Scrap SIR exercise, urge scientists in letter to ECI, Centre
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 24 October 2026
Summary
- A group of independent scientists and academics wrote an open letter to the ECI and the Centre. They want the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls scrapped and all eligible voters wrongly excluded restored.
- The same day, protests and political action against SIR played out in several places. In Delhi, a march demanded CEC Gyanesh Kumar's resignation. Walkouts took place at the Keralam and Tamil Nadu CEO meetings on the Special Summary Revision (SSR). The Punjab Assembly passed a resolution seeking a probe. Students protested in Mumbai, and the Congress began preparing for the INDIA bloc rally on 1 Nov.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324: ECI's superintendence, direction and control of elections and electoral rolls. Art. 326: universal adult suffrage (18+). Arts. 327/328: Parliament's and State Legislatures' power to legislate on elections.
- Section 21 of the RP Act, 1950 empowers the ECI to prepare and revise rolls, including a special revision at any time with recorded reasons; Section 21(3) is the SIR provision. Section 16 disqualifies non-citizens from registration, and Section 19 sets the ordinary-residence and age conditions.
- The Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 prescribe the detailed procedure. Forms 6/7/8 are used for inclusion, objection and correction/shifting.
- After the Election Laws (Amendment) Act, 2021 amended Section 14 of the RP Act, 1950, four qualifying dates a year are available.
- Art. 324(5): the CEC is removed like an SC judge (Art. 124(4), Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968). ECs are removed only on the CEC's recommendation. The CEC/ECs serve six years or until age 65, whichever is earlier. They are not eligible for reappointment.
- The CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 repealed the 1991 Act. The Selection Committee is the PM, a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM, and the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha.
- Section 163 BNSS replaced Section 144 CrPC. A BNSS Sec. 163 prohibitory order was used against the Delhi protesters.
Data and details
- About 13 crore names removed from electoral rolls nationwide under SIR (article).
- Scientists' letter: signatories from IISc; IIT Delhi; IISER Kolkata; Institute of Mathematical Sciences, Chennai; ICTS Bengaluru. They signed in individual capacities and their views do not represent their institutions.
- Scientists' demands: scrap SIR; immediate restoration of eligible voters wrongly excluded. Their claims: names of the poor, migrant workers and marginalised communities are being deleted arbitrarily; safeguards for restoration are inadequate; the process lacks transparency and accountability. They draw a parallel with the legal presumption of innocence.
- ECI has ordered fresh verification in some States/UTs, including Delhi, after weeks of protests.
- Delhi march: about 500 protesters under the 'People Against SIR' banner. Delhi Police say about 20 were detained and released; protesters say about 50 were rounded up. At least one FIR under Sec. 163 BNSS. The march started near Gol Dak Khana roundabout (Kali Bari Marg/Bhai Vir Singh Marg), gathered at Bangla Sahib Gurdwara, and was stopped by barricades on Ashoka Road about 500 m into the march.
- Participants: Yogendra Yadav, Annie Raja (CPI), Inderjeet Singh (AIKS vice-president); student bodies AISA, AISF, SFI, Krantikari Yuva Sangathan, AIDSO. SKM joined after protesters, particularly women, were manhandled earlier. Inderjeet Singh opposed giving police power through Special Executive Magistrates against protesters.
- Keralam: LDF (CPI(M)'s M.V. Jayarajan, CPI's Sathyan Mokeri) walked out of the CEO D. Sajith Babu's all-party SSR meeting, demanding restoration of 24.08 lakh voters excluded in the draft SIR list. Officials say 24.08 lakh was the draft-list number and it fell to 8.97 lakh in the final SIR list. Parties also want the 2 Nov polling-station rationalisation deadline extended. The CEO will convey the demands to the ECI.
- Tamil Nadu: ECI invited 6 national parties (Congress, BJP, BSP, AAP, CPI(M), NPP) and 7 State parties (TVK, DMK, AIADMK, CPI, NTK, VCK, DMDK). Barring BSP, the others attended. Of the 12 attending parties, 9 walked out after recording views and demanding CEC Gyanesh Kumar's resignation, including the ruling TVK and its allies and the DMK. BJP, AIADMK and NPP did not walk out. TVK's Energy Resources and Law Minister C.T.R. Nirmal Kumar said SSR is unnecessary while SIR errors are uncorrected. The DMK's I. Paranthaman said 74 lakh voters were deleted and criticised the ECI's 100% turnout campaign.
- Punjab: Assembly passed an official resolution seeking an independent probe into alleged electoral irregularities and the ECI's functioning. CM Bhagwant Mann demanded scrapping of SIR and alleged "vote theft" in Bihar, West Bengal, Haryana and Maharashtra. Congress MLAs stormed the Well, demanding Mann's resignation over law and order, drugs and gangsterism, and then walked out.
- Mumbai University (Kalina): organised by Disha Students' Organisation and Bhagat Singh Jan Adhikar Yatra. Demands: complete withdrawal of SIR, arrest of CEC Gyanesh Kumar, fresh elections on previous voter lists, and repeal of the 2023 law on EC appointments. Concerns: possible disenfranchisement of Muslims, Dalits, Adivasis and working-class voters; changes in voter-registration requirements; functioning of the ECINET platform.
- INDIA bloc rally: K.C. Venugopal said the Congress held mobilisation meetings (with Priyanka Gandhi Vadra; UP in-charge Rajendra Pal Gautam and State chief Aradhana Misra; Haryana in-charge Sanjay Dutt and State chief Rao Narender Singh). The 1 Nov rally at Ramlila Maidan culminates a 'Delhi Chalo' march, with at least 10 lakh expected. Venugopal alleged "vote chori" by the CEC at the behest of the PM and Home Minister (an allegation).
- BJP's response: spokesperson Sudhanshu Trivedi accused the Congress and allies of choosing 1 Nov to foment "anarchy", drawing a parallel with the 1984 anti-Sikh violence after Indira Gandhi's assassination on 31 Oct 1984. He called Rahul Gandhi a "failed product" and noted the Congress won only 99 seats in 2024.
Static–dynamic linkage
- The ECI has the "superintendence, direction and control" of the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections under Art. 324. Art. 326 gives every citizen aged 18 or above, not otherwise disqualified by law, the right to be registered as a voter, and Section 16 of the RP Act, 1950 lays down the disqualifications for registration. The Act excludes non-citizens (Sec. 16) and includes citizens aged 18+ who are ordinarily resident in the constituency (Sec. 19).
- SIR is formally conducted under Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950, which gives the Commission discretion to overhaul rolls when ordinary revisions fall short.
- The static tension in the news is between two things: the ECI's plenary power to "purify" the rolls, and the individual's claim to remain on the roll. The right to vote is treated as a constitutional/statutory right under Art. 326 and the RP Acts, not a Fundamental Right under Part III. The Supreme Court (ADR v. ECI, 27 May 2026) held that the right to vote is a constitutional right but not absolute, and that it contemplates verification and periodic revision of the rolls.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI, Art. 324); Representation of the People Act, 1950 (electoral rolls); electoral reforms; GS2 — Governance: transparency and accountability of institutions.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- a permanent constitutional body under Art. 324. It holds superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Founded:
- 25 January 1950 (textbook date; commemorated as National Voters' Day). The Commission briefly became multi-member in 1989, the extra posts were abolished in 1990, and the multi-member structure was restored permanently in 1993.
- Mandate:
- preparing and revising electoral rolls, conducting elections, and supervising the political-party and candidate framework (Model Code of Conduct, symbols).
- Why it matters:
- the Constituent Assembly intended an independent Election Commission, as the Supreme Court noted in 2023.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) vs Special Summary Revision (SSR)
- What it is:
- electoral rolls are revised in an intensive mode (fresh verification through house-to-house enumeration), a summary mode (update of the existing roll, done annually), or a partly intensive, partly summary mode. Separately, Section 21(3) lets the ECI order a special revision at any time, for reasons recorded. SIR is the intensive route taken under that provision.
Removal of the Chief Election Commissioner (relevant because protesters demand CEC Gyanesh Kumar's exit)
- What it is:
- Art. 324(5) says the CEC can be removed only in like manner and on like grounds as a Supreme Court judge, which links to Art. 124(4). The grounds are proved misbehaviour or incapacity.
- Why it matters:
- the high threshold is designed to prevent arbitrary executive interference.
Additional context
- Phases of SIR: Phase I was in Bihar, ahead of the 2025 Assembly elections. Phase II covered 12 States/UTs, and Phase III (announced for 16 States and 3 UTs) is under way. Insights on India reports that the share of entries purged rose from about 8% in Bihar to over 13% in Phase II and over 15% in Phase III.
- ECI's defence (PIB): deletions are made only after BLO verification, under four categories: death, permanent shifting, duplicate entries, or untraceable electors despite repeated visits. It says there are 2–3 visit attempts before an elector is treated as untraceable.
- Supreme Court position (ADR v. ECI, 27 May 2026): the Court upheld the legal and constitutional validity of SIR. It held the exercise justified under Art. 324 read with Section 21(3). Deletion on citizenship grounds does not amount to a declaration of non-citizenship; it only means the ECI was unable to be satisfied for electoral purposes. The ECI was ordered to refer those deleted on citizenship grounds to the competent authority within four weeks.
- SSR now under way: the ECI directed SSR in 14 States and 3 UTs including Kerala, Punjab and Tamil Nadu, with 1 January next year as the qualifying date. The reported schedule is polling-station rationalisation by 2 Nov, draft roll on 12 Nov, claims and objections disposed of by 28 Dec, and final roll on 4 Jan 2027. This explains the 2 Nov deadline the Keralam parties want extended.
- Earlier CEC removal attempt: earlier in 2026, Opposition notices seeking the CEC's removal were submitted in both Houses, reportedly backed by 130 Lok Sabha and 63 Rajya Sabha members. The Lok Sabha Speaker and the Rajya Sabha Chairman both refused to admit them. No CEC has ever been removed by Parliament.
- Protest-site context: a stretch of Jantar Mantar Road was denotified as a designated protest site on 11 October 2026. The Delhi Police designated Ramlila Ground, Burari Ground and CBD Ground (East Delhi) as the new venues. The INDIA bloc rally on 1 Nov is at Ramlila Maidan. A Delhi High Court judgment records that October 2026 protests in Delhi concerned the ECI's functioning and the SIR.
Mains dimensions
- Purity vs inclusion: the ECI's aim is to remove dead, shifted and duplicate entries. The scientists argue that the burden falls on citizens, especially the poor and migrants, who face cumbersome procedures and inadequate safeguards. Their presumption-of-innocence analogy captures the shift of burden. The Keralam gap (24.08 lakh in the draft vs 8.97 lakh in the final list) cuts both ways. It shows claims and objections can restore names, but also how large the initial exclusion was.
- Credibility of a constitutional body: the ECI's authority rests on perceived neutrality. In T.N., nine of 12 attending parties walked out, including the ruling party and the main Opposition, while only BJP, AIADMK and NPP stayed. Protesters in Delhi and Mumbai demand the CEC's resignation or arrest. A formal removal route exists but the threshold is very high and no CEC has been removed. An earlier 2026 removal notice was refused admission by the Presiding Officers.
- Independence and appointments: the Mumbai demand to repeal the 2023 law links to the debate over the Selection Committee. In March 2023 the Supreme Court said the executive alone should not appoint the CEC/ECs and mandated a panel of the PM, the Leader of Opposition and the CJI until Parliament legislated. The 2023 Act's panel has a Cabinet Minister in place of the CJI.
- Federal and political dimension: State-level actors (Punjab Assembly resolution, Keralam and T.N. party leaders) can only pass resolutions or relay demands to the ECI through the CEO. The ECI's Art. 324 powers are not subject to State control. Opposition parties are shifting the contest to the streets (1 Nov rally) and the ruling side frames it as a threat to order. Both sides' claims ("vote chori" and "anarchy") are allegations that the article does not substantiate.
- Right to protest vs public order: Sec. 163 BNSS orders and the FIR, the Jantar Mantar denotification, detentions at Ashoka Road, and Inderjeet Singh's objection to SEM powers over protesters all feed one debate.
- Expert civil society: scientists intervening as individuals (not on behalf of institutions) shows a widening of the dissent beyond political parties. One reform suggestion (Insights on India) is an independent statistical audit of SIR deletion patterns by academic bodies.
- Way forward: transparent publication of deletion lists and reasons; time-bound claims/objections with assistance for migrants; third-party audit; accepting widely held documents (the SC has already pushed this); and a credible, consultative approach to roll revision to rebuild trust.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has intensified the debate between the 'purity' and the 'inclusiveness' of the voter list. Examine the constitutional and legal basis of the exercise and discuss how the ECI can protect both its credibility and the franchise of vulnerable citizens."
Related topics
- Art. 324 and the plenary-power doctrine (Mohinder Singh Gill, 1977); Arts. 326–329
- RP Act, 1950 (rolls) vs RP Act, 1951 (conduct of elections); Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
- Appointment and removal of CEC/ECs; Anoop Baranwal (2023)
- Right to peaceful assembly (Art. 19(1)(b)) and Sec. 163 BNSS
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 24 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs