Govt. opposes mercy plea of convict in CM’s assassination
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 8 October 2026
Summary
- The Centre told the Supreme Court it opposes the plea of death-row convict Balwant Singh Rajoana to commute his sentence over delay in deciding his mercy petition. ASG K.M. Nataraj said that, given the prevailing situation in Punjab, taking a decision now would not be conducive.
- A bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath said that, since the Centre insists on opposing the plea, it will hear the matter on merits. The case is listed for 28 October.
- The petition has been pending before the President since 2012.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 72: President's pardoning power, including for death sentences and court-martial cases. Article 161: Governor's power in State matters.
- Pardon vs. commutation vs. reprieve vs. remission vs. respite.
- Shatrughan Chauhan (2014): delay and mental illness as supervening circumstances; 14-day notice before execution.
- BNSS 2023 Section 472 governs mercy-petition procedure: a 30-day filing window, the Centre's recommendation to the President within 60 days of receiving State comments and records, no time limit for the President, and Section 472(7) barring appeals.
- Article 21 (right to life) is the basis for the delay doctrine.
- Babbar Khalsa is the militant group Rajoana belonged to. The SGPC (Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee) filed the mercy petition on his behalf.
- Article 32 (writ jurisdiction) is the route by which a convict approaches the Supreme Court.
Data and details
- Rajoana has been in custody for 30+ years. His mercy petition has been pending before the President since 2012. He approached the Supreme Court in 2020 over the delay.
- Beant Singh was killed in a suicide bombing outside the Punjab and Haryana Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh, on 31 August 1995. The bomber, Dilawar Singh, and 17 others also died.
- Special court death sentence: July 2007. Punjab and Haryana High Court upheld it in 2010. Execution was fixed for 31 March 2012 and stayed after the SGPC submitted a mercy petition.
- 2019: the Union Home Ministry announced a decision to commute the sentence as part of measures linked to the 550th birth anniversary of Guru Nanak Dev. There was no subsequent decision on his mercy plea.
- The Centre and the CBI opposed relief earlier, citing national security and law and order in Punjab. On 3 May 2023 the Supreme Court declined to commute the sentence and left the plea to the competent authority.
- Bench: Justices Vikram Nath, Sandeep Mehta and Aparesh Kumar Singh. The hearing is on 28 October, after ASG Nataraj sought time to prepare.
- The Centre's stated stand: "considering the prevailing situation" in Punjab, a decision is not conducive.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Art. 72 empowers the President to grant pardon, reprieve, respite or remission, or to suspend, remit or commute sentences. Article 72(1) expressly covers cases where the sentence is a death sentence.
- In practice, clemency is exercised by the government and not by the President in his discretion.
- Clemency is not beyond judicial review. It is reviewable if exercised in bad faith, on irrelevant grounds, or in violation of constitutional principles (Epuru Sudhakar, 2006).
- Delay is the key doctrinal link. In Shatrughan Chauhan (2014) the Supreme Court held that unexplained delay in disposing of a mercy petition is a ground for commuting a death sentence to life imprisonment. The Court held that this ground applies to all types of cases, including terror offences (TADA), departing from the Bhullar (2013) approach.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Powers of the President/Governor (Arts. 72, 161), judicial review, Fundamental Rights (Art. 21); Prelims Polity – Pardoning power; GS4 – Case-study material on justice, mercy and public safety.
Background primer
Mercy petition / executive clemency (Arts. 72 and 161)
- What it is:
- a constitutional remedy outside the judicial process. It can be exercised after all legal remedies are exhausted.
- Founded:
- from the Constitution (1950). The idea of the pardoning power comes from the UK tradition.
- Why it matters:
- to correct errors and apply compassion where judicial process cannot. It acts as a corrective to errors in the judicial process.
Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014)
Additional context
- In May 2023 the Court noted the Home Ministry's conclusion that deciding the mercy plea then would compromise national security, and said the decision to defer amounted to declining the plea for the time being.
- A ForumIAS explainer reports that the Home Ministry accepted the plea in 2019 but the decision could not be implemented because the Council of Ministers did not send the file to the President.
- A 2025 three-judge bench judgment of the Supreme Court (Criminal Appeals 2831–2832 of 2023) held that undue, unexplained and inordinate delay in executing a death sentence entitles the convict to approach the Court under Article 32. It also held that the gravity of the crime alone cannot excuse the agonising delay. The Court added that no fixed period of delay makes a sentence inexecutable, and that each case turns on its facts.
- Section 472(7) of the BNSS says no appeal lies in any court against the President's or Governor's order under Article 72/161, and that the decision-making is not to be inquired into by any court. This is in tension with the limited judicial review recognised in Epuru Sudhakar.
Mains dimensions
- Executive delay and Article 21: more than 14 years since 2012 with no decision is the kind of delay Shatrughan Chauhan treats as a possible ground for commutation. The Centre's opposition, however, rests on security and law and order.
- Relevance of grounds: whether "prevailing situation in the State" is a legitimate consideration for deferring a decision is a judicial-review question, since clemency based on irrelevant considerations can be set aside (Epuru Sudhakar).
- Contradictory executive signals: the 2019 announcement of commutation (a national-occasion gesture) versus the present opposition. This raises consistency and arbitrariness issues.
- Aid-and-advice reality: although Art. 72 speaks of the President, the Council of Ministers decides. The delay therefore lies with the elected executive. Courts examine delay, not the merits of mercy.
- Victim and societal interests: an assassination of a sitting Chief Minister, the terrorism context and the argument that the gravity of the crime is an aggravating factor.
- Federal/Punjab sensitivity: the SGPC's role and the politics of Sikh militancy-era cases. Clemency timing intersects with law-and-order assessments.
- Way forward: time-bound disposal norms (BNSS Section 472 is a step), transparent reasons for deferral, and a clear separation of security assessments from legal merits.
- GS4 angle: retribution vs. reform, mercy vs. public safety, and the ethics of prolonged uncertainty for a death-row convict.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Prolonged delay in deciding mercy petitions raises constitutional concerns under Article 21. Discuss the evolution of judicial approach to executive clemency and suggest reforms."
Related topics
- Articles 72, 161, 32, 21; Epuru Sudhakar, Kehar Singh and Shatrughan Chauhan
- Death penalty jurisprudence: Bachan Singh ("rarest of rare"), supervening circumstances
- BNSS 2023 provisions on mercy petitions
- Governor's vs. President's clemency powers; aid and advice of the Council of Ministers
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 8 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs