BrainParrot

ED is not a ‘super cop’, can’t file private plaint: Karnataka HC

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 8 November 2026

Summary

  • The Karnataka High Court (Justice M.I. Arun) held that the Enforcement Directorate (ED) cannot file a private complaint to start a money-laundering probe when competent agencies decline to prosecute a scheduled offence on the ED's information.
  • It called ED's power under the PMLA "derivative and not original". Under Section 66(2), ED's duty is to pass the information to the concerned agency, not to investigate it itself.
  • The Court allowed writ petitions by Malur MLA and Congress leader K.Y. Nanjegowda and others, who challenged the ED's ECIR, seizure confirmation, summons and private complaint.

UPSC relevance: GS2 – Polity: judiciary, separation of powers, investigative agencies; GS3 – Security: money laundering

Key facts for Prelims

  • PMLA 2002 is administered by the Directorate of Enforcement under the Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue).
  • Section 66(2) PMLA: where ED finds a scheduled offence, it must pass the information to the concerned agency (per the HC ruling).
  • Predicate/scheduled offence: a prerequisite for the offence of money laundering. The offences are listed in the Schedule to the Act.
  • ECIR (Enforcement Case Information Report) is ED's internal case document, not an FIR.
  • Private complaint: Section 200 CrPC corresponds to Section 223 BNSS (Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita). The HC held that neither is contemplated by the PMLA for ED.
  • Money-laundering proceeds are tried before a special court under the PMLA.
  • Keywords from the judgment: ED's power is "derivative and not original". ED is "not a super cop". Where an act is to be done in a particular way, it must be done that way and no other way.

Data and details

  • ECIR registered by ED in November 2023, based on a private complaint about an alleged "land scam".
  • During that probe ED reportedly found evidence of a "job scam" involving the Kolar and Chikkaballapur Milk Union Ltd. (KOMUL).
  • ED shared the job-scam information with the police. The police did not act, so ED itself filed a private complaint before a special court.
  • Petitioners: K.Y. Nanjegowda (Malur MLA, Congress; chairs KOMUL and the Malur Land Grant Committee) and others.
  • Orders and steps challenged: the ECIR, the order confirming seizure of articles, summons, and the private complaint filed by ED.
  • Petitioners' argument: if the predicate offence collapses, even on technical grounds, ED cannot continue PMLA proceedings. If ED finds a different scheduled offence, it can only share information with the competent agency.
  • Court's reasoning:
  • the PMLA does not contemplate a private complaint
  • allowing it would let ED file against anyone and investigate by itself
  • this would "go against the philosophy of the Act", which needs an existing predicate offence
  • the ruling also invokes separation of powers and checks and balances
  • Notably: the Court did not accept ED's route even though the police had declined to act on the information.

Static–dynamic linkage

Statutory bodies hold only the powers their parent Act gives them. Where a statute prescribes how something is done, it must be done that way. The PMLA treats money laundering as dependent on a "scheduled" (predicate) offence, which another agency investigates. The ED's role is to trace and act on the proceeds of that crime. It is not a free-standing general investigator. The ruling applies checks-and-balances reasoning to a powerful central agency.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Executive and judiciary: structure, organisation, functioning; Statutory/regulatory bodies; Separation of powers; GS3 – Security: money laundering and its prevention

Background primer

Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 and the Directorate of Enforcement

What it is:
** An Act to prevent money laundering, provide for confiscation of property derived from or involved in it, and punish those who commit the offence.

Mains dimensions

  • Rule of law and statutory limits: an agency may exercise only the powers expressly given. The Court's "super cop" language is a warning against open-ended central investigative power.
  • Predicate offence as gatekeeper: the PMLA is anchored to a scheduled offence. If the police or competent agency refuses to prosecute, ED cannot use a private complaint to get round that decision.
  • Federalism and the police: police are a State subject, while ED is a central agency. The ruling reinforces the division of roles. ED must pass information on and let the competent agency decide.
  • Accountability gap: the case arose because the police did not act on ED's information. This raises the question of what remedy exists for an inactive predicate agency. (The Act's Section 66(2) duty is only to intimate.)
  • Political and institutional context: the case involves an Opposition MLA and an institution chairman. It reflects a wider debate on the perceived misuse of central agencies against political opponents.
  • Judicial approach: the Court reads the PMLA narrowly and strictly, in line with its recourse to constitutional principle. Other High Courts and the Supreme Court may differ, so an appeal is plausible.
  • Way forward: statutory clarity on ED–predicate-agency coordination, time-bound procedures on information shared under Section 66(2), and judicial oversight rather than agency discretion.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Karnataka High Court has held that the Enforcement Directorate is not a 'super cop'. Discuss the limits on the ED's powers under the PMLA and the implications for the working of central investigative agencies in a federal system."

Related topics

  • PMLA 2002: Sections 3, 5, 45 (bail), 66(2); Vijay Madanlal Choudhary (2022)
  • CrPC Section 200 / BNSS Section 223 (private complaints, cognizance)
  • Separation of powers; judicial review of agency action
  • Central investigative agencies: CBI, NIA and federal police issues
  • Money laundering and FATF standards

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 8 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs