Shah slams Congress, says SIR helped govt. identify 3 crore ‘illegal infiltrator...
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 3 November 2026
Summary
- Union Home Minister Amit Shah said that three crore "unaccounted voters" were among the roughly 13 crore names removed from electoral rolls in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR). He called them "illegal infiltrators from Bangladesh" and said they would be expelled. He spoke in Hyderabad's Old City after a "Save democracy-Remove anarchy" foot march.
- The Opposition's INDIA bloc, led by the Congress, held a very large rally at Delhi's Ramlila Maidan on Sunday against the SIR. The Hindu editorial calls it a milestone in defending election integrity. It also cautions Rahul Gandhi against overstating his case.
- Separately, the ECI is likely to revise the ECINet portal so that West Bengal's SIR Appellate Tribunal judges can e-sign and upload orders. Until now the portal required Aadhaar-based authentication, which judges said held up final orders.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324: ECI's superintendence, direction and control over rolls and elections. Article 326: adult suffrage at 18.
- RP Act, 1950: Section 16 excludes non-citizens. Section 19 includes citizens aged 18+ who are ordinarily resident in the constituency. Section 21(3) covers special revision. The Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 give the procedure.
- First appeal against a roll decision lies to the District Magistrate and second appeal to the Chief Electoral Officer. The ground-level officer is the Booth Level Officer (BLO), supported by party-nominated Booth Level Agents (BLAs).
- The ECI's digital platform is ECINet, which the e-sign change would modify.
- SIR Appellate Tribunals in West Bengal: 19 tribunals, formed on the Supreme Court's directions. Their judicial officers are drawn from a list sent by the Calcutta High Court.
- Aadhaar-based authentication is currently the norm for tribunal judges on the portal. The proposed alternative is e-signing.
Data and details
- Mr. Shah's figures: nearly 13 crore names deleted in the SIR. He split them as 4.25 crore registered in two different locations, three crore deceased and one crore duplicate entries. Separately, he said three crore were "unaccounted" voters, whom he called infiltrators from Bangladesh.
- Arithmetic check: the three categories he named add up to 8.25 crore, which is well short of the roughly 13 crore deleted. Adding the 3 crore "unaccounted" gives 11.25 crore.
- Mr. Shah's framing and rhetoric:
- He asked rhetorically whether infiltrators should be removed from the country's voter lists, and questioned whether such names should remain on the rolls.
- He called Sunday's Opposition rally a "save infiltrators" rally.
- He accused the Congress and Opposition of treating these voters as a "vote bank".
- He asked BJP workers to counter "fear-mongering" through a door-to-door campaign.
- He named Rahul Gandhi and Telangana CM A. Revanth Reddy as defenders of the alleged infiltrators.
- Tribunals: more than 38 lakh voters' cases are stuck in 19 Appellate Tribunals in West Bengal. The tribunals are handling roughly 60 lakh "doubtful and pending" cases.
- Editorial facts:
- The Ramlila Maidan crowd was in the "hundreds of thousands".
- Protestors came from across India and included people directly affected by the SIR.
- ECI chief Gyanesh Kumar has stayed silent while the BJP has "rushed to shield" him.
- The Opposition coordinated across the spectrum, often with State-level rivals.
- The editorial calls it the largest show of Opposition strength in recent memory.
- It says the protest reinforced Mr. Gandhi's role as the key challenger of PM Modi, and notes his stated focus on giving subaltern classes positions of responsibility in the party.
- It says Mr. Gandhi was caricatured by the BJP as a privileged dynast.
- Cited by the editorial as unexplained: "malpractices" in the SIR that could subvert the popular will.
Static–dynamic linkage
- The ECI's power over electoral rolls comes from Article 324, which gives it superintendence, direction and control of the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections. Article 326 gives universal adult suffrage.
- The statutory machinery is the RP Act, 1950 and the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. The core tension is between roll "purity" (removing the dead, duplicate and ineligible) and roll "inclusion" (not disenfranchising genuine citizens). Citizenship is decided under the Citizenship Act, but the roll is decided under the RP Act.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI), Representation of the People Acts, electoral reforms, citizenship and the franchise; GS2 — Governance: transparency and accountability of institutions.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- A permanent constitutional body under Article 324 that conducts elections to Parliament, State legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Founded:
- 25 January 1950 (observed as National Voters' Day). Its purpose was to run free and fair elections for the new Republic.
- Members:
- The Chief Election Commissioner and such number of other Election Commissioners as the President fixes. The article names Gyanesh Kumar as the chief.
- Mandate:
- It prepares and revises electoral rolls, supervises elections, registers parties and enforces the Model Code of Conduct.
- Why it matters:
- An autonomous body insulated from the executive, so that the electoral process stays impartial.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR)
- What it is:
- A focused, time-bound, house-to-house voter verification exercise conducted by Booth Level Officers to update and correct the rolls before major elections.
- Why it matters:
- To support "one person, one vote" by removing ghost and duplicate entries and building public trust in the rolls.
Additional context
- Phase I of the SIR was first undertaken in Bihar, ahead of the 2025 Assembly elections. The ECI then announced a second phase across 12 States/UTs.
- The ECI says deletions fall into four categories: death, permanent shifting, duplicate entries in more than one place, and electors untraceable despite repeated visits. Mr. Shah's categories (double-registered, deceased, duplicate) broadly overlap with these administrative categories.
- Safeguards the ECI lists include publication of a draft roll, a claims-and-objections window (Forms 6, 7 and 8), an appeal to the District Magistrate and further recourse to the Chief Electoral Officer.
- Supreme Court position (ADR v. ECI, 2026), as summarised by Vision IAS: The ECI may examine citizenship questions for roll inclusion, but this does not divest anyone of citizenship claims. That decision rests with the competent authority under the Citizenship Act. ForumIAS reports that the Court ordered those deleted on citizenship grounds to be referred to the competent authority within four weeks, with voting rights restored if they are found to be citizens.
- Critics' data point from an Insights on India explainer: In Bihar, of 1,087 objections raised against suspected foreign infiltrators, 390 were accepted for verification and only three people were finally identified as non-citizens. The same explainer estimates about 13 crore voters struck off nationally, projected to reach about 14 crore. This is a critic's framing, not an official figure.
Mains dimensions
- Institutional credibility: The editorial says the ECI chief's silence and the ruling party's defence of him weaken the Commission's image as an impartial referee. A body with plenary powers under Article 324 needs visible accountability, such as published reasons for deletions and the data behind them.
- Politicisation of the roll: The same deletion data is read in opposite ways. The Home Minister treats it as proof of "infiltrators". The Opposition treats it as mass disenfranchisement. Mr. Shah's own categories (dead, duplicate, double-registered) are administrative, while his "infiltrator" label is a citizenship claim. The Supreme Court has said roll deletion is not a declaration of non-citizenship. A senior political office-holder using deletion figures to claim a citizenship finding blurs this line. His categories also do not add up to the full 13 crore, which shows why a disaggregated, officially published breakdown matters.
- Inclusion vs purity: Wrongful exclusion hurts the right to vote (Article 326), whereas wrongful inclusion dilutes it. Migrants, the poor and unorganised workers face documentary barriers.
- Grievance redress and its bottlenecks: The ECI's move to e-sign shows that the appeals layer can itself become the choke point. The 38 lakh stuck cases mean that voters may not be restored before polls. Tying judicial orders to Aadhaar authentication also raises the question of whether quasi-judicial orders should depend on an executive identity system.
- Federal and political angle: Opposition parties coordinated across State-level rivalries. The editorial credits the Congress for this but warns that Mr. Gandhi questioned the legitimacy of the previous election "without substantive basis". Loose allegations can weaken a valid demand for accountability.
- Way forward: Publish deletion lists with reasons, run independent audits of deletions, fast-track tribunal disposal, and keep citizenship adjudication with the competent legal authority.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has been defended as a step towards roll purity but criticised as a threat to universal adult suffrage. Critically examine, with reference to the constitutional and statutory powers of the Election Commission of India."
Related topics
- Article 324, the independence of the ECI and the appointment and removal of election commissioners
- RP Acts 1950 and 1951 (rolls vs conduct and disqualifications); Citizenship Act, 1955 (and NRC/NPR debates)
- Aadhaar and its legal limits (Aadhaar Act, 2016: identity, not citizenship)
- Electoral reforms and quasi-judicial grievance redress
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 3 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs