Insurance reforms: Need for a balanced approach
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 12 October 2026
Summary
- In September 2026 IRDAI issued a consultation paper, "Recalibrating Economics of Insurance Distribution" (dated 23 September 2026). It proposes the most radical distribution-side reforms in recent years: lower expense-of-management (EoM) caps, a new three-category distribution architecture and revised commission norms.
- Every stakeholder except policyholders has raised serious concerns. Insurers are privately lobbying hard, and the Insurance Brokers Association of India (IBAI) has formally opposed the proposals and written to the PM.
- The article's own headline asks for a "balanced approach". It treats the clash as one between a customer-centric cost-cutting agenda and an industry that says the evidence does not support the remedy.
Key facts for Prelims
- IRDAI is a statutory body under the IRDA Act, 1999. Section 14 lists its duties, powers and functions, Section 25 provides for the Insurance Advisory Committee, and Section 26 gives regulation-making power. The Insurance Act, 1938 is the principal Act.
- Composition: Chairperson, up to five whole-time and up to four part-time members (Section 4), appointed by the Centre. Head office: Hyderabad. IRDAI was formed in April 2000.
- Expenses of Management (EoM) = operating expenses plus commission/remuneration, capped by regulation.
- GWP (Gross Written Premium) vs GDPI (Gross Direct Premium Income): the proposal shifts general insurers' EoM base from GWP to domestic GDPI. Life insurers move to a company-level EoM basis linked to GDPI.
- Proposed distribution entities: Insurance Distribution Entities (IDEs), Insurance Distribution Persons (IDPs) and Market Infrastructure Institutions (MIIs). The guiding principle is "same structure, same functions, same norms".
- Consultation paper: "Recalibrating Economics of Insurance Distribution", released 23 September 2026.
- IBAI = Insurance Brokers Association of India (President: Narendra Bharindwal).
- Regulatory arbitrage: exploiting differences in rules across entities doing the same function.
Data and details
- Life insurers' EoM limit: company-level basis linked to GDPI, proposed at 15% within two years and 12.5% within five years.
- General insurers' EoM limit: from 30% of GWP to 20% of GDPI within five years, through progressive annual reductions.
- IBAI counter-evidence: total EoM in general insurance fell from 28.2% of premium in FY23 to 26.5% in FY25, while premium grew about 13% a year. The reported rise in commission largely reflects reclassification of payments earlier booked under other heads, which the consultation paper itself acknowledges.
- IBAI, citing the paper's own figures, says costs are high mainly in forced-sale channels where the policyholder has no choice:
- loan-linked credit life pays 42–45%
- dealer-controlled motor pays up to 75%
- Independent brokers and agents average 17–18%, and brokers serving corporate clients 6–11%. IBAI says the cap nevertheless hits every channel, with the customer's own broker lowest.
- IBAI wrote to the PM on 2 October 2026, warning of job losses, lower growth and reduced competition.
- IBAI's ask: no commission or expense-limit regulation should be notified without a published impact assessment covering policyholders, employment, public sector insurers and foreign investment. It also wants the 2023 framework to run until its scheduled 2028 review.
- An anonymous general-insurer MD & CEO told businessline that the dialogue with the regulator is ongoing, objections have been submitted, and industry resistance is the strongest to any regulatory change so far.
- Notably absent: insurers have not yet officially responded publicly. Policyholders are the only stakeholder group not objecting.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Insurance is a regulated financial service. The regulator caps how much of the premium an insurer can spend on running costs and commission, the "expenses of management". This protects policyholders and keeps premium costs sensible.
- The tension is that tight caps lower prices and curb mis-selling, but can squeeze intermediaries, jobs and the incentive to push insurance penetration.
- Good regulation-making follows due process: draft regulations, public consultation and impact assessment. IBAI invokes this when it demands a published impact assessment before anything is notified.
- The "regulatory arbitrage" the paper wants to remove means different entities doing the same function under different rules. The paper's "same structure, same functions, same norms" principle targets this.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Economy: Banking/insurance and financial-sector regulation; mobilisation of resources; GS2 – Statutory/regulatory bodies (IRDAI's quasi-legislative power via regulations and consultation).
Background primer
Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI)
- What it is:
- A statutory body formed under an Act of Parliament, the IRDA Act, 1999, for overall supervision and development of the insurance sector. The Insurance Act, 1938 is the principal Act governing the sector.
- Founded:
- An interim Insurance Regulatory Authority was set up in 1996, the IRDA Act was enacted in 1999, and the IRDA was formed as an autonomous regulator on 19 April 2000. The Act also ended the exclusive privilege of LIC in life insurance and of GIC and its subsidiaries in general insurance. The exclusive privilege of the Corporation to carry on life insurance business ceased on commencement of the 1999 Act.
- Members:
- A Chairperson, not more than five whole-time members and not more than four part-time members, appointed by the Central Government. The head office is at Hyderabad.
- Mandate:
- The duty to regulate, promote and ensure orderly growth of the insurance and re-insurance business (Section 14). Functions include registering and regulating insurers, protecting policyholders' interests, licensing and setting norms for intermediaries, regulating investment of policyholders' funds, ensuring solvency margin, and ensuring rural and vulnerable-section coverage.
- Why it matters:
- To protect the interests of policyholders and to regulate, promote and ensure the orderly growth of the insurance industry. The shift from a state-monopoly market to a competitive one needed an independent regulator. The Malhotra Committee recommended this.
Expenses of Management (EoM) framework
- What it is:
- A ceiling on the operating expenses plus commission an insurer may incur. EoM covers all expenses in the nature of operating expenses of the insurance business. For life insurers it also includes commission and remuneration to agents and intermediaries.
- Why it matters:
- The stated objective was to give insurers flexibility to manage expenses and commission within overall limits, to benefit policyholders and improve insurance penetration.
Additional context
- The consultation paper also covers market conduct, transparency and the use of digital infrastructure.
- Commission disclosure: Insurers and large distribution entities would have to disclose commission policies and structures simply. Specified commercial policies would carry commission disclosures, so customers know the distribution cost built into pricing.
- Anti-mis-selling measures: The paper proposes tighter curbs on mis-selling and compulsory bundling of insurance with other financial products. These include documenting customer needs and suitability, bringing direct and indirect remuneration within the definition of commission, and prohibiting volume-linked or reward-linked incentives for bank and NBFC staff selling insurance. It also proposes linking the individual seller's identity to each policy, putting mis-selling incidents in the public domain, and allowing commission claw-backs.
- Consultation timeline: IRDAI's press-release listing shows an extension of the last date for feedback on the distribution-reforms paper to 31 October 2026.
- Baseline commission data (IRDAI Annual Report 2022-23): Life insurers paid ₹42,322 crore as commission in 2022-23, and the commission expense ratio rose to 5.41 per cent from 5.18 per cent in 2021-22.
Mains dimensions
- Policyholder-centric logic: Lower distribution cost should lower premiums and curb mis-selling. IRDAI frames the goal as a customer-centric, competitive, efficient, transparent ecosystem. Policyholders are the only group not objecting.
- Evidence-vs-remedy dispute: IBAI argues the data show costs already falling (28.2% → 26.5%, FY23–FY25) and that the "rise in commission" is a reclassification artefact. It says the problem lies in forced-sale channels (credit life at 42–45%, dealer-controlled motor up to 75%). IBAI adds that the proposed remedy nevertheless caps every channel, including independent and corporate brokers whose commissions are already low (17–18% and 6–11%), with the customer's own broker lowest. A targeted fix (bancassurance/dealer tie-ups) versus a blanket cap is the core policy question.
- Employment and competition: IBAI warns of job losses and reduced competition. Counter-view: structural simplification into IDEs/IDPs/MIIs and easing of entry and capital requirements could widen entry, and removing curbs on non-insurance business could offset lost commission.
- Regulatory process and independence: Reaching the PM over the regulator's head raises questions on due process, regulatory impact assessment and stability. The 2023 framework runs to a 2028 review, so the issue is how often rules should change. The pushback shows the risk of regulatory capture, but a regulator must also resist lobbying.
- Growth vs protection trade-off: The 2023 regulations were framed around improving insurance penetration. Over-tight caps may reduce distributors' incentive to sell to under-served customers, while loose caps leave room for mis-selling.
- Way forward: Publish an impact assessment, calibrate caps by channel and product, use phased glide paths (as already proposed), mandate commission disclosure, and link the cap to outcomes such as persistency and claim settlement.
Possible Mains question
**GS3 (Economy), 15 marks:** "IRDAI's proposed distribution reforms seek to lower insurers' expenses of management and restructure intermediaries. Examine the rationale for the reforms and the concerns raised by industry stakeholders. How can the regulator balance policyholder protection with insurance penetration and employment?"
Related topics
- IRDA Act 1999 and Insurance Act 1938; Insurance Laws (Amendment) Act, 2015
- Insurance penetration and density; FDI in insurance; LIC and public sector general insurers
- Bancassurance, mis-selling and the insurance Ombudsman; regulatory impact assessment
- Other financial-sector regulators (RBI, SEBI, PFRDA) and regulatory coordination (FSDC)
Topics: GS3Economy
All current affairs of 12 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs