SC to examine plea on CEC appointment law split verdict
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 8 October 2026
Summary
- The Supreme Court agreed to examine, and then decide whether to hear, an application seeking recall of the 23 September split verdict. That verdict came in the challenge to the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.
- The ground is non-disclosure. Justice Satish Chandra Sharma did not reveal, across several hearings, that his son is a standing counsel for the ECI.
- The application was mentioned orally before CJI Surya Kant by Sr Adv Gopal Sankaranarayanan. It was filed by Naman Sherstra.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324(2) is subject to parliamentary law on the appointment of CEC and ECs. Article 324(5) gives the CEC removal protection equal to a Supreme Court judge.
- The 2023 Act replaced the CJI with a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM in the Selection Committee. The challenge is aimed at Section 7 of the Act.
- Section 8 lets the Selection Committee consider names beyond the Search Committee's five.
- The Anoop Baranwal case (2023) is a five-judge Constitution Bench judgment.
- The 2023 Act repealed the 1991 Act. Tenure is six years or age 65.
- Article 145(3) concerns the minimum five-judge bench for substantial constitutional questions.
Data and details
- The split verdict was delivered on 23 September 2026. The recall application was heard on Wednesday (7 Oct 2026) by CJI Surya Kant.
- The Bench was headed by Justice Dipankar Datta (lead judge), with Justice Satish Chandra Sharma as the puisne judge.
- Justice Datta declined a reference to a five-judge Bench. Justice Sharma favoured it. Both passed a common order asking the CJI to allocate the case to a Constitution Bench.
- Justice Datta's separate opinion observed that the 2023 law was prima facie wrong to ignore Baranwal. Baranwal had included the CJI as a neutral member of the PM-led panel.
- The application objects to the common order. It does not specifically challenge Justice Datta's separate opinion.
- The alleged non-disclosure is that Justice Sharma's son is a standing counsel for the ECI, not revealed "during multiple court proceedings".
- The plea seeks recall of Justice Sharma's opinion on the reference question.
- The Court has so far agreed only to examine whether to hear the recall plea. It has not heard it on merits.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Article 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of elections in the ECI. Article 324(2) says the CEC and ECs are appointed by the President, subject to any law made by Parliament.
- For over seven decades no such law existed, so appointments followed the advice of the Union executive. The Supreme Court then filled the gap (Anoop Baranwal), and Parliament legislated over it in 2023.
- The tension is Parliament's legislative power under Article 324(2) against the Court's constitutional-bench directions. Petitioners argue about whether Parliament can override or modify a Constitution Bench ruling by legislation.
- The recall plea adds a second, judicial-ethics layer: whether a judge must disclose a connection with a party or institution before him. This rests on the natural-justice principle that no one should be a judge in their own cause, and on the perception of bias.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional/statutory bodies (ECI); Judiciary – separation of powers, structure and functioning; Prelims Polity – Election Commission, Article 324.
Background primer
Election Commission of India & its appointment framework
- What it is:
- the constitutional body that conducts elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President (Art. 324).
- Founded:
- established with the Constitution, on 25 January 1950 (observed as National Voters' Day).
- Members:
- a CEC and such number of ECs as the President fixes. The President periodically fixes the number of ECs. Article 324(5) protects the CEC from removal except in the manner and on grounds of a Supreme Court judge.
- Mandate:
- preparation of electoral rolls and conduct of elections.
- Why it matters:
- an independent umpire for free and fair elections, insulated from the executive.
CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023
- What it is:
- the statute under Art. 324(2) governing appointment and service conditions of the Commission. It repeals the 1991 Act. The Bill was introduced in Rajya Sabha on 10 August 2023.
- Why it matters:
- the government says it implements the Art. 324(2) mandate. Critics say it overrides the Court's interim arrangement.
Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2 March 2023)
- Why it matters:
- the need to take appointments out of the exclusive control of the executive, to ensure free and fair elections.
Additional context
- Gyanesh Kumar was appointed CEC under the 2023 Act. One member of the selection committee objected that the process bypassed the Baranwal guidelines.
- A two-judge bench referred the challenge to a larger Constitution Bench. One judge found no larger-bench reference was needed, as the five-judge Baranwal ruling had already held that ECI appointments must be free from executive influence.
- The judge favouring reference cited Article 145(3), which provides for Constitution Benches on substantial questions of constitutional law.
- Earlier reform proposals favoured a neutral, CJI-inclusive process. The Tarkunde Committee (1975) and the Law Commission's 255th Report (2015) recommended a PM–LoP–CJI collegium. The Goswami Committee (1990) recommended that the President consult the CJI and the Leader of Opposition.
Mains dimensions
- Separation of powers: can Parliament undo the basis of a Constitution Bench ruling by changing the committee's composition? Baranwal's interim panel had the CJI, and the 2023 Act replaced him with a minister nominated by the PM.
- Executive majority: petitioners say the Selection Committee gives the executive a two-to-one majority and undermines ECI independence. PRS notes that the 2023 Act keeps the Committee's recommendations valid despite a vacancy in it. Since the PM and the Cabinet Minister posts cannot be vacant, only the LoP seat can fall vacant, so the Committee could then consist only of government members.
- Judicial propriety and disclosure: the plea targets a judge's non-disclosure of a family link to a party's institution. Related ideas are recusal, bias, "justice must be seen to be done", and the credibility of a court deciding the independence of another constitutional body.
- Institutional trust: a split verdict, a reference to a larger bench and now a recall plea together delay settlement of how the umpire itself is chosen.
- Way forward: restore the CJI's role for a neutral element, or add a retired SC judge or the Lok Sabha Speaker. Also codify disclosure norms for judges.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The independence of the Election Commission depends as much on how its members are chosen as on their security of tenure. In light of the Anoop Baranwal judgment and the 2023 Act, critically examine the issues in the appointment of the CEC and ECs."
Related topics
- Article 324, the Election Commission's powers, and removal of the CEC vs. ECs
- Constitution Benches (Art. 145(3)) and judicial review of legislation that overrides a judgment
- Judicial recusal, conflict of interest and judicial accountability (cross-link GS4 probity)
- ECI's electoral-roll powers — see also the SIR/Form 6 note (Bengal)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 8 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs