Revamp functioning of Parliament
Source: The Hindu, 19 October 2026
Summary
- The authors argue that the delimitation debate is framed as "democratic arithmetic" (more MPs for fewer citizens). Representation also depends on whether MPs get floor time.
- They say the proposed Lok Sabha expansion ignores Parliament's capacity: sitting hours, Question Hour and Zero Hour. Without reform, more MPs will further dilute each MP's chance to speak.
- They propose a statutory floor on sitting days (extending Article 85(1) to include a minimum working days clause) and protected, fixed time for Zero Hour and Question Hour.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 85(1): the President summons each House. Six months must not intervene between the last sitting of one session and the first sitting of the next.
- Lok Sabha: a maximum of 20 starred and 230 unstarred questions per sitting day. An MP can submit up to 5 questions a day.
- Zero Hour is not in the rules of procedure. Notice is given before 10 am to the Speaker.
- Article 81 (composition of the House of the People) and Article 82 (readjustment after each census) govern Lok Sabha size and delimitation. Article 80 caps the Rajya Sabha at 250.
- The 131st Amendment Bill proposed amending Articles 81, 82 and 334A. As a Constitution amendment it needed a special majority under Article 368: a majority of the House's total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting.
- NCRWC recommended 120 (Lok Sabha) and 100 (Rajya Sabha) minimum working days a year.
- Article 75: the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha.
Data and details
- Proposed Lok Sabha strength: 550 to 850, per the editorial.
- Under the ECI's 2024 Atlas: 97.98 crore voters across 543 constituencies, an average of roughly 18 lakh voters per constituency.
- Disparity: Malkajgiri (Telangana) has 37.8 lakh voters while Lakshadweep has 57,953.
- Question Hour in the 17th Lok Sabha ran for only 60% of its scheduled time.
- 2026 Monsoon Session: Question Hour ran for only 1% of its scheduled time, a total of nine minutes across the whole session.
- Daily limits: 20 starred and 230 unstarred questions. Each MP can submit up to five daily, but only a tiny fraction is selected in the ballot.
- NCRWC's recommended minimum is 120 sitting days a year for the Lok Sabha.
- Instruments at risk: Zero Hour (no advance notice needed; used for urgent issues such as regional crop failures and disaster relief) and Private Member's Business (for non-Cabinet MPs to bring their own legislation).
Static–dynamic linkage
Parliament's core functions are lawmaking, holding the executive accountable and representing citizens. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha (Article 75), which is why Question Hour and Zero Hour matter as accountability tools. Parliament cannot convene itself. The President, on the advice of the Council of Ministers, summons it, and so indirectly decides when it can exercise oversight. Seat numbers (Articles 81 and 82) and sitting time (Article 85) are distinct constitutional questions. The editorial argues reform has addressed the first but not the second.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Parliament and state legislatures — structure, functioning, conduct of business, powers and privileges; issues arising from these; (links to GS2 – Representation of People's Act, delimitation).
Background primer
Question Hour
- What it is:
- the hour in which MPs ask ministers questions and hold them accountable for the functioning of their ministries.
- Why it matters:
- it is the main routine tool of parliamentary accountability, tied to the Council of Ministers' collective responsibility to the Lok Sabha under Article 75.
Zero Hour
- What it is:
- an Indian parliamentary innovation not mentioned in the rules of procedure. It allows matters to be raised without prior notice immediately after Question Hour.
Article 85 and parliamentary sittings
- What it is:
- Article 85 deals with summoning, prorogation and dissolution. Parliament must be convened at least once every six months.
- Why it matters:
- the summoning provision is based on a Government of India Act, 1935 provision.
National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (NCRWC)
Additional context
- Status of the Bills: PRS records the Delimitation Bill, 2026 as introduced in Lok Sabha on 16 April 2026 and infructuous on 17 April 2026. Vision IAS reports the Constitution (131st Amendment) Bill failed to secure the required two-thirds majority on 17 April 2026, getting 298 votes against 352 required. The government then withdrew the Delimitation Bill and the Union Territories Laws (Amendment) Bill. The editorial treats the proposal as the live frame for the debate.
- What the Bill proposed: it targeted Articles 81, 82 and 334A. It would raise the maximum Lok Sabha strength from 550 to 850, with up to 815 from states and 35 from Union Territories.
- Rajya Sabha impact: Article 80 caps the Rajya Sabha at 250 members and the Bill left this unchanged. That would change the Lok Sabha–Rajya Sabha seat ratio from 2.2:1 to 3.3:1, on PRS's assumption of 815 Lok Sabha seats.
- Sitting days trend: Lok Sabha met an average of a little over 120 days a year in the first two decades, falling to roughly 70 days in the last decade, per PRS. The 17th Lok Sabha had the lowest full-term sittings (274 days) in India's history, per Insights.
- In 2008 a Rajya Sabha MP introduced a private member bill to amend the Constitution for a minimum of 120 working days, and PRS records that the government opposed the concept of a minimum number of working days.
Mains dimensions
- Two layers of representation: voter access to the MP (constituency size) and the MP's voice in the House (floor time). The editorial argues delimitation addresses only the first. Constituency size varies hugely (37.8 lakh in Malkajgiri vs. 57,953 in Lakshadweep), so the case for restructuring is real.
- Time as the binding constraint: with 850 MPs and unchanged hours, each member's chance to speak or to get an oral answer shrinks. Of the 20 daily starred questions, only about 5–6 are typically reached (see 2a).
- Erosion of accountability tools: Question Hour ran for only 1% of scheduled time in the 2026 Monsoon Session (nine minutes in total) and 60% in the 17th Lok Sabha. Adding members to such a House will not improve executive accountability.
- Weak spots for urgent and private voice: Zero Hour (disaster relief, crop failures) and Private Member's Business lose their value if not protected.
- Reform proposals: a statutory minimum sitting days clause, building on Article 85(1) and the NCRWC's 120 days; protected, fixed-time slots for Zero Hour and Question Hour that the Speaker's directions cannot alter.
- Counter-considerations: the government has previously opposed a mandated minimum (see 2b). Fixed hours also raise questions of disruption, scheduling and the Speaker's discretionary authority. The editorial says only that time protection is needed.
- Federal and political angle: the delimitation debate also involves seat shares among states and the Lok Sabha–Rajya Sabha balance (see 2b).
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Increasing the strength of the Lok Sabha without strengthening its functioning may not improve representation. Critically examine, and suggest reforms to ensure that MPs' voices are heard on the floor of the House."
Related topics
- Articles 80, 81, 82, 85, 75; delimitation and the 1971-census freeze
- Parliamentary devices: Question Hour, Zero Hour, calling attention, half-an-hour discussion, Private Member's Business
- Declining sitting days and disruptions; committee system; role of the Speaker
- Women's reservation (106th Amendment, Article 334A)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 19 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs