BrainParrot

Are legal guarantees insufficient in abolishing untouchability?

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 9 October 2026

Summary

  • In August 2026, certain Hindu groups in Uttarakhand performed a "purification" ritual at the site where Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge, a Dalit, had addressed a rally. This triggered a national conversation on untouchability.
  • Opposition Congress leaders accused the ruling BJP of practising caste discrimination. The Uttarakhand BJP chief defended the ritual as meant to "cleanse" the area of the ideas Kharge was espousing. After sustained pressure from opposition leaders and civil society, an FIR was registered.
  • The interview asks whether legal guarantees alone can end untouchability. Rodrigues stresses social conscience and Ambedkar's "notions in the mind". Wadekar questions reliance on criminal law and argues for civil remedies and localised dispute resolution.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity (Fundamental Rights, Article 17; SC/ST protections), GS1 — Society (caste), GS4 — Ethics (social conscience)

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 17 abolishes untouchability in any form. Enforcement of any disability arising from it is a punishable offence. It comes under the Right to Equality (Articles 14–18).
  • Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955: originally the Untouchability (Offences) Act, 1955, renamed in 1976 (Section 15A: State Government duty).
  • SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989: Special Courts (Exclusive Special Courts added by the 2015 Amendment), relief and rehabilitation of victims. Administered by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment.
  • Poona Pact, 24 September 1932, Yerwada Jail (Pune): joint electorates with reserved seats for Depressed Classes. It followed the Communal Award (August 1932).
  • POSH Act: the sexual harassment of women at the workplace law that the interview cites as a civil-regime example. Its enforcement runs through complaints committees with a lower burden of proof than criminal law.
  • Gram Sabha: the village-level body cited in the interview as a localised dispute-resolution forum (a Panchayati Raj institution).
  • Related constitutional provisions: Article 15(2) (no disability on access to shops, wells, public places), Article 46 (promotion of educational and economic interests of SCs/STs).
  • Ambedkar's phrase "notions in the mind" (as cited by Rodrigues) refers to caste attitudes held by both Dalits and non-Dalits.

Data and details

  • Trigger event: August 2026 "purification" ritual by certain Hindu groups in Uttarakhand at the site of a rally addressed by Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge. An FIR was registered only after a sustained campaign by Opposition leaders and civil society. A photo caption shows Uttarakhand Pradesh Congress leaders staging a sit-in at the CM's residence, demanding action against those responsible for the ritual conducted at Ramlila Maidan, Dehradun (caption dated 7 September).
  • Political reactions: The Opposition accused the ruling BJP of caste discrimination. The Uttarakhand BJP chief said the ritual was meant to cleanse the area of the ideas Kharge espoused.
  • Interviewees: Valerian Rodrigues is Professor Emeritus at St Aloysius (Deemed to be) University, Mangalore, and a former professor at Mangalore University and JNU. Disha Wadekar is a Supreme Court litigator with over ten years' experience, a Fulbright Scholar and an LL.M. graduate of Columbia Law School.
  • Time frame: Rodrigues compares the situation with about 100 years ago, "from the time of the Poona Pact". Practices that have declined include denying access to public wells and institutions, and violence on Dalit workers in the countryside. He adds that we do not know what would have happened without the legal regime.
  • Period of reform effort: Rodrigues refers to attempts at "reopening" Indian society from 1939 to 1949 that were not carried forward.
  • Notably absent/frozen (negative facts): After Independence the legal regime came but social conscience "remains frozen". Inter-dining and inter-marriage have disappeared from public spaces. There is very little intermingling across castes, even in urban areas. The Indian setting today is "not conducive" to social reopening.
  • Reactionary backlash: Wadekar cites the Reservation Hatao Andolan and the "how dare you sit next to me / share my privilege / mobilise" mindset as responses to Dalit social mobility after the Constitution.
  • Courts as social actors: Adjudicators are social actors as well as judicial ones. A superimposed criminal-law regime does not change judges' mindsets, so harsher punishment can become counterproductive.
  • Burden of proof: Criminal law demands proof beyond reasonable doubt, which Wadekar says should not be undone. Criminal provisions have huge deterrence value, but she says they will not eliminate all atrocities, only some. Civil remedies carry a lower burden. She cites the POSH Act as precedent.
  • Local forums: Sharia adalats (used by Muslim women who felt unable to approach courts) and Gram Sabhas as dispute-resolution centres.
  • Everyday segregation: The "normalcy" of separate Anganwadis and water taps for Dalits. Urban planning often makes Dalits congregate in particular spaces.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Static concept 1: Article 17. It abolishes untouchability and makes any disability arising from it a punishable offence. It sits within the Right to Equality (Articles 14–18). It is both a rights provision and a duty on the State, backed by the statutes below.
  • Static concept 2: Limits of law versus social change. The Ambedkar approach (abolish the practices, rights-based, political) is set against the Gandhi approach (change social conscience). Rodrigues presents these as two dimensions of the problem and says legal guarantees are necessary but not adequate.
  • Static concept 3: Criminal vs civil remedies. Criminal law needs proof beyond reasonable doubt and is only as effective as its social adjudicators. Civil or administrative regimes, such as the POSH Act, carry a lower burden.
  • Static concept 4: Reactionary atrocities. Rising Dalit social mobility can provoke backlash. This is a sociological point about law, mobility and dominant-group resistance.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental Rights (Articles 14–18), Article 17; statutory mechanisms for SCs/STs; GS1 – Society: caste and social empowerment; GS1 – History: Poona Pact, Ambedkar–Gandhi debate; GS4 – Ethics: social attitudes and values.

Background primer

Article 17 – Abolition of Untouchability

What it is:
"Untouchability" is abolished and its practice in any form is forbidden. Enforcement of any disability arising out of untouchability is an offence punishable in accordance with law.
Founded:
Part of the Constitution as adopted (in force 1950). Ambedkar chaired the Drafting Committee.
Why it matters:
To end the social hierarchy of purity and pollution by constitutional fiat, and to empower Parliament to punish its practice.

Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 (PCR Act)

What it is:
A law enacted to enforce the constitutional mandate to abolish untouchability under Article 17.
Mandate:
It prescribes punishment for practising untouchability and protects civil rights. Section 15A places a duty on State Governments to make the rights arising from the abolition of untouchability available to affected persons.

Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (PoA Act)

What it is:
An Act to prevent atrocities against SC/ST members, with Special Courts for trial and provision for relief and rehabilitation of victims. Exclusive Special Courts, a chapter on victims' and witnesses' rights and a two-month trial target were added by the 2015 Amendment Act (in force 26 January 2016).
Why it matters:
The PCR Act was seen as weak against violent caste atrocities, so a stronger punitive law was needed. The interview's question is whether even this punitive route suffices.

Poona Pact (24 September 1932)

What it is:
An agreement between Gandhi and Ambedkar, signed at Yerwada Central Jail, Pune on 24 September 1932 over the electoral representation of the Depressed Classes. Madan Mohan Malaviya signed for caste Hindus and Ambedkar for the Depressed Classes. Gandhi, who was imprisoned, gave consent.
Why it matters:
It combined two approaches: Ambedkar's political approach and Gandhi's social approach. This is the same Ambedkar–Gandhi dual the interview opens with.

Additional context

  • Victim protection under the PoA Act (as amended). The Act as amended requires States to set up enough courts to dispose of cases within two months as far as possible, and trials are to be completed within two months of the charge-sheet. Investigation and charge-sheet are due within sixty days. Special Courts must provide protection, travel and maintenance expenses, socio-economic rehabilitation and relocation to victims and witnesses. This shows the statute already has procedural and rehabilitative elements, not just punishment.
  • Article 17 as a positive duty. Article 17 is read as both a negative prohibition and a positive command requiring the State to take active steps against untouchable practices. The Supreme Court has also held that it can be enforced against non-state actors such as private citizens (Sukanya Shantha v. Union of India, 2024). This links to Rodrigues's call for state-led social reopening.
  • Gandhi's social-conscience route after the Pact. Gandhi founded the All India Anti-Untouchability League on 30 September 1932, later renamed Harijan Sevak Sangh, and began the weekly Harijan in February 1933.
  • Ambedkar's critique. In his 1945 book What Congress and Gandhi Have Done to the Untouchables, Ambedkar argued that joint electorates reduced the political independence of elected Depressed Class representatives.

Mains dimensions

  • Law is necessary but not sufficient (Rodrigues): The legal regime has checked the most visible practices (access to wells, public spaces and institutions, rural violence) and given Dalits and allies legal tools, but with very limited resources against huge odds. Conscience has not changed. Rodrigues identifies two dimensions, Ambedkar's (abolish untouchable practices) and Gandhi's (change social conscience), and says the legal regime alone leaves the second unaddressed.
  • Re-situating law (Wadekar): Law should not be treated as a perfect instrument. Legal consciousness is shaped by everyday experience and by interaction with caste, patriarchy and Brahmanism. Formal rule of law broke the "law of caste" and was emancipatory, but may not be enough to annihilate caste.
  • Backlash and new forms of atrocity: Traditional atrocities have been joined by reactionary ones tied to Dalit mobility (the Reservation Hatao Andolan). The Uttarakhand "purification" incident is a contemporary instance. The FIR came only after sustained pressure.
  • Limits of the carceral model: Stricter punishment has not delivered the expected results because adjudicators carry caste mindsets. Beyond-criminal options include civil remedies, lower-burden regimes (POSH) and localised dispute resolution (Gram Sabhas).
  • Social reopening and the "common": Rodrigues argues for revising textbooks and teacher training, urban planning that avoids caste enclaves, and ending separate Anganwadis/water taps. This is a role for the state and for non-state actors.
  • Evaluation and way forward: Combine enforcement of the PCR and PoA Acts (including speedy trials) with education, integrated public spaces, civil remedies and community forums. Ethical dimension: collective responsibility for attitudes, not only punishment of individuals.

Possible Mains question

**GS2/GS1, 15 marks:** "Despite constitutional abolition and a dedicated statutory framework, untouchability persists in new and subtle forms. Critically examine the adequacy of legal guarantees and suggest non-legal measures to address caste-based discrimination."

Related topics

  • Articles 14, 15, 16, 17, 21 and 46; horizontal application of Fundamental Rights
  • SC/ST Prevention of Atrocities Act amendments and Supreme Court rulings; National Commission for Scheduled Castes
  • Poona Pact; Communal Award; Ambedkar–Gandhi debates (Annihilation of Caste)
  • POSH Act, 2013 and alternative dispute resolution; Gram Sabha (Panchayati Raj) and Nyaya Panchayats
  • Reservation policy and social mobility; NCRB data on crimes against SCs

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 9 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs