BrainParrot

The ECI’s unfinished lessons

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 21 October 2026

Summary

  • The editorial argues that the ECI's own history shows how inclusion was won. In the first roll, about 28 lakh women were missing because they were listed through male relatives. The first CEC, Sukumar Sen, worked to enrol them in their own right. It says today's mass roll revision, suspicious deletions and polling-record access test the same principle.
  • It lists concerns: Bihar and West Bengal deletions, the Aland (Karnataka) Form 7 episode, Maharashtra 2024 turnout figures, the Rule 93 amendment on records, and the changed selection panel for Election Commissioners.
  • A separate news report says a civic-tech audit by "Charchagram" found ECINET features that let State-wise access to enumeration form details, and SNO access, be switched off centrally. The Congress used the report to attack the ECI.
  • Note the author's affiliation (Congress minority department functionary) when using the editorial's claims as arguments.

UPSC relevance: GS2 – Polity: Election Commission, electoral integrity, independence of constitutional bodies

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art. 324(1): ECI's superintendence of rolls and elections. Art. 324(2): composition and appointment. Art. 324(5): conditions of service of CEC cannot be varied to disadvantage after appointment.
  • Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023): interim selection committee of PM, LoP and CJI.
  • CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023: Selection Committee has PM, a Union Cabinet Minister and LoP; CJI excluded.
  • Rule 93, Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961: inspection of election papers; amended December 2024.
  • Form 7: request for deletion of a name from the roll.
  • ECINET: ECI's unified portal for officials. SNO: State Nodal Officer. ERO/AERO: Electoral Registration Officer/Assistant ERO.
  • CEC removal: like an SC judge (Art. 324(5) proviso).

Data and details

  • Historical: about 28 lakh women were omitted from the first roll for being identified through male relatives. By the 1957 elections, about 85% of those affected were registered under their own names.
  • Bihar (draft roll, August 2025): around 65 lakh names missing. Reasons cited: deaths, migration, duplicates. The Supreme Court directed the ECI to publish the list of excluded voters with reasons.
  • West Bengal: more than 27 lakh names deleted during adjudication, producing around 22 lakh appeals. Tribunal judges reported technical issues with the appeals portal, including notices, hearings and restoring names.
  • Aland (Karnataka): 6,018 online Form 7 applications for deletion. The ECI rejected 5,994 as incorrect and accepted 24 after verification. An inquiry and an FIR followed.
  • Maharashtra 2024 Assembly election: reported turnout rose from 58.22% at 5 p.m. to a final 66.05%. The ECI said the early figure was provisional.
  • Rule 93 was amended in December 2024, after the Punjab and Haryana High Court's order on records in a case on the Haryana Assembly election. The editorial questions whether the aim was privacy or limiting scrutiny.
  • Selection panel: the government now controls two of the three seats on the committee (PM plus a Union Cabinet Minister the PM nominates).
  • ECINET audit (Charchagram; author Saurav Rajput, data scientist, IIT Delhi and IIM Calcutta alumnus):
  • The portal was launched in January 2026. It is unclear since when the feature has existed. Rajput says he could locate it since 28 September.
  • An SNO management area has a disable button, with a pop-up saying a disabled SNO can no longer access the application.
  • The code carries a message that viewing enumeration form details is "not enabled for selected State". Viewing is therefore switched on or off State by State.
  • The platform can bar EROs and AEROs only in West Bengal from reviewing enumeration forms and viewing the notice-and-hearing dashboard.
  • Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had objected to the centralisation of ECINET and the roll database.
  • Congress alleged ECINET centralises manipulation. Jairam Ramesh said EROs have statutory authority over rolls but ECINET and the ECI's IT division have overruled it. Both are political claims.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Art. 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of elections and rolls in the ECI. Independence rests on appointment, tenure, removal and finances.
  • Appointment is "subject to any law made by Parliament", and the law's design (who sits on the selection panel) is where executive influence enters.
  • Procedural transparency (appeals, reasons for deletion, access to records) is what turns constitutional independence into public trust.
  • Statutory authority over the rolls lies with the EROs. If a central IT platform can switch off State or officer access, the question is whether decentralised statutory authority is being overridden by system design. This is the core of Jairam Ramesh's allegation, which is a political claim.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Election Commission (Art. 324), appointment and independence of CEC/ECs, electoral rolls (RPA 1950), Conduct of Elections Rules 1961, transparency in elections; GS2 – Governance: e-governance and data centralisation.

Background primer

Election Commission of India (ECI)

What it is:
A constitutional body under Art. 324(1), with superintendence, direction and control of the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of all elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
Mandate:
Roll revision, conduct of polls, enforcement of the Model Code, and advice to the President or Governor on disqualification of legislators under Arts. 103 and 192.
Why it matters:
A neutral umpire, insulated from the executive.

Selection of Election Commissioners

Additional context

  • On 23 September 2026 a two-judge Supreme Court bench (Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma) delivered a split verdict on whether a larger bench was needed. The petitions challenging the 2023 Appointment Act were referred to the CJI to constitute a five-judge Constitution Bench.
  • Rule 93(2)(a) of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961 once allowed public inspection of "all papers relating to elections". The amendment limits it to papers specified in the rules, excluding electronic records such as CCTV and webcasting footage. It followed a Punjab and Haryana High Court directive to share election documents including CCTV footage from the Haryana Assembly elections.
  • The ECI cited voter privacy and misuse concerns, while RTI activists and opposition parties said it compromises transparency. Candidates keep access to all election records, and restricted records can still be sought through courts.

Mains dimensions

  • Inclusion as the founding principle: Sukumar Sen's enrolment of women in their own right shows the ECI's strongest tradition: correcting exclusion proactively. Applying the principle to SIR means workable ways for wrongly excluded voters to find reasons and challenge them.
  • Remedy speed: Bihar's exclusion list and reasons, and West Bengal's 22 lakh appeals and portal problems, show that deletions without prompt correction cost votes. Late remedy equals lost vote.
  • Traceability of deletion requests: Aland shows safeguards can reject bad Form 7s. Yet a concentrated pattern of 6,018 applications needs the identity and document trail of applicants. Every request should leave a verifiable record of applicant, evidence and decision.
  • Data transparency: A change from 58.22% to 66.05% is not evidence of wrongdoing by itself, but a substantial change demands a clear explanation. The Rule 93 amendment, coming right after a High Court order, weakens public scrutiny of CCTV and webcast material. The ECI cited privacy and misuse. Critics see an effort to limit scrutiny.
  • Institutional independence: Baranwal's three-member panel (PM, LoP, CJI) was replaced by one where the executive has two of three seats. The 2023 Act is before a Constitution Bench.
  • Centralised technology vs statutory authority: The ECINET findings, if accurate, raise the question of whether technical controls can override the statutory powers of EROs. Opposition claims need verification, and the ECI has not yet answered in these articles.
  • Counterpoint: The author concedes the ECI need not accept every party allegation. A rolls-cleaning exercise is necessary. The ECI's case is accuracy, one of purging duplicates, dead and shifted voters. The editorial is by an opposition party functionary, so claims should be read alongside the ECI's response.
  • Way forward: Publish reasons for each deletion. Give electors a tracking tool. Ensure appeal portals work. Release disaggregated turnout data with explanations. Publish access-control and audit logs for ECINET. Restore a broad-based selection process, subject to the pending Constitution Bench.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The credibility of the Election Commission depends as much on procedural transparency as on constitutional independence. Discuss with reference to recent controversies on electoral rolls, polling data and the appointment of Election Commissioners."

Related topics

  • Art. 324–329; Representation of the People Acts 1950 and 1951
  • Anoop Baranwal (2023); the 2023 Appointment Act; Dinesh Goswami Committee, Law Commission 255th Report
  • Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961 (Rules 93 and 94); Form 17C
  • E-governance and data protection in election management

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 21 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs