BrainParrot

Supreme Court goes beyond Deepavali AQI, flags vehicular emissions polluting Del...

GS3Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 11 November 2026

Summary

  • On 6 November, two days before Deepavali, a Supreme Court Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant said citizens, not the judiciary alone, must fight air pollution. It flagged vehicular emissions as the persistent driver of Delhi's toxic air.
  • The Court directed Delhi's civic and traffic authorities and the governments of UP, Haryana and Rajasthan to report on how they regulate vehicles. Its amici curiae told it that compliance with its earlier orders was yet to be properly reported.
  • Politically, Congress's Ajay Maken objected to a parliamentary panel dropping "air pollution" from its 17 November agenda, and Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge attacked the government's record. Pakistan blamed Indian Deepavali fireworks for Lahore's smog.

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Environment: air pollution, CAQM/GRAP, judicial monitoring; GS2 — Polity: Parliamentary committees, federal coordination

Key facts for Prelims

  • CAQM: statutory body (Act of 2021); covers NCR and adjoining areas of Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh; accountable to Parliament.
  • GRAP: notified 2017; AQI bands: Poor 201–300, Very Poor 301–400, Severe 401–450, Severe+ above 450. Delhi's 24-hour AQI of 299 on Tuesday falls in the 'Poor' band (Stage I), just short of 'Very Poor'.
  • Right to clean air/environment: Art. 21 (judicially recognised); Art. 48A; Art. 51A(g).
  • PM2.5: particles small enough to penetrate deep into the lungs.
  • Parliamentary Standing Committee on Home Affairs: chaired by Radha Mohan Das Agarwal (BJP) per the article. It had listed "Air pollution in Delhi-NCR" on its 17 November agenda before dropping it.
  • Four suo motu matters listed 23–30 November: vehicular emissions; enhancement of green cover; construction activities/power plants; waste management/stubble-burning/firecrackers.
  • Amici curiae: court-appointed independent assistants.

Data and details

  • Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant said the people, not the judiciary, must "strike a blow" against air pollution, 48 hours before Deepavali. The Court detected a sharp increase in issues from vehicular emissions.
  • It noted that Delhi-NCR carries the cumulative burden of vehicular traffic from within and from neighbouring UP, Haryana and Rajasthan. Responses were sought from the MCD, Delhi government, Delhi Police (Traffic), Haryana, Rajasthan and UP on regulating commercial and non-commercial vehicles and traffic from outside Delhi.
  • Details sought:
  • Steps to identify, monitor and regulate vehicles not meeting emission standards.
  • Measures to prevent entry and operation of overage, end-of-life or non-compliant vehicles.
  • Action taken: number of vehicles inspected, challaned and denied entry.
  • Coordination mechanisms between Delhi and neighbouring states on inter-state vehicle movement.
  • Earlier orders:
  • 21 January: lists CAQM recommendations — phasing out polluting vehicles from Delhi-NCR, strengthening the pollution-under-check regime, more rail and metro, and a revised EV policy.
  • 23 February: Delhi government and the Ministries of Environment, Petroleum & Natural Gas, and Commerce & Industry to submit a joint proposal to shift coal-based industries out of NCR. This followed a CAQM recommendation to bar new coal-based thermal power plants within 300 km of Delhi.
  • Amici told the Court on 6 November that compliance was "yet to be properly reported". Four suo motu cases are listed from 23 to 30 November.
  • The agenda circulated on 5 November included the topic "Air pollution in Delhi-NCR: Enforcement of regulatory measures, effective implementation of GRAP measures, protection of vulnerable sections and coordination among law enforcement and government agencies". The revised agenda omitted it.
  • Maken (Congress member of the panel) wrote to chair Agarwal calling the situation a "public health emergency". He asked for the 17 Nov hearing to be restored, or the earliest date plus an explanation. No alternative date had been announced.
  • "Piecemeal measures, PR stunts, broken promises and blame games"; India becoming a "Vishwaguru" in pollution; clean air is a fundamental right.
  • He alleged PM2.5 readings disappeared from 36 of Delhi's 59 monitoring stations, and cited ₹1,154 crore of unspent environmental compensation. He demanded "Hawa Ka Hisaab" from the PM, referring to the Court's direction to Delhi, Haryana, UP and Rajasthan.
  • Delhi's 24-hour AQI was 299 ('poor') on Tuesday, just below 'very poor'. It is expected to improve further, with experts attributing it to higher wind speed.
  • Reuters: Lahore topped IQAir's ranking of the world's most polluted major cities for a second day on Tuesday, with AQI 263 ('very unhealthy') and PM2.5 at 37.2 times the WHO guideline. IQAir ranked Delhi second with AQI 188.
  • Government data showed firecrackers caused nearly 55% of Delhi's PM2.5 a day earlier. Vehicle emissions, construction dust and crop-waste smoke are major winter contributors on both sides of the border.
  • Pakistani Punjab's Environment Protection Minister Marriyum Aurangzeb attributed the pollutants to light winds carrying air from India, with a gradual decline expected as winds shift. India's MEA did not immediately respond.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The right to a clean environment flows from Art. 21 (right to life). The directive principle of Art. 48A and the fundamental duty of Art. 51A(g) underpin it. The judiciary has long supervised Delhi's air quality through continuing mandamus (M.C. Mehta line of cases).
  • Delhi's air is a regional commons problem: NCR traffic, stubble burning and industry cut across state borders. This needs institutional coordination (CAQM) rather than state-by-state action.
  • Governance gap: orders and commission recommendations exist, but implementation and reporting are weak, as the amici flagged.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: pollution and degradation, conservation; GS2 – Polity: judiciary (continuing mandamus, *suo motu*), Parliamentary Standing Committees, Centre–state coordination; GS2 – IR: transboundary pollution (SAARC neighbourhood)

Background primer

Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM)

What it is:
a statutory body under the Commission for Air Quality Management in NCR and Adjoining Areas Act, 2021, to coordinate and implement air pollution control in the NCR and adjoining areas of Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and UP.
Founded:
constituted in 2021 (first through an Ordinance, then the Act of 2021), replacing the Supreme Court-appointed EPCA.
Mandate:
it is directly accountable to Parliament and is the apex body for NCR air quality management.
Why it matters:
one commission with jurisdiction across states to end fragmented, state-wise efforts.

Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP)

What it is:
an emergency response mechanism for the NCR based on average AQI levels and weather forecasts.
Founded:
notified by the Centre (MoEF&CC) in January 2017, pursuant to the Supreme Court's order in the *M.C. Mehta* case. It is now implemented by CAQM.
Why it matters:
pre-emptive, graded and cumulative curbs rather than reactive measures.

Additional context

  • CAQM's GRAP Sub-Committee revoked all Stage III actions across Delhi-NCR on 22 January 2026 after air quality improved. Stage I and II actions stayed in force.
  • CAQM has revised the GRAP schedule several times, most recently on 29 September 2026. The four-stage AQI bands (Poor 201–300, Very Poor 301–400, Severe 401–450, Severe+ above 450) remain unchanged.

Mains dimensions

  • Beyond festival-time focus: the Court shifted attention from Deepavali fireworks to year-round vehicular emissions. Fireworks accounted for nearly 55% of PM2.5 a day after the festival (government data), yet vehicles, construction dust and crop burning are the persistent contributors.
  • Federal coordination: the airshed spans Delhi, UP, Haryana and Rajasthan. The Court asked for inspections, challans and denied entries, plus coordination mechanisms. CAQM was created exactly for this.
  • Implementation deficit: the January and February orders recommended phasing out polluting vehicles, strengthening PUC, more rail and metro, EV policy and shifting coal industries, but compliance reporting is lacking. Judicial monitoring (continuing mandamus) has limits when the executive does not report.
  • Parliamentary oversight: dropping the topic from the Standing Committee's agenda, which Maken says leaves no new date, raises concerns about legislative scrutiny of a public health issue.
  • Data transparency: Kharge's claim that PM2.5 readings vanished from 36 of 59 stations (an allegation) and that ₹1,154 crore of environmental compensation lies unspent points to monitoring and fund-utilisation gaps. Verify before using in answers.
  • Transboundary angle: Pakistan blames India's Deepavali smoke. Both countries share the Indo-Gangetic Plain airshed and common causes. There is no regional air-quality mechanism, so the issue is a candidate for SAARC or bilateral cooperation.
  • Public health and equity: the committee's own agenda title referred to the protection of vulnerable sections.
  • Way forward: phase out old vehicles, expand public transport and EVs, enforce PUC, regional emission monitoring and public data, clear compliance reporting to the Court and CAQM.

Possible Mains question

**GS3, 15 marks:** "Air pollution in Delhi-NCR is a regional and year-round problem, not merely a post-Deepavali one. Examine the role of the judiciary and CAQM in tackling vehicular emissions and suggest measures for effective inter-state coordination."

Related topics

  • Art. 21, Art. 48A, Art. 51A(g); M.C. Mehta cases; continuing mandamus and amicus curiae
  • National Clean Air Programme (NCAP) and the AQI categories
  • Stubble burning, BS-VI norms, EV policy, vehicle scrappage
  • Parliamentary Standing Committees; National Green Tribunal
  • Transboundary pollution and regional cooperation (Indo-Gangetic Plain)

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 11 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs