BrainParrot

House panel asks NTA to hold entrance exams in CBT mode

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 10 October 2026

Summary

  • The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Education tabled a report in Rajya Sabha on reforming the National Testing Agency (NTA). It recommends moving flagship exams such as NEET-UG to Computer-Based Test (CBT) mode, tighter logistics, and a national registry to bar compromised vendors.
  • In related NEET-UG 2026 paper-leak developments, the Centre denied claims that protesters' biometric data was shared on national criminal databases. The SC refused to review its order quashing FIRs against protesting students.

UPSC relevance: GS2 Polity/Governance — Education governance, parliamentary committees, exam integrity; GS2 — Rights (privacy, protest), judiciary; GS3 — Technology in policing

Key facts for Prelims

  • NTA: autonomous, non-statutory society under the Societies Registration Act, 1860; created by Cabinet decision in November 2017; under the Ministry of Education.
  • Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024 — up to 10 years' jail and ₹1 crore fine for organised syndicates.
  • Parliamentary Standing Committee on Education, tabled its report in Rajya Sabha (Friday).
  • NAFIS: managed by NCRB (Ministry of Home Affairs); CCTNS: NCRB project.
  • Art. 142: "complete justice" power (used to quash the FIRs).
  • Rajya Sabha MP A.A. Rahim is the petitioner challenging FRT/biometric surveillance at Jantar Mantar.

Data and details

  • Recommends CBT for major national tests, specifically NEET-UG.
  • Question banks: large, diverse and continuously updated, generating dynamic randomised question sets. Relying on standard or static sets is called a severe integrity risk.
  • Hybrid encrypted delivery of papers right up to the start of the exam.
  • Multi-session CBT in independent shifts. Normalisation across sessions must be independently audited, mathematically robust, and explained to students beforehand.
  • Content curation primarily by IITs, AIIMS, IIMs. Strict background checks on paper setters to rule out conflicts (e.g. faculty ties to private coaching).
  • Warns against over-reliance on unverified private vendors.
  • To bridge digital gaps (Tier-2/3, rural): use mid-sized IT labs (100–200 nodes) at public universities, government engineering colleges, polytechnics and accredited schools.
  • Over 40% vacancy among key permanent NTA posts.
  • Avoid invasive physical searches that cause undue anxiety.
  • Create a centralised, inter-agency digital registry of blacklisted and penalised vendors. Vendors blacklisted by one body or State often win contracts from others because records are isolated.
  • It opposes Rahim's "sweeping" claim that biometric data of "thousands of protesters" are on national criminal databases.
  • It said blanket allegations of indefinite retention, storage and sharing are not based on foundational facts. Privacy/free-speech claims need a factual foundation.
  • Rahim had not identified a single biometric record unlawfully collected at Jantar Mantar, sent to NCRB, and retained in breach of law. An "omnibus" assertion about NEET-UG protesters cannot replace proof.
  • His prayer for deletion from NAFIS, CCTNS and allied databases is "wholly omnibus". Deletion would require identifying the record category, database, creating authority, related proceedings and the retention regime.
  • A nodal officer would consider destruction pleas and check whether the biometrics are linked to other active cases.
  • Claims of an interface to share biometrics with private entities are, at best, vague.
  • Rahim challenged use of Facial Recognition Technology (FRT) and biometric surveillance at public demonstrations, alleging illegal retention and passing to third parties.
  • The SC refused to review its 1 September direction quashing FIRs against students and youth in the NEET-UG 2026 paper-leak protests. They had faced a police crackdown on 20 July in the capital.
  • The FIRs were quashed using Art. 142. CJI Surya Kant said the Court does not use Art. 142 in every situation. It did so out of concern for the students' parents and futures, and so they would not be entangled in court cases.

Static–dynamic linkage

Departmentally-related Standing Committees scrutinise ministries and make recommendations. These are persuasive, not binding, but they frame reform. The recurring NTA leaks reveal a governance gap: a non-statutory agency, heavy reliance on outsourced vendors and contractual staff, and inadequate permanent capacity. The protest-related items test the State's response to youth dissent: data retention, surveillance, and the limits of criminal law, and the Court's use of Art. 142 to give "complete justice".

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Governance: statutory/non-statutory bodies, role of Parliament's committees, education policy, transparency and accountability; GS2 – Polity: Art. 21 (privacy), Art. 19 (protest), Art. 142; GS3 – S&T/Security: biometric and facial-recognition surveillance.

Background primer

National Testing Agency (NTA)

What it is:
An autonomous and self-sustained premier testing organisation, registered as a society, to conduct entrance examinations for higher educational institutions.
Founded:
The 2017-18 Budget announced it and the Union Cabinet approved it in November 2017. It was meant to relieve CBSE, AICTE and other agencies of conducting these exams and to bring in reliability and standardised difficulty.

Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024

Radhakrishnan Committee (High-Level Committee of Experts)

NAFIS, CCTNS and NCRB (for the surveillance plea)

Additional context

  • The report: A PIB release says the Department-related Standing Committee on Education, Women, Children, Youth and Sports (chair: Mukul Wasnik) presented its 382nd report, "Reforms and Strengthening of the NTA", on 9 October 2026. It records that only 23 of 39 sanctioned NTA positions are filled, a vacancy of 41%. This matches the over-40% figure in the article.
  • From that release: The Committee recommended amending the 2024 Act so district administrations withhold permission for rallies, processions or gatherings on examination days.
  • It also said contracting with any blacklisted entity should be considered under the 2024 Act, and that the Committee made the same recommendation in its 371st report.
  • It recommended that the NTA immediately refocus on admission tests to higher education institutions alone, in line with its mission statement.
  • The Committee was told that the majority of reforms have been implemented, since 60 of the 101 recommendations related to 2025 and 2026.
  • On exam mode: the Committee noted the Radhakrishnan panel (HLCE) recommended a phased transition to CBT and broadly concurs. It observed that most NTA exams (JEE-Main, UGC-NET, CUET) already run as CBT and that NEET-UG is an outlier in relying on pen-and-paper. It said the HLCE's recommendation of 1,000 secure government CBT centres must be implemented on a clear, phased timeline.
  • Government follow-up: GKToday reports that the Centre has announced NEET will be conducted as a CBT from 2027. It also reports that the Nandan Nilekani-led exam-reform task force, constituted in July 2026, has had its tenure extended to January 2027.
  • Court follow-up: In hearing pleas on the NEET-UG 2026 paper leak, the SC directed the Union Education Secretary to file an affidavit on implementing the Radhakrishnan recommendations as nuanced by the Nandan Nilekani Committee.

Mains dimensions

  • Why CBT. Eliminating physical paper handling (printing, transport, storage) removes the commonest leak points. Dynamic randomised sets reduce the value of a leaked paper. Multi-session design suits scale but raises normalisation fairness concerns, hence the audit demand.
  • Implementation realism. Access gaps in Tier-2/3 and rural areas, and the sheer scale of test-taker numbers, make a phased transition necessary. The 100–200-node public lab suggestion is an attempt to reconcile CBT with equity.
  • Institutional capacity is the real gap. With 41% vacancy in key posts (23 of 39 positions filled), a non-statutory body relies on outsourcing. Technology without capacity transfers risk to vendors, which is why the panel wants a national blacklist registry.
  • Integrity vs candidate dignity. Panel advises against invasive searches, a recognition that security measures can themselves harm candidates.
  • Conflicts of interest. Background checks for paper setters address coaching-industry entanglements.
  • Protest, privacy and proportionality. The surveillance plea tests whether protest policing involves unregulated biometric retention. The government says no specific unlawful record has been shown. Courts will look for specific proof of unlawful collection and retention, and the Home Ministry points to a nodal-officer process for destruction pleas.
  • Judicial compassion vs rule of law. Quashing FIRs under Art. 142 shows a pragmatic, welfare-oriented use of the power; critics may say it bypasses ordinary criminal procedure. The CJI's statement frames it as exceptional.
  • Way forward: give the NTA a statutory footing and permanent staff; implement the remaining Radhakrishnan recommendations; legislate retention rules for police biometric databases; phase CBT with infrastructure.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Recurring paper-leak controversies have shaken confidence in the National Testing Agency. Examine the institutional and technological reforms needed to restore the credibility of national entrance examinations."

Related topics

  • Statutory vs non-statutory bodies; role of Parliamentary Standing Committees (DRSCs)
  • Public Examinations Act, 2024; Radhakrishnan Committee; NEP 2020 on common entrance tests
  • Right to privacy (Puttaswamy), proportionality; data protection law; facial recognition in policing
  • Art. 142 and its limits

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 10 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs