Another retired judge resigns from Bengal SIR tribunal
Source: The Hindu, 8 November 2026
Summary
- Retired Calcutta High Court judge Biswajit Basu resigned from a West Bengal SIR tribunal on Saturday, citing personal reasons. He is the fourth judge to step down from the 19 tribunals hearing appeals by voters deleted in SIR.
- In Karnataka, after The Hindu reported residual duplicates in Mahadevapura constituency after SIR, the Chief Electoral Officer's office blamed data-processing circumstances, specifically multiple Form 6 applications handled independently and unfinished Form 7 deletions during the roll freeze.
- Together, the two stories show SIR's two weak points: slow appellate redress and incomplete cleaning of the rolls.
Key facts for Prelims
- ECI: constitutional body under Article 324. The tribunals here are appellate bodies constituted by the ECI in compliance with a Supreme Court order, each headed by a retired High Court judge.
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: Form 6 (inclusion), Form 7 (objection/deletion), Form 8 (correction/shifting).
- Electoral Registration Officer (ERO) prepares and updates the roll for a constituency.
- EPIC = Elector Photo Identity Card. The same EPIC number should not appear in two constituencies.
- Statutory basis for SIR: Section 21(3) RP Act 1950 and Article 324.
- ECINET: ECI's digital portal, used by tribunals and for appeals.
- West Bengal's 19 SIR tribunals were set up by ECI after a Supreme Court order and are headed by retired High Court judges.
Data and details
- Bengal tribunals
- Justice (retd.) Biswajit Basu resigned on Saturday, the fourth judge to quit.
- Earlier resignations: former Calcutta HC Chief Justice T.S. Sivagnanam (first, May 2026), then Justice Ranjit Kumar Bagh and Justice Indrajit Chatterjee.
- All four cited personal reasons.
- 19 tribunals are tasked with 38 lakh appeals from voters deleted in SIR.
- Basu had earlier said resolving lakhs of cases this way is "a little difficult", but that it must be done because the Supreme Court directed it.
- Minutes of the August 11 meeting of tribunal judges: most judges said the ECINET portal failed to work as intended. Judges also voiced displeasure at the slow pace of disposal.
- Basu's resignation was sent to Calcutta HC Chief Justice Ravindra Vithalrao Ghuge. He has also been appointed chairman of the Commission on Institutional Corruption by the Suvendu Adhikari-led government.
- Karnataka (Mahadevapura)
- At least 803 voter IDs linked to 397 people persisted after SIR.
- The same EPIC number appeared in the final rolls of two constituencies in some cases.
- Cause 1: some applicants filed multiple Form 6 applications via the Citizen Service Portal. These were "processed independently", generating multiple EPIC numbers.
- Cause 2: Form 8 (migration) was approved and the name added to the new constituency. The matching Form 7 (deletion from the old constituency) stayed pending because roll operations were frozen under statutory provisions before final publication.
- The article notes SIR was meant to flag repeat applications through its phased process, but the system processed them independently.
Static–dynamic linkage
The Election Commission's constitutional duty under Article 324 includes keeping an accurate electoral roll. SIR, a deep special revision, aims to remove deceased, shifted and duplicate entries and include all eligible citizens. Two tests of any such exercise are whether the machinery for removing duplicates works and whether deleted voters get a fast, credible appeal. A tribunal system that loses its judges, and a roll that still carries duplicate EPIC numbers, both affect the integrity of the franchise.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Constitutional bodies (ECI); Representation of the People Act, 1950 (electoral rolls); Tribunals and judicial redress; Electoral reforms; Transparency and e-governance
Background primer
Election Commission of India and the SIR framework
- What it is:
- ** The constitutional body that supervises and controls elections and electoral rolls. Article 324 gives it total superintendence and control over elections.
- Mandate:
- ** preparing electoral rolls and conducting elections to Parliament, State legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR)
- What it is:
- ** An intensive voter-roll verification and re-enumeration drive to build fresh rolls by purging deceased, shifted, duplicate and ineligible voters through house-to-house enumeration.
SIR Appellate Tribunals (West Bengal)
- What it is:
- ** ECI-constituted tribunals to hear appeals on inclusion or exclusion of voters in the SIR exercise in the State.
- Mandate:
- ** The tribunals cease to exist once all appeals are disposed of in the respective districts.
Additional context
- Appeals can be filed online via the ECI NET platform or at offices of District Magistrates, Sub-Divisional Magistrates or Sub-Divisional Officers.
- The Supreme Court ordered three retired Chief Justices or judges to oversee speedy disposal of appeals. The Calcutta High Court Chief Justice was to form this committee, which monitors the 19 tribunals.
- The Court said that mere pendency of an appeal gives no right to vote.
- While refusing to entertain writ petitions directly and sending petitioners to the tribunals, the Court noted that nearly 30–34 lakh appeals were pending, with each tribunal handling over one lakh cases.
Mains dimensions
- Appellate capacity vs scale: 19 tribunals face 38 lakh appeals. Four resignations of retired judges in about six months (May to November 2026) cut capacity just as the backlog is large.
- Systemic causes vs "personal reasons": all four cited personal reasons. But the August 11 minutes record complaints about the ECINET portal, and judges have voiced frustration at the pace. Together these suggest infrastructure and workload strain as a factor.
- Independence and propriety: one resigning judge had been named to head a State Government commission. This raises questions of post-retirement appointments for judges who sit on electoral tribunals.
- Right to vote and delayed justice: if appeals take years, deletion can effectively become permanent disenfranchisement. The Supreme Court has said pendency alone gives no right to vote, so speed matters.
- Data quality in e-governance: Karnataka's duplicate EPICs arose from independent processing of multiple Form 6 applications and from a Form 8/Form 7 sequencing gap during the freeze. These are design flaws in the system's logic, not just user error. They undercut the claim of a "clean roll".
- ECI credibility: a revision meant to remove duplicates still left duplicates. This feeds Opposition and civil-society criticism of SIR.
- Way forward:
- expand tribunal strength and fix ECINET
- time-bound disposal with SC-monitored benchmarks
- cross-constituency deduplication keyed to EPIC and Aadhaar-seeding safeguards
- an audit and public disclosure of post-SIR duplicates
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls aims at a 'clean roll', yet appeals backlogs and residual duplicate entries persist. Critically examine the challenges in ensuring both accuracy and inclusiveness of electoral rolls."
Related topics
- Article 324, Articles 325–326; RP Act 1950 (Sections 16, 19, 21); Registration of Electors Rules 1960
- ADR v. ECI (SIR validity) and Mohinder Singh Gill (1977)
- Tribunals in India: independence, post-retirement appointments
- Electoral reforms: voter-ID/Aadhaar linkage, ECINET
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 8 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs