- Registration would also cease if it is not renewed before expiry, no renewal application is made, or renewal is denied.
- Assets created even partly with foreign funds would vest entirely in the Designated Authority. The organisation can apply to get back any distinct portion created from domestic sources. Objections from the Opposition and the Church centred on this vesting of foreign-funded assets.
- The Bill cuts the maximum imprisonment from five years to one year, but requires prior central government approval to start an investigation.
- Both Houses approved referral to the JPC, on 12 August. Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju said the Bill contains nothing aimed at targeting minority institutions.
- The JPC is chaired by Lok Sabha MP Sanjay Jaiswal. It has heard stakeholders including the Catholic Bishops' Conference of India, the All India Christian Council and the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. Its report is due by the last day of the first week of the Winter Session 2026.
- Revised FCRA Rules, 2026 were notified on 22 June and are in force.
- Committee referral has declined: about 16% of Bills in the 17th Lok Sabha against 71% in the 15th.
Mains dimensions
- Two-sided accountability: the state must show proportionality and due process. Foreign funds "cannot be placed beyond scrutiny", yet FCRA cannot become a pretext to suppress charitable, educational, health or social-service activity.
- Minority rights vs regulation: Art. 30 protects institutional autonomy but is not immunity from financial regulation. The article's test is "accountable autonomy".
- Voluntary transparency as moral capital: disclosure of audited accounts, funding sources and usage strengthens the credibility of the demand for state accountability. The article uses the Catholic Church in Tamil Nadu and large orders such as the Jesuits and Salesians as examples.
- Internal inequity / irony: the CBCI says caste persists after conversion, yet Dalit Christians remain without SC status after decades. The author asks whether the Church has mobilised on this as intensely as on FCRA.
- Legislative process: the JPC gives a forum for stakeholder concerns, though its recommendations are not binding and the committee-referral trend has declined (see 2b).
- Concerns raised on the Bill itself: automatic vesting of partly foreign-funded assets and executive discretion versus the stated goals of transparency and national-interest protection (see 2b, including property-rights angle under Art. 300A).
- Way forward: disclosure norms for religious and charitable bodies; clear due-process safeguards in the Bill; resolve the SC-status question.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Regulation of foreign contributions must balance national-interest concerns with the autonomy of civil society and minority institutions. Discuss in the context of the FCRA Amendment Bill, 2026. How can accountability be strengthened without undermining minority rights?"
Related topics
- Articles 25–30 (religious freedom, minority educational rights); Art. 300A (right to property)
- Article 341 and the SC status of Dalit Christians/Muslims; Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950; Ranganath Misra Commission (textbook)
- Parliamentary committees (DRSCs, JPCs, Select Committees) and their limits
- Regulation of NGOs: FCRA Rules, NGO registration and CSR transparency
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 11 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs