BrainParrot

Govt. going back on assurances made to Ladakh: Wangchuk

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 23 October 2026

Summary

  • At a Delhi press conference on Thursday, activist Sonam Wangchuk accused the Union Home Ministry of backtracking on earlier assurances of political autonomy and constitutional safeguards for the UT of Ladakh.
  • He claimed the Centre never denied Statehood in earlier talks and had said it would come "eventually".
  • He said protection under Article 371 was agreed at a 22 May meeting, but the Centre is now offering only a council-type body. He says Ladakh will not settle for less than a UT with a legislature.
  • After the 15 October meeting in Leh, the Leh Apex Body (LAB) and Kargil Democratic Alliance (KDA) were told the next meeting would be in Delhi on Thursday. It did not take place.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: federalism, UT governance, Sixth Schedule / Article 371

Key facts for Prelims

  • Sixth Schedule: autonomous district/regional councils under Art. 244, currently in Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram. Ladakh is not covered.
  • Articles 371–371J sit in Part XXI (Temporary, Transitional and Special Provisions) of the Constitution.
  • Art. 371A (Nagaland) and 371G (Mizoram) bar Parliamentary laws on customary law and land ownership unless the State Assembly agrees. Art. 371J covers Hyderabad-Karnataka (98th Amendment, 2012).
  • Article 240 deals with the President's power to make regulations for certain Union Territories.
  • Ladakh became a UT on 31 October 2019 after reorganisation of the former State of J&K. The J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019 carved it out as a UT without a legislative assembly.
  • Existing local bodies: the Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Councils (LAHDC Leh and Kargil). The LAHDC Act, 1997 was amended to reserve one-third of seats for women.
  • The MHA's High-Powered Committee on Ladakh is the formal dialogue forum with LAB and KDA.

Data and details

  • 22 May: meeting where, per Wangchuk, protection under Article 371 was agreed.
  • 15 October: last meeting, held in Leh. LAB and KDA were told the next meeting would be in Delhi on Thursday, but it did not happen.
  • Earlier this month: Ladakh Chief Secretary Ashish Kundra said it was "categorically conveyed" to LAB and KDA that neither Statehood nor a UT with legislature is on the agenda. Wangchuk's claim is that the Centre had said Statehood would come "eventually".
  • Wangchuk's security argument: China is claiming Ladakh while the government alienates Ladakhis. He says the Ministry, for its own reasons, is compromising national security in sensitive border areas.
  • Offer vs demand: a council-type body (Centre) versus a UT with legislature, the minimum Wangchuk says he will accept.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Ladakh became a UT in 2019 without a legislature, so it has no elected legislature or government of its own. Executive power sits with the Lieutenant Governor and the bureaucracy.
  • The local demand is for a constitutionally entrenched layer of self-rule. The two entrenched models in the Constitution are:
    • the Sixth Schedule, which creates autonomous councils in tribal areas; and
    • the Article 371 series, which gives region-specific safeguards.
  • Entrenchment is the key issue. A new Article 371-type provision would need a constitutional amendment under Article 368, which is how Articles 371A–371J were inserted.
  • Safeguards by ordinary regulation or executive arrangement can be altered by the Centre. That gap is the core of the trust deficit in this story.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Federal structure, Union Territories, special provisions for regions (Art. 371 series), Fifth/Sixth Schedule tribal-area governance; GS3 – Security: border-area management

Background primer

Leh Apex Body (LAB) and Kargil Democratic Alliance (KDA)

What it is:
the two civil-society/political coalitions speaking for Leh and Kargil. They jointly negotiate with the MHA. They jointly organised protests in Leh and Kargil to protect local land and cultural rights.

Sixth Schedule (Article 244)

What it is:
a Schedule under Article 244 allowing autonomous administrative divisions within a state, with certain legislative, judicial and administrative autonomy.
Why it matters:
protect tribal identity, local control over land and resources, and employment.

Article 371 series (Part XXI – Temporary, Transitional and Special Provisions)

What it is:
special provisions for particular states or regions. They are meant for regions that are backward, tribal, have internal-security challenges or distinct identities. The provisions address socio-economic backwardness, internal security challenges, difficult geography and tribal populations with distinct identities.

Additional context

  • The Centre's October 2026 draft. In October 2026 the MHA shared a 32-page draft governance proposal with Ladakh's representatives, and the administration notified Sankoo as the eighth district. LAB and KDA rejected the 15 October draft, saying it differed from the understanding reached in May 2026.
  • Their objections.
    • The proposed body would make regulations on specified subjects rather than hold broad legislative authority.
    • The draft provides for the Lieutenant Governor's assent to regulations.
    • The representatives want more control over transfers and postings of officials.
  • Proposed Article 371(K). The MHA has proposed a new provision, Article 371(K) (or a Chapter K under Part XXI), for a directly elected governing body with legislative powers for the UT. It would cover land, culture, environment and natural resources. It aims to address political alienation without granting statehood or Sixth Schedule status.
  • Statehood as a "long-term aspiration". The MHA's released minutes of its meetings with Ladakhi groups reportedly acknowledge Statehood as the "long-term aspiration" of Ladakhis, though not part of the immediate package because of financial constraints. This relates to Wangchuk's claim that Statehood was promised "eventually".
  • Why Article 240 regulations fall short of the Sixth Schedule. Regulations under Article 240 can be revoked or amended unilaterally by the Centre, whereas the Sixth Schedule is constitutionally protected. The President also promulgated the LAHDC (Amendment) Regulation, 2026, extending Hill Councils to all eight districts of Ladakh.
  • Earlier concessions (Sept 2025 MHA release). ST reservation in Ladakh was raised from 45% to 84%, one-third women's reservation was provided in the councils, Bhoti and Purgi were declared official languages, and recruitment to 1,800 posts began.

Mains dimensions

  • Democratic deficit. A UT without a legislature means rule by the Lieutenant Governor and bureaucrats. Even the proposed body would have the LG's assent over its regulations, and no control over bureaucrats' postings. The draft body would make regulations on specified subjects, with the LG's assent.
  • Trust deficit and contradictory narratives.
  • Wangchuk says Statehood was never ruled out and that Article 371 was agreed on 22 May.
  • Chief Secretary Kundra says Statehood and a UT with legislature are not on the agenda.
  • The meeting Ladakhis were promised did not happen.
  • Negotiation credibility depends on written, minuted commitments.
  • Entrenchment vs executive discretion. Regulations under Article 240 can be changed by the Centre, while Sixth Schedule or Article 371 protections cannot be unilaterally altered. This is why the form of the safeguard matters as much as its content.
  • Security vs autonomy.
  • Wangchuk argues that alienation of locals weakens border security. This is the "hearts and minds" argument for tribal border regions.
  • The Centre's counter-concern is that Ladakh is a sensitive LAC and Siachen frontier. Ladakh borders China along the LAC and has a Pakistan-facing western frontier and the Siachen sector.
  • Federal and identity politics. There is a concern that full Statehood might sharpen identity politics between Buddhist-majority Leh and Muslim-majority Kargil, causing governance deadlocks. The Centre also cites financial viability.
  • Way forward. A time-bound constitutional settlement on land, employment, culture, natural resources and financial authority, negotiated with LAB, KDA and elected local institutions. Other measures include a permanent dialogue forum, published minutes and phased implementation.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Ladakh's demand for Sixth Schedule status or an Article 371-type arrangement raises the question of how far asymmetric federalism can reconcile local autonomy with national security concerns in border regions. Discuss."

Related topics

  • Sixth Schedule vs Fifth Schedule; Autonomous District Councils; Article 244 and 275(1)
  • Articles 3 and 4 (formation of states and UTs); Article 239A; J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019; Article 370 abrogation
  • Asymmetric federalism and Articles 371A–371J; Governor's "special responsibility"
  • Border Area Development Programme (BADP); Ladakh's strategic importance (LAC, Siachen)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 23 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs