Bid to restrain functioning of CEC against law: ECI to SC
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 27 October 2026
Summary
- The Election Commission of India (ECI), CEC Gyanesh Kumar and ECs Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi filed a joint affidavit of about 250 pages in the Supreme Court late on Monday. It argues that any attempt to restrain the CEC's functioning is contrary to law.
- The petitioners include the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and other INDIA bloc leaders. They allege unilateral or authoritarian functioning by the CEC and rely on a media report about internal frictions in the Commission. The ECI says a media report is hardly evidence.
- The ECI also denies that Form 6 was changed during the SIR orders. Separately, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge demanded the CEC's resignation and an immediate halt to the SIR. He announced the INDIA bloc's Chalo Dilli rally for 1 November.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324 is the source of the ECI's powers. Article 324(5) says the CEC can be removed only like a Supreme Court judge. ECs can be removed only on the CEC's recommendation.
- Removal "like a Supreme Court judge" links to Article 124(4). The process is a Presidential order on a motion passed by both Houses in the same session. It needs a majority of the total membership of each House and at least two-thirds of members present and voting.
- A removal motion needs 100 Lok Sabha or 50 Rajya Sabha signatories. If admitted, a three-member committee investigates (a Supreme Court judge, a High Court Chief Justice and a jurist).
- The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 governs appointment and business. Section 18 provides majority decision-making. It repeals the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of Election Commissioners and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991.
- Form 6 is the statutory application for inclusion in the electoral roll. The SIR "declaration form" is a separate document submitted along with Form 6 (ECI's position).
- Mohinder Singh Gill v. CEC (1978): Article 324 is a plenary power allowing the EC to act even where the law is silent.
Data and details
- The affidavit runs to about 250 pages and was filed late Monday (26 Oct 2026).
- The three SIR orders in which Form 6 is alleged to have been amended are dated 24 June 2025, 27 October 2025 and 14 May 2026. The ECI says Form 6 was not amended.
- The ECI says the mapping details in the additional declaration form are "not part of Form 6". It calls this a measure for the voters' assistance that only removes the need to submit further verification documents.
- The decision chain described in the affidavit: a decision goes first to one EC, then to the other EC, then to the CEC. Approved decisions are noted in the file with the signatures of the ECs and the CEC. The EC Secretariat then notifies and implements them.
- The ECI concedes that where the CEC or an EC cannot be available in person, approval is taken by electronic means and recorded later in the official file.
- It says "important functions" are directly under the Commission as a whole. Decisions at meetings or noted in files carry the signatures of the ECs and the CEC.
- A 28 July office order on internal work allocation was issued by an additional-secretary-rank IAS officer on deputation to the EC. The affidavit indirectly confirms that ECs Sandhu and Joshi wrote to the Cabinet Secretary about the conduct of Senior Deputy Election Commissioner Maneesh Garg. This followed a controversial 28 July order affecting levels of IT oversight over electoral rolls, passed without the two ECs' knowledge or consensus.
- On 29 July the two ECs wrote separate letters to the Cabinet Secretary about the order and the officer. The ECI says the 28 July order was "never implemented".
- The ECI says it "neither released nor authorised the release of any internal note or file to any news agency".
- Petitioners include the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and other INDIA bloc leaders. The ECI argues that petitions based on media reports should not even be maintainable.
- Political reaction (Congress): Kharge alleged "vote theft" on a massive scale and held the CEC solely responsible, saying he acted on the PM's and Home Minister's instructions. He also said the ECI refused RTI information on the SIR software, citing "trade secrets".
- Rahul Gandhi said the agitation would end "in 30 seconds" if the CEC were removed. He called the CEC "accused no. 4". Traders in Kashmere Gate protested and asked for the 1 November Ramlila Maidan rally to be deferred until after Deepavali. Chamber of Trade and Industry chairman Brijesh Goyal said major wholesale markets within 5 km of Ramlila Maidan could be affected (Chandni Chowk, Sadar Bazar, Khari Baoli, Naya Bazar, Chawri Bazar, Daryaganj, Kashmere Gate).
- K.C. Venugopal defended Kharge's alleged remark against the PM as an ideological attack on the RSS, not a personal one.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Article 324 vests the superintendence, direction and control of elections in the ECI. The Constitution gives the CEC security of tenure by tying removal to the Supreme Court judge model, to insulate the Commission from the executive.
- The 2023 Act now governs appointment, service conditions and business of the Commission. Its rule that differences are settled by majority is what the ECI's affidavit relies on to rebut the "unilateral CEC" charge.
- The static question the news tests is "who checks the Commission, and how?" The two available routes are judicial review (the petition) and parliamentary removal (Art. 324(5)). The ECI's reply is that a court should not restrain a CEC on the strength of a news report.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional bodies; Election Commission (Art. 324); Representation of the People Act (electoral rolls); GS2 — Governance: independence and accountability of statutory/constitutional bodies.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- Article 324 vests the "superintendence, direction and control of elections" in an Election Commission consisting of the CEC and such number of other ECs as the President fixes. It is a constitutional body for elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Mandate:
- The ECI, under Article 324 and the Representation of the People Act, 1950, is empowered to prepare and revise electoral rolls.
- Why it matters:
- Limiting removal grounds to proved misbehaviour or incapacity is meant to prevent arbitrary executive interference. The Supreme Court in Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975) held that free and fair elections are part of the Basic Structure.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) and Form 6
- What it is:
- SIR is a special revision of the electoral rolls ordered by the ECI, carried out through the orders of 24 June 2025, 27 October 2025 and 14 May 2026 mentioned in the article. It uses an additional declaration form (with "mapping" details) submitted along with Form 6.
Additional context
- The Supreme Court earlier declined to pass an interim order suspending CEC Gyanesh Kumar over alleged unilateral decision-making during the SIR, observing that it cannot pass an ex-parte order solely on newspaper reports. It indicated that if the records showed decisions were taken without the required unanimity or majority, those decisions could be reconsidered.
- Earlier in 2026, in a first, opposition members submitted removal notices in both Houses. The Lok Sabha Speaker and Rajya Sabha Chairman rejected them. One report puts the support at 130 Lok Sabha MPs and 63 Rajya Sabha MPs.
- The counter-affidavit was filed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu on the Commission's behalf and sought summary dismissal. It said the affidavit itself was approved by a unanimous decision of all three members. It said the three SIR orders followed unanimous Commission decisions, and that a commissioner's query while a file is processed is not a decision of the Commission.
- No CEC has ever been successfully removed by Parliament in independent India.
Mains dimensions
- Institutional independence vs accountability: The ECI's position is that a CEC enjoys judge-like removal protection, so restraint by a court is contrary to law. The opposition's position is that independence is not immunity. The tension is between Article 324(5) security of tenure and checks such as judicial review and parliamentary scrutiny.
- Collegiality in a multi-member body: The affidavit stresses the multi-level file route and the majority rule under Section 18. The admitted electronic approvals and the 28 July order passed without the two ECs' consensus (later "never implemented") show where process and perception can diverge. The Commission also needs a transparent record of dissent and decision-making.
- Asymmetry of protection: The CEC can be removed only like a Supreme Court judge, but ECs only on the CEC's recommendation. The 255th Law Commission report (2015) recommended extending the same protection to ECs.
- Appointment framework: The 2023 Act's selection committee excludes the CJI, which critics say allows executive dominance. This links to the Supreme Court's interim arrangement in Anoop Baranwal (2023).
- Evidence and justiciability: The ECI argues that media reports are not evidence. The Supreme Court has itself cautioned against ex-parte orders based on newspaper reports. Court-led accountability therefore depends on access to the Commission's actual files.
- Transparency of SIR: The RTI refusal on the SIR software (citing "trade secrets") and the Form 6/declaration form dispute raise questions of procedural clarity. Disputes over whether a declaration form amounts to a change in statutory form reflect delegated-power concerns.
- Politicisation: Allegations of "vote theft" by the opposition and agitation tactics (rally, traders' backlash) show the Commission's legitimacy being contested in the public sphere, not only in court.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The independence of the Election Commission rests on constitutional safeguards, yet the Commission's functioning has repeatedly been questioned. Examine the adequacy of the legal framework governing the appointment, removal and decision-making of the Election Commission in light of recent controversies."
Related topics
- Article 324, Article 124(4), Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968
- Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023) and the 2023 appointment law
- Representation of the People Act, 1950 (Sections on roll preparation/revision) and the Registration of Electors Rules
- Electoral roll revision: SIR vs Special Summary Revision (see the SIR/municipal polls note of the same date)
- Basic Structure and free and fair elections
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 27 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs