Ahead of local body polls, fate of deleted voters in Kolkata remains uncertain
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 27 October 2026
Summary
- Elections to the Kolkata and Howrah Municipal Corporations are due next month. It is unclear whether voters deleted in the SIR, including those whose appeals are stuck in tribunals, can vote. The State Election Commission (SEC), not the ECI, controls municipal rolls, and has discretion over whether to adopt the Assembly rolls.
- Karnataka's final post-SIR roll was to be published on Tuesday (27 Oct). The exercise deleted 1.07 crore names, and additions fell short of deletions in every constituency.
- The Supreme Court (CJI Surya Kant's Bench) orally assured that no deleted voter in the Maharashtra SIR will be prosecuted merely for filing Form 6. It will hear the challenge to Maharashtra deletions on 5 November.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 243ZA (Part IXA, municipalities): superintendence, direction and control of municipal rolls and elections vest in the SEC. Article 243K is the panchayat counterpart (Part IX).
- Section 5, West Bengal State Election Commission Act, 1994: the SEC has discretion on whether to adopt Assembly rolls and powers to add or delete names.
- The ECI is not in charge of municipal elections. Its sphere (Art. 324) is Parliament, State Legislatures, President and Vice-President.
- Form 6: application for inclusion of name in the roll (new electors). Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 covers false declarations.
- Under Section 13C(2) of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, an Assistant ERO is competent to perform the ERO's functions, subject to the ERO's control.
- Section 21(2) of the 1950 Act: rolls are to be revised before every election and annually as ECI orders.
Data and details
- Kolkata and Howrah Municipal Corporation elections are scheduled for next month (Nov 2026).
- Nearly 60 lakh voters were removed in the enumeration phase under the "Absent/Shifted/Duplicate and Dead" category. More than 37 lakh cases are stuck in Appellate Tribunals.
- The final SSR list is due on 4 January. The ECI has begun special drives to re-enrol voters left out of the SIR.
- A memorandum was submitted on Monday to State Election Commissioner Krishna Gupta by Pradesh Congress president Subhankar Sarkar, TMC MP Saugata Roy, and former MPs Samik Lahiri and Jawhar Sircar, among others. It asks the SEC to hold elections only after the re-enrolment drive and SSR, and to include all appellants with pending appeals. The SEC's office said the Commissioner would meet a delegation on Wednesday.
- 5.54 crore voters at the start. The draft roll had 4.54 crore, with about 1 crore struck off. Total deletions are 1.07 crore, and the final roll was to be published on Tuesday on the Chief Electoral Officer's website, after more than three months of the exercise.
- Draft-stage deletions: 16.39 lakh dead, over 7 lakh duplicates, 3.83 lakh under "Others" (a category not seen in many other states and not explained by the CEO's office), and 80.62 lakh shifted or not found at their address.
- The 80.62 lakh "shifted/not found" voters were not necessarily ineligible and had to apply through Form 6. Only 7,87,534 inclusion applications were received, including from new voters.
- Counts of ineligible voters and foreign citizens identified (a stated aim of the SIR) remain unknown. No constituency saw deletions offset by additions.
- The Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant said orally, "Do not worry. Nobody will be prosecuted," on Form 6 filers. The Court will urgently hear the plea on 5 November.
- Senior advocate Arvind Datar (for petitioner Arun Anantagiri) said thousands in Mumbai and Pune were marked absent because of redevelopment projects. He cited 3,500 such projects in Mumbai and 1,500 in Pune.
- He pointed out that deleted voters are made to file Form 6 and present themselves as fresh voters, which could be treated as an offence. He asked for a new form exclusively for SIR-deleted voters.
Static–dynamic linkage
- The Constitution splits electoral machinery in two. The ECI (Art. 324) controls rolls and elections for Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President. State Election Commissions (Art. 243K, 243ZA) control panchayat and municipal elections and their rolls. A roll "cleaned" by the ECI's SIR does not automatically bind a municipal election; the SEC and the state law decide.
- The Kolkata and Howrah polls test this divide. The article treats the question as "whose roll?" and "will deleted or appellant voters vote?"
- The Form 6 point shows how procedural design (re-registration as a "fresh" voter) can collide with penal provisions on false declarations.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Electoral rolls and elections; Constitution (Part IXA, Art. 243ZA, 243K); Representation of the People Act, 1950; local self-government; judiciary and rights (right to vote as statutory/constitutional right).
Background primer
State Election Commission (SEC)
- What it is:
- Articles 243K and 243ZA established an SEC in every state as a constitutional body with powers of superintendence, direction and control of the preparation of electoral rolls for, and the conduct of, all elections to panchayats and municipalities.
- Founded:
- Before 1992 these elections were conducted by state governments. The 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments of 1992 gave local self-governments constitutional sanctity. The 74th Amendment (Nagarpalika Act) came into force on 1 June 1993.
- Mandate:
- Article 243ZA(1) vests municipal roll preparation and elections in the SEC, and 243ZA(2) lets the state legislature make laws on municipal elections. In West Bengal, per the article, Section 5 of the West Bengal State Election Commission Act, 1994 gives the SEC "discretion" to adopt Assembly rolls and powers to add or delete names.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) and Special Summary Revision (SSR)
- What it is:
- SIR is a process to eliminate errors from rolls and prepare an accurate voter list. An Electoral Registration Officer (ERO) is appointed for each Assembly constituency under Section 13B of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 to prepare and revise the roll, assisted by Booth Level Officers (BLOs).
Additional context
- In West Bengal the ECI constituted 19 Appellate Tribunals in compliance with a 10 March 2026 Supreme Court order, on the Calcutta High Court Chief Justice's recommendation. They are headed by former High Court judges.
- During the Bengal Assembly election, the Supreme Court said voters whose appeals were allowed before the cut-off dates must be allowed to vote, but the mere pendency of an appeal gives no right to vote.
- The ECI has told chief electoral officers that previously enrolled voters filing Form 6 after missing from the draft roll are not making a false declaration, and no action under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 should follow. It cited a Delhi High Court order and said this holds if the person is not already enrolled in another constituency and the declaration otherwise complies with law.
Mains dimensions
- Federal electoral architecture: The ECI and SEC operate in separate constitutional spheres. The Kolkata/Howrah question shows the practical effect: a voter excluded from the Assembly roll may be left out of municipal elections unless the SEC decides otherwise, since the SEC has discretion under state law.
- Voting rights vs roll integrity: The Bengal numbers (about 60 lakh deleted, over 37 lakh appeals pending) set large-scale exclusion against the aim of "no ineligible voter". The Karnataka data shows that most deletions (80.62 lakh) were "shifted/not found", not proven ineligibility, and re-inclusion fell far short (7.87 lakh applications).
- Design flaws in procedure: Redevelopment-driven displacement in Mumbai/Pune is a structural cause of "absent" markings that a door-to-door exercise does not capture. The Form 6 "fresh voter" declaration creates a risk of prosecution, which the Supreme Court has orally defused.
- Remedy bottlenecks: The backlog before appellate tribunals reduces the practical value of an appeal. Opposition demands (poll after SSR, include appellants) reflect a design gap between appeal timelines and election timelines.
- Transparency: Unexplained "Others" deletions in Karnataka (3.83 lakh) and the absence of data on ineligible voters/foreigners identified undermine the claimed purpose of the exercise.
- Way forward: Unified or reconciled rolls across ECI and SECs, a dedicated re-inclusion form or process for SIR-deleted voters, faster tribunal disposal, and published category-wise deletion reasons.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Examine the constitutional division of responsibility between the Election Commission of India and State Election Commissions for electoral rolls. How do large-scale deletions during intensive revision of rolls affect local body elections?"
Related topics
- 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments; Part IX and IXA; Article 243K/243ZA/243ZG (bar to court interference in municipal election matters)
- Representation of the People Act, 1950: Sections 13C, 21, 31; Form 6/7/8
- Right to vote: constitutional vs statutory right
- ECI's Article 324 powers and the Commission's independence
- Delimitation and reservation in urban local bodies
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 27 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs