Caste and class
Source: The Hindu, 11 November 2026
Summary
- The editorial argues that OBC reservation must address both caste hierarchy and class inequality within OBCs. The creamy-layer rules are meant to exclude advanced OBC families, but the government has applied them inconsistently.
- In March 2026 (Rohith Nathan), the Supreme Court held that the parents' salary alone cannot show social advancement. On 6 November it clarified that it had not asked the government to reopen completed selections.
- The editorial wants a proactive policy, including supernumerary posts and application of the 1993 rules to pending allocations. It also wants public data on intra-OBC inequality, including the Rohini Commission report.
Key facts for Prelims
- Creamy layer originated in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992), which upheld 27% OBC reservation in central services.
- Ram Nandan Prasad Committee (1993) → DoPT Office Memorandum of 8 Sept 1993 (status tests Categories I–V + income/wealth test Category VI).
- Income ceiling for creamy layer: ₹8 lakh per annum (since 2017); salary and agricultural income are excluded from the income test.
- Relevant provisions: Arts. 14, 15(4), 16(4), 340. In Rohith Nathan, Arts. 14 and 16 were invoked against "hostile discrimination".
- Rohini Commission (Art. 340): sub-categorisation of OBCs. The article says its report was submitted in 2023 and is still not public.
- DoPT = the department that issues the Office Memoranda laying down creamy-layer criteria for central services (the 1993 OM and later clarifications).
- Supernumerary posts: posts created additionally, without displacing existing incumbents.
Data and details
- Timeline in the article:
- 1992: Indra Sawhney (27% OBC reservation, with creamy-layer exclusion).
- 1993: equivalence requirement/OM.
- 2004: DoPT "clarification".
- ~2015 onward: government used the clarification to deny dozens of OBC Civil Services Exam qualifiers their benefits because of parents' salaries.
- 2017: Cabinet approved equivalence guidelines; a parliamentary committee criticised them on several issues.
- March 2026: Rohith Nathan.
- 2025 exam: allocations stalled; the government argued retrospective application would create "administrative chaos".
- 6 November: the Court said it had not asked the government to reopen completed selections, since that could set workers against one another while leaving government misapplication unaddressed.
- Salary revisions: the denial occurred because pay revisions pushed parents' salaries above the threshold without reflecting a change in occupational status.
- OBC representation in central government employment: 26.3% (DoPT Annual Report 2024-25). It "declined steadily towards higher positions".
- Rohini Commission report: submitted in 2023, still not in the public domain.
- Upcoming Census includes caste enumeration. The editorial says policymakers also need caste-wise data on education, occupations, assets and landholdings.
- Remedy asked for: supernumerary posts for legitimate claimants, and the 1993 rules applied to pending allocations. These should not be reserved only for those who can afford litigation.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Reservation for backward classes rests on Arts. 15(4) and 16(4). The creamy-layer doctrine applies the idea of relative equality: treating unequals alike within a class violates Art. 14.
- Eligibility is mainly status-based (parent's post or rank). Income is only a residual test.
- An executive "clarification" (2004) cannot override a binding framework (the 1993 OM). The judiciary polices executive overreach but leaves policy design (equivalence of posts) to the executive.
- Redistribution within backward classes (sub-categorisation, Art. 340) needs empirical data on caste-wise benefit capture. The article says this data is missing.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Arts. 14, 15(4), 16(4), 340; judicial review of executive memoranda; GS2 – Social Justice: welfare of backward classes; GS1 – Society: social empowerment
Background primer
Creamy layer (OBC)
- What it is:
- the exclusion of socially and economically advanced OBC members from reservation, so that benefits reach the genuinely backward sections.
- Founded:
- introduced in *Indra Sawhney* (1992), which upheld 27% OBC reservation and directed that the advanced sections be excluded. The Ram Nandan Prasad Committee (1993) set the objective criteria on which the DoPT's 1993 Office Memorandum is based.
- Why it matters:
- the idea of relative equality: treating unequals as equals would violate the right to equality.
Rohith Nathan (2026) — the Supreme Court ruling
Additional context
-
The Court later clarified, on the Centre's plea, that the ruling operates prospectively. It does not alter past allocations, appointments or seniority lists, but strictly governs pending allocations, including CSE 2025.
-
The DoPT had sought to proceed with service allocation for the 958 candidates recommended by the UPSC, using the creamy-layer criteria applied before the March verdict.
-
The Centre argued that salary can be the "sole intelligible differentia" between OBC candidates. It warned that parents earning up to ₹1 crore could count as non-creamy-layer if salary is excluded.
-
The Court said creamy-layer policy and post equivalence belong to the executive and legislature, subject to constitutional principles, and set no deadline for that exercise.
-
In the EWS case (Neil Aurelio Nunes), the Union itself distinguished OBC criteria (salary excluded) from EWS criteria (salary included).
-
The ₹8 lakh ceiling was last revised in 2017.
Mains dimensions
- Caste vs class: caste disadvantage does not make economic differences within OBCs irrelevant. Creamy-layer rules aim to separate the advanced from the backward.
- Executive arbitrariness: the 2004 clarification overrode the 1993 OM. The government applied it from about 2015 to deny OBC qualifiers, based on salaries inflated by pay revisions.
- Remedy gap: the government stalled allocations. The Court (6 Nov) refused to unsettle completed selections, so relief risks going only to litigants. The editorial wants policy-level relief, namely supernumerary posts and the 1993 rules for pending cases.
- Representation data: OBCs hold 26.3% of central employment but their share falls at higher levels (the "glass ceiling" in higher services).
- Intra-OBC inequality: the Rohini Commission pointed to uneven distribution among OBC communities. The suppressed report limits evidence-based policy. Both defending redistribution among castes while ignoring inequality within them, and curbing OBC quotas on an unproven assumption of elite capture, are hard to justify.
- Judiciary–executive balance: the Court corrects arbitrariness but leaves equivalence-framework design to the executive. The Cabinet's 2017 guidelines drew parliamentary criticism.
- Way forward: publish the Rohini report; collect caste-wise socio-economic data through the Census; settle post-equivalence guidelines; consider periodic revision of the income ceiling.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The creamy-layer principle seeks to balance caste-based and class-based disadvantage within OBC reservation. Critically examine, in the light of recent Supreme Court rulings and the issues in its implementation."
Related topics
- Indra Sawhney (1992), M. Nagaraj, Jarnail Singh (creamy layer for SC/ST promotions), EWS 10% quota (103rd Amendment)
- Sub-categorisation of OBCs (Art. 340, Rohini Commission) and SC/ST sub-classification (State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh, 2024)
- National Commission for Backward Classes (102nd Amendment, Art. 338B)
- Caste enumeration in the Census; Socio-Economic and Caste Census (SECC)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 11 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs