Cabinet Secretariat copied acknowledgement sent to letters by two ECs to CEC
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 23 October 2026
Summary
- An RTI reply shows that two Election Commissioners, S.S. Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, wrote to Cabinet Secretary T.V. Somanathan on July 29 about the functioning of Senior Deputy Election Commissioner Maneesh Garg.
- The Cabinet Secretariat's file notings record that it treated the letters as individual communications, not as a formal communication from the Commission as a whole. It sent acknowledgements to both ECs with a copy to CEC Gyanesh Kumar "for information".
- The RTI replies do not show whether the CEC responded to or acknowledged the information.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324: ECI's powers of superintendence, direction and control. Article 324(5): CEC removable like a Supreme Court judge (linked to Article 124(4)); other ECs removable only on the CEC's recommendation.
- The CEC and Other ECs Act, 2023 replaced the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of Election Commissioners and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991.
- Selection Committee under the 2023 Act: PM (Chair), Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha, and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM.
- Tenure is six years or until 65. Under Section 10 of the 2023 Act, the salary, allowances and service conditions of the CEC and ECs are the same as those of the Cabinet Secretary (the 1991 Act had pegged them to a Supreme Court judge).
- Section 11 of the Act allows the CEC or an EC to resign by writing to the President, and says removal can happen only as per the provisos to Article 324(5).
- The ECs' letter was addressed to the Cabinet Secretary (head of the civil services). A copy was marked to the Secretary, Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT), because Mr. Garg is an All-India Service officer.
Data and details
- ECs S.S. Sandhu and Vivek Joshi wrote to the Cabinet Secretary on July 29 about the work of Senior Deputy Election Commissioner Maneesh Garg.
- Days later, the Cabinet Secretariat sent acknowledgements to both, with a copy to CEC Gyanesh Kumar (via his Principal Private Secretary) for "information". This was revealed through an RTI plea filed by Commodore Lokesh Batra (retd).
- A file noting of August 3 records the ECs' complaint. After taking charge as link officer of the Deputy Election Commissioner (Administration), Mr. Garg issued an order allocating work among officers equivalent and senior to him. This was done without discussing the revised allocation with the Commission or the officers concerned.
- The ECs said this happened despite repeated oral and written instructions to all officers not to take such steps without the Commission's prior discussion or approval.
- The August 3 note says the Cabinet Secretariat "may request the CEC for his opinion on the issue".
- The next day, August 4, the file notes that the Commission is a constitutional body, insulated from executive interference by design. It says the letters came from ECs individually, with no official communication from the Commission as a whole, so any action at this stage "may be inappropriate" and could be read as interference.
- The Cabinet Secretariat described the letters as individual-capacity communications needing serious attention. It said they cannot be taken as formal communications from the ECI as a whole.
- Notable absences: it is not clear from the RTI replies whether Mr. Gyanesh Kumar responded to or acknowledged the information from the Cabinet Secretariat.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Article 324 creates the Election Commission as a constitutional body with the CEC and such other ECs as the President fixes. Its independence is protected by security of tenure, service conditions and a special removal procedure for the CEC.
- The episode is a live test of the principle that a constitutional body's internal disagreements are for the Commission itself to resolve. The Cabinet Secretariat's reasoning was that action on a letter from only some members could amount to "interference".
- It also shows the structural tension in the Commission: the CEC is formally primus inter pares, yet ECs have equal voice in decisions. Their administrative control over the Commission's secretariat staff is not clearly defined.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission, Article 324); independence and accountability; executive–constitutional body relations; collegiality within the Commission.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- the constitutional authority responsible for conducting elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of the President and Vice-President. It manages the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of these elections.
- Founded:
- established under Article 324 (Part XV). It briefly became multi-member in 1989, the additional posts were abolished in 1990, and the multi-member structure was restored permanently in 1993. The Supreme Court upheld this structure in T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995).
- Mandate:
- superintendence, direction and control of elections, including preparation of electoral rolls. CECs and ECs also perform quasi-judicial functions.
- Why it matters:
- The Supreme Court (2023) noted that the Constituent Assembly intended an independent Election Commission whose appointment is regulated by law and not decided by the Executive.
Removal and parity between CEC and ECs
Additional context
- In a counter-affidavit to the Supreme Court on petitions challenging the CEC's functioning, the Election Commission said the SIR orders were approved unanimously by all three members of the Commission. It said any suggestion, observation or query raised by a commissioner while a file is being processed does not constitute a decision of the Commission. The source article does not link the ECs' letters to these petitions.
- In a press note after its meeting of 26 September 2026, the ECI said the letter to the Cabinet Secretary was not about any policy matter of the Commission. It said the letter concerned the working of an officer on deputation to the ECI. It added that the work-redistribution orders issued by that officer were not actually implemented after the two Commissioners' orders.
- The Goswami Committee (1990) and the ECI itself have recommended an independent secretariat for the ECI, along the lines of the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha secretariats and the Supreme Court and High Court registries. The Supreme Court (2023) also noted the importance of an independent secretariat.
Mains dimensions
- Insulation vs oversight: the Cabinet Secretariat's stand was to avoid acting without a Commission-level communication, to prevent "interference". This protects ECI independence in form. But the ECs' letters went to the executive first, which shows internal channels may have been inadequate.
- Internal collegiality: the Commission is a multi-member body, but the CEC's special removal protection and ECs' vulnerability (removal only on the CEC's recommendation) create asymmetry. The episode shows two ECs seeking an outside forum on an internal personnel matter.
- Administrative autonomy: the dispute is about work allocation among officials of the Commission, including a senior All-India Service officer. This ties to the long-pending demand for an independent ECI secretariat, and to how deputed officers' loyalties are split between the ECI and parent cadres.
- Transparency: the RTI route exposed the exchange. It is a useful illustration of RTI as a tool of institutional accountability even for constitutional bodies.
- Selection and independence: the 2023 Act's executive-heavy Selection Committee (without the CJI) is criticised. Intra-Commission disagreements will increase scrutiny of how ECs are chosen and protected.
- Way forward: a written protocol for Commission business (decisions, notings, communication with the executive), a dedicated secretariat cadre, and parity in removal protection for ECs.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The independence of the Election Commission depends as much on its internal functioning as on its insulation from the executive. Discuss in the light of the constitutional and statutory framework governing the CEC and the Election Commissioners."
Related topics
- Article 324 and the 2023 Act (appointment, tenure, removal); Article 124(4) and the removal of Supreme Court judges
- Independent secretariat for the ECI and the Goswami Committee on electoral reforms
- Role of the Cabinet Secretary and DoPT with All-India Services
- RTI Act and constitutional bodies; Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 23 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs