Flawed by design, exclusionary in impact
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 9 October 2026
Summary
- The editorial argues that the ECI under CEC Gyanesh Kumar has reversed its 75-year "inclusion" mission through the SIR. It says a deferential Supreme Court judgment of 27 May 2026 emboldened the ECI. It calls the SIR flawed in design and exclusionary in impact.
- Counter-narrative, same issue: 42 former Supreme Court and High Court judges signed an open letter. They say there is a "calculated campaign driven by vested political interests" against the ECI. They name no party.
- Ground-level SIR items, same issue:
- Haryana's CEO office is running a 3-day drive (7–9 October) to dispose of pending SIR notices, using special camps and house-to-house document collection.
- In Karnataka, the Vijayapura police registered an FIR against MLA Basanagouda Patil Yatnal for allegedly creating false death certificates to delete voters.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections and electoral rolls vests in the ECI. Article 326: universal adult suffrage (citizen, 18+, not disqualified).
- Section 21(3), RPA 1950: special revision "for any constituency or part of a constituency"; it begins with a non-obstante clause overriding Section 21(2).
- Section 16 RPA 1950 disqualifies a non-citizen from being enrolled in the electoral roll.
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 govern ordinary revisions.
- Form 6 is the application for new voters; per the article it is now also used by deleted voters seeking re-entry. Form 7 is used for objections to or deletion of entries (as in the Vijayapura case).
- Officials and tools named: Booth Level Officer (BLO), Booth Level Agent (BLA), Electoral Registration Officer (ERO, the statutory authority on eligibility), ERONet (central database), and the ECI's Manual on Electoral Rolls (2023).
- Lal Babu Hussein (1995), a three-judge Supreme Court ruling: a name on the roll is presumed valid and can be removed only after notice and a hearing. The ECI's Manual also incorporates this.
- Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023) concerns the appointment committee for the CEC and ECs.
- The CEC is removable like a Supreme Court judge; ECs only on the CEC's recommendation (Article 324(5)).
- The 2023 Act gives the Selection Committee as PM + Union Cabinet Minister + LoP in Lok Sabha.
Data and details
- Scale of deletion:
- 13.37 crore names struck off at the draft stage across 30 States/UTs in three phases.
- 65 lakh in Bihar; 6.57 crore in the 12 States/UTs of Phase 2; 6.15 crore in Phase 3 (final rolls not yet published).
- Deletion rate: 8.3% (Bihar) → 12.9% (Phase 2) → 17% (Phase 3). Delhi 32.8%; Telangana 21.7%.
- Net deletions in Phases 1 and 2 were about 6.2 crore even after names were added back.
- Delhi:
- The draft roll has 97.54 lakh electors, barely above the 94.95 lakh who voted in the Feb 2025 Assembly election.
- In 24 of 70 constituencies the draft roll has fewer electors than the number who voted.
- A further 19.33 lakh electors are flagged for "logical discrepancies".
- The ECI has ordered a "special drive" to enrol those "left out". The article reads this as an implicit admission.
- West Bengal:
- 60 lakh names were flagged; judicial officers deployed by the Supreme Court struck off 27 lakh.
- Appellate tribunals restored electors in 93% of cases, about one lakh names.
- By early September, only 1.22 lakh of 38+ lakh appeals were disposed of (3.2%).
- 16.1 lakh appeals were filed to remove electors whom judicial officers had found eligible. Who authorised these on the ECI's behalf is unanswered.
- SABAR Institute estimate: 65% of those deleted after adjudication for "logical discrepancies" were Muslims, against about 27% of the State's population.
- Tamil Nadu: the final roll of 5.67 crore is about 33 lakh short of the projected 6.02 crore.
- Bihar: more women than men were struck off, especially those aged 18–29 recorded as "permanently shifted". The gender ratio in the final SIR rolls is 892, down from 907 in the 2024 Lok Sabha rolls.
- Logical-discrepancy flags: spelling mismatches, more than six voters linked to one ancestor, and parent–child age gaps outside 15–45 years.
- Historical context:
- The first general election (1951–52) had to enrol about 17 crore electors, many illiterate.
- Turnout among the poor in India is higher than among the rich.
- The SIR requires electors to trace themselves or a parent to the last intensive revision, held over two decades ago.
- Court timeline: the Supreme Court ruled on 27 May, after Phase 2 ended and Phase 3 was notified.
- Internal dissent: Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi recorded at least 14 objections between Oct 2025 and Aug 2026.
- One was that Form 6 was altered without amending the rules, asking applicants whether they or their parents or grandparents appeared on the "last SIR" roll.
- Between them they formed a majority in the three-member Commission but did not use it to stop these decisions.
- Related-story data:
- Former judges' letter: 42 signatories, including former SC judges Hemant Gupta and Pankaj Mithal and former HC Chief Justices B.C. Patel, Subhro Kamal Mukherjee and Permod Kohli.
- Haryana drive: 7–9 October.
- Vijayapura: complaint by vegetable vendor Abdul Razak Bagwan at Jala Nagar police station. He alleges he and at least seven others were falsely declared dead. Yatnal was expelled by the BJP in March 2025. On 7 October the Vijayapura unit of Mata Kavalu Samiti presented persons "passed off as deceased" at a Bengaluru press meet.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Article 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of electoral rolls and elections in the ECI.
- Article 326 gives every citizen aged 18+ who is not disqualified the right to be registered as an elector.
- The RPA 1950 and the Registration of Electors Rules 1960 govern roll preparation and revision.
- The core tension is between roll "purity" (removing dead, shifted, duplicate and ineligible entries) and universal adult franchise (no eligible citizen excluded).
- The proportionality test and the burden of proof (who must prove eligibility) are the doctrinal fault-lines.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI); Representation of the People Act; free and fair elections; judicial review and the role of the Supreme Court. Also GS2 — Governance (transparency and accountability of institutions).
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- A constitutional authority under Article 324 for superintendence, direction and control of the electoral process for Parliament, State Legislatures, and the offices of President and Vice-President. Its powers include preparation, revision and maintenance of electoral rolls.
- Founded:
- Constituted on 25 January 1950 in conformity with the Constitution. A multi-member commission was introduced in 1989. Since October 1993 it has been a three-member body (CEC plus two ECs).
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- enumeration is shifted onto electors, who must trace themselves or a parent to the last intensive revision or produce documents. This inverts the Manual's de novo, house-to-house procedure.
Additional context
- Bihar baseline: The ECI ordered the Bihar SIR on 24 June 2025 under Article 324 and Section 21 of the RPA, with 1 July 2025 as the qualifying date. The draft roll of 1 August 2025 had 7.24 crore electors, about 65 lakh fewer than the earlier 7.9 crore. Bihar SIR orders barred removal of any name from the draft without a speaking order from the ERO/AERO after an enquiry and a fair opportunity.
- The Supreme Court's 27 May 2026 reasoning (ADR v. ECI):
- The Court held that the ECI can conduct SIR under Article 324 read with the RPA 1950 and its Rules.
- It found the SIR met the three proportionality requirements, treating a statewide SIR as proportionate to the scale of the problem.
- It held that the ECI may examine citizenship questions for roll inclusion. This does not divest anyone's claim to citizenship, which the competent authority decides under the Citizenship Act.
- It rejected the argument that "special revision" can be done only in isolated constituencies.
- Other deletion data point: In Bihar, 1,087 objections alleging foreign infiltrators were raised. Only 390 were accepted for formal verification, and just three people were identified as non-citizens.
Mains dimensions
- Inversion of the burden of proof:
- The Manual (para 9.3.1) defines intensive revision as de novo enumeration by visiting every house, and para 7.4.2 gives "probative value" to presence on the earlier roll, with the onus on the objector.
- The SIR shifts enumeration to the elector and presumes ineligibility until documents prove otherwise, resembling a citizenship test. Illiterate or migrant electors who did not return forms were dropped even if they had voted.
- Re-entry and auditability: Deleted voters must apply via Form 6 as if new. Returning and first-time voters therefore cannot be told apart in published figures, which prevents a proper audit.
- Algorithmic exclusion: Arbitrary "logical discrepancy" rules (spelling, ancestor linkage, age gaps) flagged lakhs. The West Bengal appeals data (93% restored on appeal; 3.2% of appeals disposed) show a high error rate and a justice delay that effectively disenfranchises people through the election.
- Centralisation vs statutory authority: ERONet overrides EROs, who are the statutory authorities on eligibility, and State officials cannot see central changes. This is an accountability and federalism concern.
- Missing baseline: The Census is delayed, so the ECI has no firm population denominator to check rolls. Gaps such as Tamil Nadu's 33 lakh shortfall stay unexplained.
- Differential social impact: The gender ratio fell in Bihar, and the West Bengal data show a disproportionate Muslim share of deletions. Both raise equality and inclusion concerns.
- Judicial deference:
- The Court read Section 21(3), an exceptional and targeted power, as allowing a statewide exercise free of the 1960 Rules.
- It applied only a "manifestly excessive" test, not a least-restrictive-means inquiry, and sidestepped Lal Babu Hussein.
- It required "widespread or systemic" disenfranchisement without saying what would suffice.
- Counterpoint: the Court itself found the SIR proportionate and the least restrictive option, so this is a live legal contest.
- Institutional independence: Dissent by two Election Commissioners (14 recorded objections) was not turned into a majority decision. This raises the question of how far the 2023 appointment framework secures independence.
- The other side:
- The 42 former judges call the campaign against the ECI "destabilising". They say allegations of "vote theft" are made at press conferences, not courts, and that sworn declarations sought by the Commission are not filed.
- They also say EVMs are blamed only after defeats, and that election officials face threats.
- The Vijayapura FIR shows that Form 7 can itself be abused to delete voters, which supports robust verification and accountability on both sides.
- Way forward (editorial):
- Halt the SIR and audit rolls finalised so far before any further deletions.
- Return to door-to-door verification by BLOs.
- Let States going to the polls soon use pre-SIR rolls updated with fresh enrolments.
- Have the Court revisit its judgment on review or before a Constitution Bench.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Election Commission has historically treated universal adult franchise as a promise to be fulfilled. Critically examine whether the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls balances the integrity of rolls with the constitutional guarantee of inclusion. Suggest reforms."
Related topics
- Article 324 and the ECI's plenary powers and their limits (Mohinder Singh Gill, T.N. Seshan line of cases)
- Representation of the People Acts, 1950 and 1951: roll preparation versus conduct of elections
- Article 326 and universal adult franchise; the right to vote as a constitutional or statutory right
- Proportionality doctrine and burden of proof in rights cases
- Citizenship Act 1955 and who decides citizenship; Census and delimitation
- CEC and Other ECs Act 2023 and independence of constitutional bodies
- Electoral reforms: EVM/VVPAT, ECINET, Aadhaar–EPIC linkage
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 9 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs