BrainParrot

CJP leaders jailed for entering Jantar Mantar

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 15 October 2026

Summary

  • Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) leaders Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka were remanded to five days' judicial custody on Wednesday (14 October). They had been detained a day earlier, with 12 others, for entering Jantar Mantar, which Delhi Police had denotified as a designated protest site on Monday.
  • Two FIRs were filed: trespass, disobedience of official orders and obstruction of police on duty.
  • This came amid a fifth straight day of protests in Delhi against the SIR and CEC Gyanesh Kumar, and amid questions over the unpublished Section 163 orders.
  • The SC will be asked to hear a challenge to the denotification. The DMRC filed affidavits on Metro closures, and an editorial frames the protests as "Constitution-as-commons".

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Right to assemble/protest (Art. 19), police powers under BNSS, Delhi's governance

Key facts for Prelims

  • Art. 19(1)(a) (speech and expression) and 19(1)(b) (assemble peaceably and without arms); Art. 19(3) (restrictions: sovereignty and integrity, public order).
  • Art. 239AA(3)(a): Delhi Assembly cannot make laws on public order, police and land.
  • Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India (2018): protest is a fundamental right and can be regulated, not prohibited.
  • BNSS provisions in the news:
  • Sec. 126: an Executive Magistrate may require an undertaking to keep the peace for up to one year if a breach of the peace is apprehended.
  • Sec. 170: police may arrest without warrant to prevent a cognisable offence when it cannot otherwise be prevented.
  • Sec. 163: written prohibitory orders by an Executive Magistrate (successor to Sec. 144 CrPC). Sub-section (5) lets an aggrieved person seek rescission or alteration.
  • Sec. 172: detain or remove persons who ignore lawful directions.
  • Statutory two-month limit on Sec. 163 orders, extendable by the State Government to six months at most.
  • Delhi's three new designated protest venues: Ramlila Ground, Burari Ground, CBD Ground (East Delhi).
  • Delhi Police Standing Order No. 10/2018 governs protest guidelines at Jantar Mantar, Central Vista and Boat Club.

Data and details

  • Arrests and bail:
  • 14 people were detained on Tuesday (Das, Ranka and 12 others). Das, Ranka and Ajinkya Shinde were put under preventive arrest.
  • Das and Ranka were remanded to five days' judicial custody on Wednesday. Two FIRs were registered.
  • Shinde was released on a personal bond and ₹5,000 surety, with an undertaking to maintain peace for six months.
  • Police said the group reached the site through private premises, obstructed personnel and used social media to instigate others. Proceedings began before a Special Executive Magistrate.
  • Reactions: CJP founder Abhijit Dipke called it an "unofficial Emergency" and asked why members were jailed for waving the national flag. Rahul Gandhi (LoP, Lok Sabha) called jailing youth for a peaceful Tricolour protest an "act of cowardice" and said the INDIA bloc would "reclaim" Jantar Mantar. Youth organisations protested the jailings.
  • Day 5 of protests (Wednesday):
  • Protests have been continuing since 10 October, when the CJP called a demonstration against the SIR and the CEC.
  • Youth Congress, SFI and DYFI held separate marches. Left groups were on Firoz Shah Road, and the Youth Congress marched from Patel Chowk Metro Station towards Jantar Mantar.
  • Police detained protesters on Parliament Street and elsewhere. Protesters alleged being beaten. The number detained was not available at press time.
  • Slogans included "Vote chor, gaddi chhod". Traffic was disrupted.
  • Prohibitory orders (The Hindu):
  • The accessed Section 163 BNSS order was issued on 23 August by ACP Ajay Sharma and is in force until 21 October.
  • It covers the Parliament Street sub-division and expressly excludes a demarcated area on Jantar Mantar Road.
  • It prohibits assembly of five or more, meetings, processions, slogan-shouting and speeches.
  • Delhi Police sources would not confirm whether orders for other sub-divisions (Connaught Place, Chanakyapuri, Barakhamba Road) or for the Jantar Mantar area were public. They pointed to hoardings and announcements.
  • Former SC judge Abhay S. Oka said Sec. 163(5) implies a statutory mandate to publish the orders, and hoardings and announcements are not enough. Advocate Abhinav Sekhri said access has long come only through RTI, and that "cyclostyled" orders are reissued as soon as the two-month limit expires.
  • SC petition on denotification:
  • Filed by Swaty Singh (advocate Akanksha Mehra), registered and numbered on Wednesday, against the Union government and the Delhi Police Commissioner. It may be listed on 26 October.
  • It says relocation pushes dissent "out of sight and out of mind". The three alternative sites are on the outskirts, far from Parliament, the SC, ministries and public offices.
  • It says no SOP for accessing the new venues has been issued, though the denotification took immediate effect during the ongoing protest.
  • DMRC affidavits (SC):
  • The Delhi Metro was "fully functional" on 10 October, with 32 lakh passengers against about 58 lakh on a normal second Saturday.
  • Entry/exit was regulated at 45 of 303 stations, and 258 stations (over 85%) were fully operational. DMRC claimed zero reduction in train trips.
  • It attributed the lower ridership to public caution.
  • Petitioners M.A. Baby (CPI(M)) and advocate Shailendra Mani Tripathi say the closures violated the SC's 9 October order requiring proportionate movement restrictions.
  • Editorial (Kalpana Kannabiran, Vienna Centre for Advanced Studies) — opinion:
  • She says a new language of citizenship is emerging from "criminal dispossession" of homes, savings, education and now voting rights.
  • She criticises judges for stressing "lawful protests" and "judicial discipline" while declining bail to Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam.
  • She calls "andolanjeevi" an extra-statutory category of criminal.
  • She proposes "Constitution-as-commons" and says courts should learn from "constitutional jurisprudence from the streets", and that the Constitution now "resides" in the streets.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Art. 19(1)(b) guarantees assembly "peaceably and without arms". Art. 19(3) permits reasonable restrictions in the interest of sovereignty and integrity or public order.
  • The SC's test (Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan, 2018) is that protests may be regulated but not prohibited outright. The state must balance protesters' rights with residents' rights.
  • Preventive criminal-procedure powers (BNSS Secs. 126, 163, 170, 172) are legitimate but must be proportionate and published. Prohibitory orders that are secret defeat the right of any aggrieved person to challenge them.
  • Because Delhi Police reports to the Union Home Ministry, protest management in the capital is directly a Union responsibility.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental Rights (Art. 19(1)(a), (b); Art. 19(3) reasonable restrictions; Art. 21); Delhi's special status (Art. 239AA); preventive police powers; GS3 – Internal security (public order)

Background primer

Right to protest and the legal framework in Delhi

What it is:
protest is a facet of the freedom of speech and assembly. In *Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India* the SC held that peaceful protests are a fundamental right under Art. 19(1)(a) and (b), subject to reasonable restrictions.

Additional context

  • Denotification: Delhi Police named Ramlila Ground, Burari Ground and CBD Ground in East Delhi as new protest venues, and the Police Commissioner de-notified Jantar Mantar. This was based on the recommendations of a committee set up by the Union Home Ministry. Police said detailed revised SOPs for the three new venues would be issued separately.
  • Historical significance: Jantar Mantar hosted the 2011 India Against Corruption movement, the 2012 Nirbhaya protests, the 2019 anti-CAA and Art. 370 protests, the 2023 wrestlers' protest and the 2026 NEET-UG protests.
  • Related case law: In Re: Ramlila Maidan Incident (2012) protected peaceful assembly against arbitrary police action. Amit Sahni v. Commissioner of Police (2020) held that protests cannot indefinitely occupy public spaces or block traffic corridors.

Mains dimensions

  • Constitutional balance: The MKSS (2018) formula is regulate, not prohibit. Denotifying the only central, visible site (with three outlying alternatives and no published SOP) tests whether regulation has become exclusion.
  • Transparency of prohibitory orders: Orders accessible only through RTI, reissued as cyclostyled copies, undermine the remedy in Sec. 163(5). Justice Oka's view ties publication to the right to challenge.
  • Preventive powers: Secs. 126/170/172 BNSS allow pre-emptive arrest, detention and security bonds. Safeguards are proportionality, necessity, magistrate scrutiny and non-weaponisation (the article records a ₹5,000 bond and judicial custody for entering a site).
  • Federal/administrative angle: Delhi Police is under the MHA (Art. 239AA), so the Centre is directly accountable for protest policy in the capital. The denotification followed a Home Ministry committee.
  • Proportionality in mobility curbs: The DMRC figures (45 of 303 stations; 32 lakh against 58 lakh) show a dispute over what counts as proportionate, with the Court's 9 October order as a benchmark.
  • Competing narratives: Police emphasise trespass, obstruction and instigation. Protesters and the Opposition cite the flag-waving and the "Emergency" charge, and the editorial reads the events as a citizenship movement. An answer should present both while applying legal tests.
  • Link to the cause: The protests concern the SIR and the CEC's legitimacy (see the companion notes), so the right to protest is itself a channel for electoral accountability.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The right to protest is a fundamental right but can be reasonably restricted. In light of recent developments around Jantar Mantar in Delhi, discuss the constitutional and legal framework governing protests and how to balance public order with the freedom of assembly."

Related topics

  • Art. 19(1)(a)/(b) and Art. 19(2)/(3); Art. 21
  • BNSS vs CrPC (Secs. 126, 163, 170 vs Secs. 107, 144, 151; Sec. 172 is a new provision with no CrPC equivalent); BNS Sec. 189 unlawful assembly
  • Art. 239AA and Delhi's governance; police reforms
  • Ramlila Maidan (2012), Amit Sahni (2020)
  • Judicial approach to bail and "lawful protest" (Umar Khalid, Sharjeel Imam, as mentioned in the editorial)
  • Companion notes: "Illogical reasons" (SIR), "A split verdict..." (CEC appointment law)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 15 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs