SC reserves verdict on ED plea for CBI probe in I-PAC case
Source: The Hindu, 30 October 2026
Summary
On Thursday (Oct 29) the Supreme Court reserved judgment in the ED's petition seeking a CBI probe into alleged obstruction of its raids at I-PAC and its co-founder Pratik Jain's premises in Kolkata. The accused include then West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee, State officials and others. A Bench headed by Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra closed final arguments. Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, for Ms Banerjee, noted that power in West Bengal has changed hands and that the current government could decide whether to transfer the case to the CBI.
Key facts for Prelims
- ED: enforces PMLA, 2002 (and FEMA); described in the article as the anti-money-laundering agency.
- CBI: statutory basis in the DSPE Act, 1946; probes into States ordinarily need State consent.
- Article 32: right to constitutional remedies (writ jurisdiction of the Supreme Court). The Court said it would decide the maintainability of the ED petition under Article 32.
- Kesavananda Bharati (1973): basic structure doctrine, cited before the Bench in the hearing.
- Police and public order are State List subjects.
- I-PAC: political consultancy; Pratik Jain is a co-founder.
Data and details
- Hearing: Supreme Court reserved judgment on Thursday; Bench headed by Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra closed final arguments.
- Respondents (arraigned by ED): State of West Bengal, Mamata Banerjee, State DGP, Kolkata Police Commissioner, DCP South Kolkata, along with the CBI.
- ED's allegations: Ms Banerjee removed records and devices from the raid sites. State machinery's illegal intervention turned the sites into a "showdown" (ED's petition). Her intervention upset a lawful investigation into coal smuggling.
- Banerjee's defence: the raids were a deliberate attempt to derail the Trinamool Congress ahead of the 2026 Assembly election.
- Sibal's submission: power in West Bengal has changed hands, so the current government could decide whether the case is transferred to the CBI.
- Context: I-PAC helped the TMC in the 2021 Assembly election and subsequent elections in West Bengal.
- Description of Ms Banerjee as "then" CM reflects the change in government in the State.
Static–dynamic linkage
Police and public order are State subjects, but the Centre has agencies with specific statutory mandates (ED under PMLA). The CBI is governed by the DSPE Act, and its jurisdiction in a State ordinarily requires State consent. Constitutional courts can nevertheless order a CBI probe where they find that the State's machinery cannot be trusted. The case tests where the line lies between a State's powers and central-agency investigations of serious offences, and what happens when a State actor is accused of interfering in a lawful investigation.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Federal structure and Centre–State relations (law and order, police and investigative agencies), role of the judiciary (writ jurisdiction, directing CBI probes), accountability of constitutional office-holders; GS3 — Internal security: money laundering and agencies.
Background primer
Enforcement Directorate (ED)
- What it is:
- The central agency that investigates money laundering and foreign-exchange violations. In this case it describes itself as the anti-money-laundering agency.
- Mandate:
- Enforces the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA) and FEMA, 1999. The agency sits under the Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance.
Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)
- What it is:
- India's premier central investigating agency, whose statutory basis is the Delhi Special Police Establishment (DSPE) Act, 1946.
I-PAC
Additional context
- The ED raids took place on January 8 as part of a multi-crore money-laundering investigation linked to an alleged coal smuggling scam.
- The ED alleged that Ms Banerjee, accompanied by more than 100 police personnel and senior officials, entered the I-PAC office and Mr Jain's residence during the searches.
- The ED first approached the Calcutta High Court seeking a CBI probe against the Chief Minister before moving the Supreme Court.
- The Supreme Court stayed FIRs registered by West Bengal Police against ED officials over the searches and directed preservation of CCTV footage and storage devices till the next hearing.
- The Court agreed to examine whether a state's law-enforcing agencies can interfere with a central agency's investigation into a serious offence.
- The Bench warned that democracy would be in peril if a sitting CM intervenes in an ongoing investigation. It said the issue is not merely a Centre–State dispute but an act by an individual holding constitutional office.
- The Court rejected arguments to refer the matter to a larger bench and said it would decide maintainability of the petition under Article 32.
- Ms Banerjee lodged complaints at two Kolkata police stations against the ED after the search.
Mains dimensions
- Federal conflict over investigations: The ED alleges the State machinery, including the DGP and city police chiefs, obstructed a lawful central probe. The Court itself has framed the question as whether State law-enforcement agencies can interfere with a central agency's investigation into a serious offence. The answer will shape Centre–State relations in policing.
- Accountability of constitutional office-holders: The Court observed that the matter concerns a person holding constitutional office, not simply a Centre–State dispute. This puts rule-of-law principles (nobody is above investigation) at the centre.
- Political weaponisation of agencies: The defence argued that raids were intended to hurt the TMC ahead of the 2026 election. Opposition parties often allege central agencies are used selectively against them. Court guidelines or findings on a fair, non-partisan process would matter.
- Mootness and political change: Sibal's point that West Bengal's government has changed shows the interplay between litigation and politics. As Sibal put it, the current State government could decide whether the case is transferred to the CBI, which may affect how the dispute proceeds.
- Judicial role: The SC's ability to direct a CBI probe under Article 32 despite State objections, and its decision not to refer the case to a larger bench, relate to the delicate balance of federalism and the Court's duty to protect the integrity of investigations.
- Evidence integrity: Alleged removal of devices and records, and the Court's earlier direction to preserve CCTV, highlight the importance of tamper-proof evidence handling during searches.
- Way forward: Clear protocols for State cooperation with central searches, safeguards against arbitrary use of agencies, and prompt, reasoned judicial decisions.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Alleged interference by a State government in an investigation by a central agency raises questions of federalism and the rule of law. Discuss in light of the recent controversy over the I-PAC raids, and examine the role of the judiciary in resolving such conflicts."
Related topics
- Federalism: State, Union and Concurrent Lists; Article 355 and Centre–State relations
- Article 32 and Article 226 (writ jurisdiction); Article 131 (original jurisdiction in Centre–State disputes)
- CBI: DSPE Act, general consent, and Supreme Court rulings on CBI probes
- PMLA, 2002 and the powers of the ED
- Basic structure doctrine (Kesavananda Bharati)
- Free and fair elections and the role of political consultancies
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 30 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs