Appeals for return to voter list should be heard first: SC
Source: The Hindu, 10 October 2026
Summary
- The SC orally suggested that West Bengal voters seeking inclusion in the electoral roll should be heard first. Pending appeals against inclusion could wait. These voters were excluded in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR).
- ECI statistics show the Appellate Tribunals are overwhelmed.
- Separately, the ECI capped the number of Form 7 (deletion) objections an individual can file, after reports of bulk filings.
- The Congress cited an opinion piece and a Reporters' Collective report to allege that SIR deletes genuine voters.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324: ECI's superintendence, direction and control of elections and rolls. Art. 326: elections to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies are on the basis of adult suffrage.
- SIR is conducted under Section 21(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1950.
- Form 6 = enrolment of new elector; Form 7 = objection to inclusion/deletion of name.
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: a claim or objection not lodged within the specified period, form or manner is liable to be rejected by the ERO.
- Para 11.3.2(ii) of the Manual on Electoral Rolls, 2023: bulk claims and objections by an individual (including those sent by post) are not to be entertained.
- ECI limits announced Friday: an individual elector may file at most 10 Form 7s during the claims and objections period, and at most 5 per month during continuous updation. These apply online and physically. Earlier, physical Form 7s had no limit.
- BLAs of recognised parties during SIR: at most 50 forms per day to the BLO before draft publication and 10 per day after.
- Appellate Tribunals (West Bengal): 19 in number. ERONet is the ECI software named in the Congress allegation.
Data and details
- More than 22 lakh voters excluded in SIR on grounds such as "logical discrepancies" filed appeals challenging their exclusion.
- 16.10 lakh appeals were filed against inclusion, and a total of 38.31 lakh appeals were filed in the tribunals.
- 37.05 lakh of the 38.31 lakh appeals are pending before the 19 tribunals. Only about 3% have been disposed of.
- Petitioner Prasenjit Bose (Congress) argues that, at the current pace, clearing the backlog will take over 12 years.
- Counsel: Gopal Sankaranarayanan (for Bose); Prashant Bhushan and Neha Rathi (for five disentitled voters). They asked that these voters be allowed to vote in the municipal polls scheduled for November 2026.
- CJI Surya Kant said the Court is already working on pending appeals and will find a middle path: inclusion appeals will be taken first.
- The Hindu reported bulk Form 7s filed in the names of BJP leaders from Rajasthan, Gujarat, West Bengal and Karnataka.
- The ECI said bulk Form 7s on unsubstantiated grounds inconvenience the elector objected to and add to the workload of field-level officials.
- He shared an opinion piece in The Hindu saying SIR violates the letter and spirit of Art. 326 and disenfranchises crores.
- He called SIR a "mischievous instrument" of the CEC, and said it was meant to perpetuate the rule of two leaders.
- Citing the Reporters' Collective, he claimed 2.96 crore voters were removed from UP's rolls in SIR, the highest among the States covered.
- He questioned the addition of 16 lakh voters through Form 6, alleging their details were not made public despite requests.
- He alleged that 85,854 pre-filled Form 7 copies were generated through ERONet after the claims and objections deadline expired.
Static–dynamic linkage
The electoral roll is the legal basis of the right to vote. Art. 324 gives the ECI superintendence, direction and control over preparing rolls. Art. 326 guarantees adult suffrage to eligible citizens. The tension in the news is that purity of rolls (removing ineligible names) must not defeat inclusiveness, so erroneous deletions need a fast remedy. A backlog of appeals nullifies that remedy in practice, which is why the Court said inclusion appeals will be taken first, even as petitioners press for excluded voters to vote in the municipal polls scheduled for November 2026.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI, Art. 324), adult suffrage (Art. 326), Representation of the People Acts 1950/1951, electoral reforms, dispute-redressal mechanisms.
Background primer
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- A comprehensive door-to-door verification and update of electoral rolls by the ECI.
Forms
Additional context
- Tribunals: On 10 March 2026 the SC directed the Calcutta High Court Chief Justice to constitute special appellate tribunals for West Bengal's voter-roll appeals. The ECI constituted 19 Appellate Tribunals, one headed by a former Chief Justice and the rest by former High Court judges. The tribunals cease to exist once all appeals are disposed of.
- The SC invoked its Art. 142 powers in this matter, amid allegations and counter-allegations against both State officers and ECI-deputed officers.
- On 1 April 2026 the SC directed that each adjudication decision record explicit reasons for inclusion or exclusion, and said removal from the roll does not permanently extinguish the right to vote.
- Earlier voting rule (April 2026 order): The Court said the mere pendency of appeals does not entitle excluded persons to vote. The SC directed the ECI that, where tribunals decided appeals by 21 April or 27 April 2026 (the cut-offs for the two polling phases), the orders were to be given effect through a supplementary revised electoral roll.
- Scale then: More than 34 lakh appeals had been filed in West Bengal as of 11 April.
- Unique category: Justice Bagchi observed that the "logical discrepancy" category in West Bengal's SIR was unique to the state.
- Roll size: The ECI put the state's electorate at over 7.04 crore after revision, from 7.66 crore earlier, a fall of more than 61 lakh names.
Mains dimensions
- Remedy delayed is remedy denied. With 37.05 lakh of 38.31 lakh appeals pending and about 3% disposed of, the appellate design fails to protect franchise before upcoming polls. The SC's "inclusion first" triage is a pragmatic prioritisation.
- Weaponisation of the objection process. Bulk Form 7s (reported in BJP leaders' names) and the allegation of 85,854 pre-filled Form 7s generated after the deadline show how a protective safeguard can be gamed. The ECI's 10/5 caps respond to this but come only after bulk filing was reported.
- Procedural fairness. The Court earlier insisted on reasons for deletion (see 2b). "Logical discrepancy" as a ground, unique to West Bengal, raises transparency and arbitrariness concerns.
- Dual vulnerability. Opponents argue SIR over-deletes (UP: 2.96 crore claimed), while ECI argues it ensures purity. Both ends of the Art. 326 balance (inclusive suffrage and clean rolls) must be honoured.
- Institutional trust. The ECI is the sole authority over rolls under Art. 324. Opposition allegations such as Jairam Ramesh's turn on whether it is seen as neutral.
- Way forward: time-bound tribunal disposal, a public list of deletion reasons, safeguards against mass objections (done partly through caps), and independent audit of ERONet-generated forms.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls aims at purity but has triggered concerns of disenfranchisement. Discuss the constitutional basis of the ECI's powers and suggest safeguards to protect the right to vote."
Related topics
- Art. 324–329; RP Act 1950 (rolls, ss.16, 21–23) vs RP Act 1951 (conduct, disputes)
- Qualifying dates and continuous updation of rolls; role of BLO/BLA/ERO/CEO
- Art. 142 (complete justice) and tribunal design
- Right to vote: constitutional/legal right, not fundamental
- Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 10 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs