BrainParrot

SC notice to journalist, Sena (UBT) leader for remarks against CJI

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 17 October 2026

Summary

  • On Friday (16 Oct 2026) a Bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi issued notice on a contempt petition by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA). It is directed against senior journalist Nikhil Wagle and Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut (Shiv Sena–UBT) for public remarks against the CJI. The case will be heard soon.
  • The SCBA, through senior advocate Pradeep Rai, acted with the Attorney-General's consent. The CJI observed orally that people who approach the Court for relief later "condemn, criticise" it. The Solicitor General said such remarks are made deliberately to pressure the judges.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Judiciary, contempt of court, Art 19(1)(a) vs Art 129

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art 129 (SC) and Art 215 (HC): courts of record; power to punish for own contempt. Art 142(2) also enables the SC to investigate and punish for its contempt.
  • Art 19(2): "contempt of court" is a ground for reasonable restriction on free speech.
  • Contempt of Courts Act, 1971: Section 2(a)–(c) definitions; Section 14 (contempt in the court's presence); Section 15 (cognizance of criminal contempt in other cases, with AG consent); Section 17 (notice, procedure); Section 18 (Bench of not less than two judges); Section 13 (truth as a defence, from the 2006 amendment).
  • "Contempt of court" is not defined by the Constitution. Entry 77 of List I and Entry 14 of List III give legislative competence.
  • The Attorney General of India is appointed under Art 76. The AG for India (in the article: R. Venkataramani) and the Solicitor General (Tushar Mehta) are the Union's law officers.

Data and details

  • Petitioner: Supreme Court Bar Association, through senior advocate Pradeep Rai. Respondents: Nikhil Wagle (senior journalist) and Sanjay Raut (Shiv Sena–UBT Rajya Sabha MP).
  • AG R. Venkataramani consented to initiation of proceedings. Bench: CJI Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi. Notice issued; listing "soon" (no date given).
  • Pradeep Rai's submission: the SCBA first thought to ignore the remarks, but "others get instigated" and act inappropriately.
  • SG Tushar Mehta: the comments are made "deliberately" and are believed to create pressure on the judges.
  • CJI's oral observation: each of them had earlier approached the Court and later "condemn and criticise" it.

Static–dynamic linkage

The SC and High Courts are "courts of record" with a constitutional power to punish for contempt of themselves (Art 129 and Art 215). The Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 defines and regulates the offence and the procedure. Criminal contempt includes "scandalising" the court, and it is the part of the law that most directly meets freedom of speech. The news is an instance of the non-suo-motu route: a private body, with the AG's written consent, moves the Court.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Judiciary (powers, contempt); Fundamental Rights (Art 19(1)(a) and its limit in Art 19(2) — "contempt of court"); Separation of powers; role of the Attorney General (Art 76).

Background primer

Contempt of Courts Act, 1971

What it is:
The statute that categorises contempt into civil and criminal contempt and defines both in Section 2.
Founded:
It replaced the 1952 Act and gave effect to the Sanyal Committee (1963) recommendations.
Members:
The SC or HC may act suo motu or on a motion by the Advocate-General, or by any other person with the Advocate-General's written consent. For the SC, Section 15 itself defines "Advocate-General" as the Attorney General or Solicitor General (also reflected in Rule 3 of the Rules to Regulate Proceedings for Contempt of the Supreme Court, 1975). Every criminal-contempt case under Section 15 must be heard by a Bench of at least two judges.
Mandate:
Civil contempt means wilful disobedience of a court order or breach of an undertaking. Criminal contempt means publishing or doing anything that scandalises or lowers the authority of a court, prejudices or interferes with judicial proceedings, or obstructs the administration of justice. The punishment is up to six months' simple imprisonment, a fine up to Rs 2,000, or both.
Why it matters:
Protect public confidence in the administration of justice. The consent-based procedure exists to prevent frivolous petitions from wasting court time.

Art 129 / Art 215 (constitutional contempt power)

What it is:
The SC (Art 129) and every High Court (Art 215) are courts of record with the power to punish for contempt of themselves.

Additional context

  • Role of the AG's consent: The consent is meant as a safeguard against frivolous petitions. If the AG refuses, the matter all but ends, although the complainant can bring it to the court's notice and ask it to act suo motu. The AG has consented here, so the SCBA route is open.
  • Precedent: Prashant Bhushan (2020): The SC held Bhushan guilty of scandalising the court for two tweets on a suo motu basis and imposed a fine of Re 1. Earlier, in Shiv Shankar (1988), the Court held that criticism that does not impair the administration of justice cannot be punished.
  • Reform debate: The Act was amended in 2006 to allow truth as a defence under Section 13. Britain abolished scandalising the judiciary as a form of contempt in 2013. In 2018 the Law Ministry asked the Law Commission to examine restricting contempt to wilful disobedience of court orders. The Commission (Report No. 274, limited to Section 2) concluded that no amendment was needed. It noted that India still has many criminal contempt cases, that the UK offence survives under other laws, and that the superior courts' constitutional contempt power would remain even if the statutory offence were deleted. "Scandalising the court" is not defined in the statute.

Mains dimensions

  • Free speech vs institutional dignity: Art 19(1)(a) is limited by Art 19(2) but only by "reasonable" restrictions. Criticism that is fair and in good faith is protected, while attacks that undermine public confidence can be contempt. The vagueness of "scandalising" makes outcomes judge-dependent.
  • Judge in own cause: In criminal contempt the Court acts as complainant, prosecutor and judge, even when the case is initiated by a bar association. Safeguards include the AG's gatekeeping, a Bench of at least two judges, personal service of notice, and the truth defence (since 2006).
  • Gatekeeping role of the AG: Both Union law officers appear aligned with the petition here. This invites a debate on whether the AG's consent is a genuine filter or a formality.
  • Political criticism of the judiciary: The respondents include an elected representative and a journalist. The Court's remark about litigants who criticise after seeking relief reflects institutional anxiety about outcome-based criticism. The counter is that a court's authority rests on public trust and transparency, not on deterrence.
  • Comparative: The UK abolished scandalising the court (2013). The Law Commission's 274th Report (2018) declined to follow that route for India and advised leaving the Act unamended, noting that the constitutional power exists independently of the statute.
  • Way forward: Define "scandalising" or restrict it to imminent obstruction of justice. Make "fair criticism" and good-faith public-interest defences explicit. Respond to allegations with transparency and accountability, not only with contempt.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The power of the Supreme Court to punish for contempt is both a constitutional and a statutory power. Examine whether the law on criminal contempt, particularly 'scandalising the court', strikes a proper balance between the dignity of the judiciary and freedom of speech."

Related topics

  • Art 19(1)(a)/19(2); Art 129, 142(2), 215; Art 76 (Attorney General)
  • Prashant Bhushan (2020); Law Commission reports on contempt; 2006 amendment
  • Judicial accountability and transparency (collegium, RTI and the judiciary)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 17 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs