BrainParrot

Majhi urges Patnaik not to politicise Kotia dispute, reiterates Odisha’s territo...

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 October 2026

Summary

  • Odisha CM Mohan Charan Majhi replied on Tuesday to a 19 October letter from his predecessor Naveen Patnaik. Patnaik had flagged Andhra Pradesh's announcement of elections in Kotia, in Odisha's Koraput district.
  • Majhi said Kotia has been an integral part of Odisha since the separate State was formed in 1936. He said the State is committed to safeguarding its territorial integrity, and he asked Patnaik to offer constructive, legally tenable suggestions instead of treating the issue politically.
  • Patnaik had asked whether the Odisha BJP government's silence stems from the BJP's political dependence on the TDP, which governs Andhra Pradesh and is a crucial NDA ally at the Centre.

UPSC relevance: GS2 – Polity: Federalism, inter-State boundary disputes, local government

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 131: Supreme Court's original and exclusive jurisdiction in Centre–State and inter-State disputes, limited to questions of legal right.
  • Article 3: Parliament can form new States and alter areas, boundaries or names of existing States.
  • Article 263: Inter-State Council, an advisory body to inquire into and advise on inter-State disputes.
  • Panchayat elections are conducted by the State Election Commission. Panchayats are a State subject (Part IX of the Constitution).
  • Odisha became a separate State on 1 April 1936, carved out of the Bihar and Orissa Province.
  • Kotia gram panchayat is in Koraput district, Odisha. The disputed cluster is 21 villages.
  • The TDP governs Andhra Pradesh and is described as a crucial ally of the BJP-led NDA government at the Centre.

Data and details

  • 21 villages in Kotia gram panchayat are claimed by both States, "since 1955" per the article.
  • Odisha's stated position: Kotia has been part of Odisha since 1936.
  • Patnaik's letter is dated 19 October. Majhi's reply came on Tuesday (the issue is dated 28-10-2026).
  • Patnaik's letter raised three points:
  • It called Odisha's government a "double-engine" government.
  • It asked what happened to the BJP's assurances that Kotia belongs to Odisha.
  • It asked whether political dependence on the TDP explains the Odisha government's silence and willingness to compromise on territorial integrity.
  • Majhi's reply raised three points:
  • It said the letter approached the issue from a political standpoint, not through constructive and legally tenable solutions.
  • It said the State has upheld its territorial interests through constitutional means.
  • It said the State has prioritised Kotia's development: inclusive growth, better public service delivery and the well-being of local people.
  • Revenue and Disaster Management Minister Suresh Pujari heads a committee on Kotia and has made several visits to the region for coordinated action on holistic development. He has also asked all political parties to cooperate in protecting the State's territorial integrity.
  • Notably absent in the reported reply: no specific legal or administrative counter-move to AP's election announcement is mentioned. It relies on constitutional means, development work and an appeal to political parties.

Static–dynamic linkage

The Constitution gives India's federal system several routes for settling inter-State disputes:

  • Parliament can alter State boundaries (Article 3).
  • The Supreme Court has original jurisdiction over disputes involving a legal right (Article 131).
  • The President can set up an Inter-State Council under Article 263.

Border disputes persist because State boundaries are legacies of colonial and linguistic reorganisation. Disputes in remote tracts also tend to be fought through competing administration: rival elections, schemes and police posts. The Kotia episode adds a political layer, namely coalition dependence at the Centre, to a long-running boundary question.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Federal structure, inter-State disputes and their redressal; Union–State relations; local government (Panchayats). Also GS1 – Post-independence reorganisation of States.

Background primer

Kotia group of villages (the disputed territory)

What it is:
A cluster of 21 villages under Kotia gram panchayat in Koraput district, Odisha. Both Odisha and Andhra Pradesh have claimed jurisdiction over them since 1955 (per the article).

Constitutional routes for inter-State boundary disputes

Additional context

  • Earlier litigation: Odisha filed a case in the Supreme Court in 1968 (No. 10/1968). It sought right, title and possession over the 21 villages and restrained Andhra Pradesh from interfering in them. The Odisha government's own Orissa Review says that on 30 March 2006 the Supreme Court passed an order citing Article 131 and said the dispute could be resolved only by Parliament.

  • An earlier flare-up: The dispute had resurfaced earlier when Andhra Pradesh announced panchayat polls in three villages of Kotia panchayat.

Mains dimensions

  • Federalism and cooperative federalism: Boundary disputes strain Centre–State and inter-State relations. The available institutional tools are the Article 131 judicial route, Parliament's Article 3 power and the Inter-State Council under Article 263. The 2006 Supreme Court order recorded by Odisha, which said only Parliament can resolve the dispute, suggests the political and legislative route matters most.
  • Competing administration as a tool of claim: AP's election announcement, Odisha's development committee and welfare benefits received from both sides show claims being asserted through governance. Residents are caught between two administrations and depend on both blocks.
  • Coalition politics and federal interests: Patnaik links the Centre's coalition arithmetic (TDP's importance to the NDA) to the Odisha government's stance. Majhi counters that this politicises a sensitive issue. This raises the question of whether regional parties in a coalition can protect their State's territorial interests.
  • Governance deficit in border pockets: Development and service delivery (Majhi's own emphasis) work as legitimacy-building. They also address the basic point that people in disputed areas need schools, power and records irrespective of the claim.
  • Way forward: Standing inter-State mechanisms, joint survey or satellite mapping of boundaries, local consultation, and a bipartisan State position as Pujari has urged.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Inter-State boundary disputes are a persistent challenge to cooperative federalism in India. Discuss the constitutional mechanisms available for their resolution and examine their effectiveness, with reference to the Odisha–Andhra Pradesh dispute over Kotia."

Related topics

  • Article 131 vs. Article 32 (original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court)
  • Reorganisation of States (SRC 1953–56, linguistic States) and Article 3 procedure
  • Inter-State Council and Zonal Councils
  • Other boundary disputes (Assam–Meghalaya, Karnataka–Maharashtra) for comparison
  • Panchayati Raj (73rd Amendment, State Election Commissions)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs