BrainParrot

Necessary corrective

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 17 October 2026

Summary

  • The ECI has ordered a Special Summary Revision (SSR) of electoral rolls in 17 States/UTs, with 1 January 2027 as the qualifying date. The annual exercise was stalled last year by the Special Intensive Revision (SIR).
  • The editorial reads the SSR, the "special drive" to re-enrol people "left out", the cap on Form 7 objections and the release of searchable text-PDF rolls as an implicit admission that the SIR was flawed. It argues these steps fall short of accountability and calls for the CEC's resignation.
  • Manipur's SSR schedule and Telangana's SIR experience show the SSR (a corrective) and the SIR (the flawed exercise) in practice.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Election Commission, electoral rolls, free and fair elections

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections and electoral rolls in the ECI. Article 324(2): appointment of CEC/ECs by the President, subject to any law made by Parliament. Article 324(5): CEC removal like a Supreme Court judge.
  • Section 21(2), Representation of the People Act, 1950: revision of rolls. The Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 prescribe the forms and procedures.
  • Form 6 = new registration; Form 7 = objection/deletion; Form 8 = shifting/correction. An eligible citizen turning 18 on any of the four qualifying dates of a year can submit an advance Form 6 application.
  • Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023) – five-judge Bench; interim PM+LoP+CJI committee. The 2023 Act replaced the CJI with a Union Cabinet Minister.
  • Article 145(3): a Bench of at least five judges for substantial questions of constitutional interpretation.
  • Summary revision involves no house-to-house enumeration; intensive revision yields a de novo roll.
  • In an objection (Form 7) on the ground of non-citizenship, the onus of proof initially lies on the objector.

Data and details

  • SSR in 17 States/UTs; qualifying date 1 January 2027; the annual exercise was stalled last year because of the SIR.
  • The special drive to re-enrol "left out" electors uses the original Form 6 without the ancestry declaration. It drops mapping to older rolls and "logical-discrepancy" checks.
  • Form 7 objections have been capped after reports of bulk filings in several States. Searchable electoral rolls in text PDFs will go to parties and candidates.
  • States going to polls early next year: Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Uttarakhand.
  • West Bengal: appellate tribunals disposed of barely 3% of 38 lakh appeals, 22 lakh of them by deleted electors. They restored electors in 93% of the cases decided. The ECI has not said whether appellants can use the new drive or what happens to the tribunals.
  • Bihar: gender ratio fell from 907 (2024 Lok Sabha rolls) to 892 (SIR rolls). Young married women who were struck off must be allowed to re-enrol.
  • The Supreme Court upheld the SIR in May and is now hearing petitions on West Bengal, Delhi and the Commission's conduct.
  • The ECI's 2002-03 guidelines show a revision need not shift the burden onto the elector.
  • The two Election Commissioners objected on record to decisions of the CEC, and their questions remain unanswered.
  • The Anoop Baranwal appointment process was overturned by Parliament in 2023, and a two-judge Bench delivered a split verdict last month. The editorial demands that CEC Gyanesh Kumar resign.
  • ECI must report re-enrolments (after deletion) separately from fresh enrolments. House-to-house visits must ensure the burden does not fall on electors again.
  • Manipur's Chief Electoral Officer is Arun Kumar Sinha. The SSR qualifying date is 1 January 2027, with advance applications for 1 April, 1 July and 1 October 2027.
  • Polling-station rationalisation is to finish by 2 November, ten days before the integrated draft roll. Claims and objections are to be disposed of by 28 December, and the final roll is due 4 January 2027.
  • The Manipur SIR concluded in September. 1,32,456 names were deleted, leaving 19,60,620 voters.
  • Manipur has 60 Assembly seats: 40 in the Meitei-dominated Imphal and Jiribam valleys and 20 in the hills shared by Naga and Kuki-Zomi people. Elections are due by March 2027. In 2022 the BJP won 32 seats.
  • The SIR began 15 June. Pre-enumeration lasted 10 days. 3,38,26,446 enumeration forms were printed in duplicate for electors on the 2025 rolls. BLOs were to make at least three door-to-door visits.
  • Many urban BLOs set up camps in community halls and RWA buildings instead of visiting households. A pre-SIR mapping exercise was not carried into the enumeration phase.
  • ASDD (Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate) list: 73,39,235 voters, of whom 9,22,229 were classified deceased. The ERONET app used AI to flag similar entries, while verification of "absent/shifted" voters was left largely to BLOs.
  • The analysis found 53.97 lakh ASDD names across 104 of 119 constituencies (about one in four electors). Some booths had over 1,000 deletions against a State average of about 500. Only about 8.2% of removals were recorded as deaths.
  • Hyderabad district (15 constituencies): 19,41,444 names, with women 47.8% of deletions. Only 27.95 lakh of 47.36 lakh electors (59%) reached the draft rolls. About 3 lakh were "Untraceable" and 13.45 lakh "Permanently Shifted". Hyderabad, Ranga Reddy and Medchal-Malkajgiri accounted for about 60% of ASDD-listed voters.
  • Among Muslim-classified electors (identified by names), 19.8% of deletions were "Untraceable/Absent" against 16% for non-Muslims. 7.6% were "enrolled elsewhere" against 3.4%.
  • Form 6 applications during claims and objections were fewer than 6 lakh against 73 lakh deleted. 24,323 Form 7 applications were filed. Pre-filled applications seeking removal of Muslim voters were allegedly circulated by BJP-linked Booth Level Agents in Musheerabad, Bahadurpura and Goshamahal. CEO C. Sudharsan Reddy says deletions need documents or BLO verification.
  • Over 92 lakh electors classified "unmapped" or with "logical discrepancies" were asked to prove citizenship with one of 12 documents. Notices were auto-generated, and one cited an age gap of under 40 years for a grandfather born 1939 and grandson born 1999.
  • Muslims were 15.5% of "grandparent-age anomaly" cases. Persons with six or more siblings were 50.5% of cases. Polling station 91, Kukatpally got 1,061 notices; at station 103, Karwan, 601 of 678 (88.6%) went to electors with Muslim names; at station 33, Charminar, 98.3%.
  • Officials' defence: the 2025 roll matched the district population per the Census house-listing, against a national elector–population ratio of 67–73%, and multiple deadline extensions were given. Claims and objections closed 7 October.
  • Case: Jaseemunnisa Begum's husband, Abdul Kareem Malik, was marked dead and told to file Form 6. A technical glitch showed another elector's details for Mohammed Jani Miya.
  • An official involved in the 2008 roll/EPIC exercise says intensive revisions should be de novo, not tweaks to existing rolls. The first rolls were prepared in 1949.
  • Other Telangana details: the 2025 rolls used for enumeration were those published after the SSR. Women were the highest share of deleted electors in Bahadurpura, Chandrayangutta, Karwan, Yakutpura, Malakpet and Nampally. In Kukatpally, polling station 91 received 1,061 notices and station 235 received 1,057. The notice period ran beyond the 7 October claims deadline. Academic Padmaja Shaw called the process "a mockery of democracy" and demanded that the rolls be restored to their 2025 version and the revision restarted.

Static–dynamic linkage

Article 324 vests the superintendence, direction and control of the preparation of electoral rolls in the ECI. Section 21(2) of the RP Act, 1950 requires rolls to be revised before general elections to the Lok Sabha/Assemblies and annually by reference to a qualifying date. The ECI may also order a special revision for reasons recorded in writing.

The SIR/SSR dispute is about who bears the burden of proof for inclusion, the elector or the state. It also tests whether the ECI's plenary Article 324 power is exercised with procedural fairness. Free and fair elections are part of the basic structure, per Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975).

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission); Representation of the People Act; electoral reforms; free and fair elections. Also GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability.

Background primer

Election Commission of India (ECI)

What it is:
the constitutional body under Article 324 for superintendence, direction and control of elections and electoral rolls.
Founded:
constitutional body set up on 25 January 1950 (stable textbook fact).
Mandate:
preparing and revising electoral rolls and conducting elections to Parliament, State legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
Why it matters:
an impartial, insulated body to run elections independently of the executive.

Types of electoral roll revision

What it is:
in a summary revision there is no house-to-house enumeration; the existing roll is published as a draft and claims and objections are invited. An intensive revision produces a de novo roll, built on enumeration.

CEC and ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023

What it is:
the statute that replaced the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of ECs and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991.
Why it matters:
Parliament's response to the constitutional gap. Critics say it restores executive control, and petitioners contend it gives the executive a two-to-one majority.

Additional context

  • On 23 September 2026 a two-judge Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma split on whether the petitions against the 2023 Act need a larger bench. The matter was referred to the CJI to consider constituting a Constitution Bench after the 1:1 split. One judge cited Article 145(3) (a Constitution Bench of at least five judges). The other found no reference necessary because Anoop Baranwal had already settled that appointments must be free from executive influence.
  • On 6 May 2026 the Supreme Court declined to stay appointments of new Election Commissioners made under the 2023 law.

Mains dimensions

  • Burden of proof and inclusion: the SIR's mapping to old rolls and "logical discrepancy" checks effectively made electors prove eligibility. The special drive's use of plain Form 6 concedes that these tests were unnecessary. The 2002-03 guidelines are the benchmark for future intensive revisions.
  • Scale of exclusion and remedial gaps:
  • West Bengal tribunals decided only about 3% of appeals and restored 93% of those decided, which suggests wrongful deletions were widespread.
  • Bihar's gender ratio fell from 907 to 892, pointing to women being struck off.
  • Telangana's 73 lakh ASDD deletions compare with fewer than 6 lakh Form 6 filings.
  • The number of eligible voters actually left out of the process in Telangana remains unknown.
  • Algorithmic and procedural fairness: auto-generated notices with factual errors, AI-based flagging and apparent community-wise patterns (per the Sabar–CGF analysis) raise Article 14 and non-discrimination concerns. Officials dispute the inferences.
  • Misuse of Form 7: bulk and allegedly politically pre-filled objections were the reason for the cap. Safeguards require document or BLO verification.
  • Institutional independence: the two ECs' recorded objections are unanswered. The Baranwal vs 2023 Act contest, now headed to a Constitution Bench, goes to the legitimacy of executive-dominated appointments.
  • Way forward: report re-enrolments separately; make the drive house-to-house and let wrongly deleted appellants use it; fix tribunal capacity; restore the 2002-03 model for future intensive revisions; settle the appointment framework judicially.
  • Counterpoint: the Supreme Court upheld the SIR in May (per the editorial). The ECI would argue the exercise was needed to clean rolls of dead, duplicate and shifted entries. Its stated aim is that no eligible citizen is excluded while invalid entries are removed. Officials in Telangana also point to multiple deadline extensions and the claims-and-objections window.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Election Commission's powers over electoral rolls under Article 324 must be exercised with procedural fairness. In the light of the Special Intensive Revision and the subsequent Special Summary Revision, critically examine the issues of voter exclusion and institutional accountability of the Election Commission."

Related topics

  • Article 324, the RP Acts of 1950 and 1951, and the Conduct of Elections Rules
  • Anoop Baranwal (2023) and the Election Commissioner appointment debate; Goswami Committee (1990); Article 145(3) and Constitution Benches
  • Basic structure and free and fair elections; Article 326 (adult suffrage) and citizenship (Part II)
  • Delimitation and the Census (Telangana officials cited the Census 2027 house-listing survey), since both depend on credible rolls and demographic data

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 17 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs