Is GRAP enough to curb pollution?
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 29 October 2026
Summary
- With Delhi's air quality slipping to the 'poor' category, the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) announced Stage 1 of the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP) in Delhi-NCR.
- The explainer describes how GRAP works, who enforces it, how it evolved from the EPCA era to CAQM, and what its stages require.
- A CREA analysis (22 October 2026) finds no consistent improvement in Delhi's winter air quality over four years despite GRAP. The Delhi government has added its own winter curbs this year.
Key facts for Prelims
- CAQM was constituted under the CAQM in NCR and Adjoining Areas Act, 2021 and replaced EPCA, which the Supreme Court had constituted in 1998.
- GRAP was first notified by MoEFCC in January 2017 on Supreme Court directions.
- GRAP stages (Delhi AQI): I 'Poor' 201–300; II 'Very Poor' 301–400; III 'Severe' 401–450; IV 'Severe+' above 450.
- CAQM directions bind State governments in Delhi and the NCR districts of Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan. The Commission can initiate legal action against officers who do not follow them.
- Stage III: ban on construction and demolition in Delhi-NCR and on BS III petrol / BS IV and below diesel LMVs in Delhi and the High Vehicle Density districts (Gurugram, Faridabad, Sonipat, Ghaziabad, Gautam Buddh Nagar).
- Stage IV: stricter construction ban with fewer exemptions, and a ban on truck entry into Delhi except BS-VI, electric, CNG and LNG trucks.
- Stage I: mostly strict implementation of existing norms, including no regular use of diesel generator sets.
- GRAP stages are announced on the basis of the pollution level recorded or forecast for the near future. GRAP can be imposed at any time of the year, but the higher stages are mostly invoked in winter.
- CREA is the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air, a Finland-based non-profit research organisation.
Data and details
- CREA winter AQI (Delhi):
- Mean: 280 (2022–23), 304 (2023–24), 285 (2024–25), 295 (2025–26).
- Median: 294, 324, 289 and 305 for the same winters.
- CREA analyst Manoj Kumar says the latest winter's mean and median were both higher than in 2022–23, with no consistent downward trend since the 2022 revision of GRAP.
- Delhi government's June 23 notification (irrespective of AQI):
- From 1 November to 31 January, a ban on non-Delhi-registered vehicles below BS-VI standard. Electric, CNG, emergency and sovereign-duty vehicles are exempt.
- From 1 November to 28 February, parking charges at authorised sites are doubled, except DMRC-owned and managed spaces.
- GRAP orders take precedence if they conflict with this notification.
- Seasonal causes: Lower wind speeds and temperature drops, stubble burning in October–November, festive firecrackers, vehicle emissions and dust.
- Enforcement point: GRAP restrictions take effect on the ground only when State governments pass implementing orders.
- Overall: This winter is set to see one of the highest levels of government action in recent years "at least on paper".
Static–dynamic linkage
- Air pollution in Delhi-NCR is a collective-action problem across state borders. Sources include vehicles, dust, stubble burning, firecrackers and meteorological trapping, in an area covering Delhi and parts of Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and Punjab.
- GRAP is an emergency, trigger-based protocol. Measures are tied to AQI bands, so it manages peaks rather than the baseline. The article stresses it is not a long-term strategy.
- The shift from a Supreme Court-created authority (EPCA, 1998) to a statutory commission (CAQM, 2021) reflects the move from judicial oversight to a legally empowered regulator with binding directions.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 — Environment: environmental pollution and degradation, conservation; GS2 — Polity: statutory, regulatory and quasi-judicial bodies, Centre–State relations, judicial intervention in governance.
Background primer
Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM)
- What it is:
- A statutory body under the Commission for Air Quality Management in National Capital Region and Adjoining Areas Act, 2021, for better coordination, research, identification and resolution of problems around air quality.
- Founded:
- It was first formed by an ordinance in October 2020, and the ordinance lapsed in March 2021 and was repromulgated in April 2021 before Parliament passed the Act. The Act dissolved the Environment Pollution (Prevention and Control) Authority (EPCA), established in 1998.
- Members:
- A full-time Chairperson (15 years' experience in environment protection or 25 years' administrative experience), an MoEFCC representative not below Joint Secretary, five ex officio members from Delhi, Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh, three full-time independent technical members, technical members from CPCB and ISRO, three NGO members and a NITI Aayog representative, among others.
- Mandate:
- It can take measures, issue directions and entertain complaints for protecting and improving air quality in the NCR and adjoining areas. Directions may include closure or regulation of an industry, or stoppage of electricity or water supply. In case of conflict, its directions prevail over orders of state governments, CPCB, state PCBs and state-level statutory bodies.
- Why it matters:
- A single empowered authority with legal teeth, since the article notes EPCA was not backed by statute and experts said it lacked the power to act against authorities that ignored its orders.
Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP)
- What it is:
- A set of short-term emergency measures, graded by pollution level, for the whole NCR. It is an emergency response mechanism for the entire NCR, based on average AQI levels in Delhi, that brings together multiple stakeholders and implementing agencies.
- Founded:
- Notified by MoEFCC in January 2017 on Supreme Court directions (article). EPCA implemented it until the CAQM took over in 2021.
- Mandate:
- Actions are triggered when Delhi's AQI crosses, or is forecast to cross, a threshold on the basis of a dynamic model and IMD/IITM forecasts, so higher-stage actions can be invoked in advance of the projected AQI.
- Why it matters:
- Cut emission sources quickly when pollution is very high so that air quality improves, without being a structural fix.
Additional context
- CAQM's 30th Full Commission meeting on 28 September 2026 approved modifications to the GRAP schedule. The revised schedule is dated 29 September 2026. It moved DG-set actions and entry of BS-IV and below buses from Stage II to Stage I. It extended the BS-III petrol and BS-IV diesel LMV restriction to Sonipat in addition to Gurugram, Faridabad, Ghaziabad and Gautam Budh Nagar, and removed exemptions for BS-IV and below goods vehicles carrying essential commodities in Stages III and IV. The revised schedule has 25 actions in Stage I, 8 in Stage II, 10 in Stage III and 5 in Stage IV, a total of 48.
- In the earlier November 2025 revision, measures from Stage IV moved to Stage III, Stage III to Stage II and Stage II to Stage I. Under the November 2025 schedule, the decision on 50% office attendance with the rest working from home sits at Stage III.
- In January 2026 CAQM's Sub-Committee on GRAP revoked Stage III (on 2 January and again on 22 January), citing the disruptive nature of restrictions for a large number of stakeholders and the public. This shows the trade-off between pollution control and economic and social cost.
- CAQM's order list shows the Stage I implementation order dated 21.10.2026.
Mains dimensions
- Reactive vs. structural: GRAP is an emergency, short-term tool that cuts sources temporarily once pollution is high. CREA's four-year numbers show no consistent winter AQI improvement despite repeated revisions. This points to the need for sustained structural measures on transport, industry, power, dust, waste and crop residue.
- Institutional design: EPCA was a Supreme Court-created body without statutory backing, and lacked teeth. CAQM has statutory powers, binding directions, overriding authority over state bodies and legal action against officers who do not comply. Even so, implementation depends on State orders, which creates a gap between announcement and action.
- Federalism and coordination: Multiple states (Delhi, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Punjab) share an airshed. A single commission is the answer to cross-border pollution, but states control enforcement.
- Judicial role: GRAP originated in Supreme Court directions, and the article notes that it has been made more stringent over the years, sometimes after criticism by the Supreme Court.
- Layering of measures: The Delhi government's fixed-date winter restrictions are independent of AQI, whereas GRAP is trigger-based. The GRAP-prevails clause avoids conflict. The two approaches combine preventive and emergency logic.
- Equity and economic costs: Stage III and IV measures (construction bans, vehicle curbs) affect livelihoods and businesses. Higher parking fees and vehicle bans shift costs to commuters, so public transport capacity matters.
- Way forward: Stronger monitoring, source apportionment, clean transport, enforcing existing norms (the main content of Stage I) and year-round action, rather than winter-only response.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "The Graded Response Action Plan has been invoked every winter in Delhi-NCR, yet air quality shows no consistent improvement. Critically examine the effectiveness of GRAP and the institutional framework under CAQM, and suggest long-term measures."
Related topics
- Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981; National Clean Air Programme (NCAP); National Air Quality Index (AQI categories)
- Stubble burning, crop residue management and environmental compensation
- Bharat Stage emission norms (BS-IV/VI), EV policy, public transport
- National Green Tribunal and Supreme Court's role in M.C. Mehta air pollution cases
- Federalism and inter-state coordination bodies
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 29 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs